Monday Mar 02, 2009

Yeshiva Boy: Extraordinarily confusing times

Posted by Nathaniel Rosen
Comments: 12
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

There must be something in the water here, because my peers and I have caught a bug: suddenly we are confused about what our futures hold and what our tasks in the great challenge of life are. Some might say such confusion is characteristic of our age, but I tend to think that the confluence of events occurring in the world around us has created a "perfect storm" of doubt and uncertainty unique to my generation.  And this realization has bred utter confusion and the need for a reevaluation of our futures.

A few weeks ago, one of my friends here told me that he has decided to make aliya.  He said that the return to Zion was such an expansive theme in Judaism that he would be somewhat of a hypocrite were he to remain in the Diaspora while Jews had a sovereign state of their own.  He didn't know why he had been suddenly overcome by such an epiphany or why he was willing to abandon the life he knew; he couldn't explain exactly why, after eighteen years of an extremely comfortable life in Canada, he would decide to forgo what would probably be a prosperous  future there.  Another friend told me last night that he suddenly had no idea what his future held.  He had always thought he would go to college and make a comfortable living, have a few kids and live in a picturesque house, but something has shattered that perception. Now he is considering staying in Israel for another year and perhaps enrolling in college here.

I find myself thinking about my own future as well. As I listen to the rain patter outside my bedroom window, I realize that this year is almost over, and that life - real life - is about to start, and I have no idea what I want to do or what I want to study.  Normally that wouldn't seem like a big problem for an eighteen-year-old, but something is making me think it's not okay to just float along and see where life and my interests take me.  I suddenly feel like I need to act.

Maybe it's the fact that I have always felt fortunate, almost too fortunate, which is spurring my confusion. I've been fortunate to have been born into my family, fortunate to have had the opportunities afforded to me, fortunate to have had things come easily to me.  That I have been given so much for no apparent rhyme or reason is bothersome. It bothered me acutely after my summer job in construction, when I worked with people who were quite unfortunate, and it made me feel like I had to do something to help others less fortunate than myself. That feeling has intensified here in Israel. When I look around and think about the fact that I can take a year and study here, I feel selfish.

Maybe it's the times that are to blame. The threats to the Western world and the Jewish people are great: Iran speaks of wiping Israel off the map and America is reeling from an economic recession of historic proportions. Surely one might ponder the future given the perilous state of world?

Or maybe it's the fact that despite these personal and global difficulties, everything in my life is still going "according to plan." I am going to finish my year in Israel and spend the next four years in an Ivy League university, in what will be the realization of the American academic dream. I will have thoroughly enjoyed my year here, and will go on to study that which interests me, find a job and live a run-of-the-mill, happy life. Maybe it's that dissonance that is bothersome?

Or maybe, just maybe, it's something much more profound. Maybe my confusion and my rethinking of my future stems from a question that challenges all three of my previous assumptions: Given all I have been blessed with and all the opportunities I have been afforded, and given the world's plethora of problems, is it okay to just be the normal person I had always thought I would be? Or does the time and place in which I live demand something greater of me - something extraordinary?

Maybe the realization we can't live ordinary lives because we don't live in ordinary times is what confuses my generation. Or then again, maybe it's just the age.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   Aaron, Jerusalem, Tuesday Mar 03, 2009
As an "Unfortunate person" who has long felt resentment of the wealthy kids I have seen in Jerusalem who mostly never had to work and never seemed to have any problem bigger then which flavor of starbucks to drink, I am very happy to see this essay. I'm glad you're feeling a bit of discomfort and I'm glad you feel a need to actually do something more consequential then the "comfortable" life you'd always planned. I hope you find something to do which will live up to your new standards and I'll be rooting for you and for your peers who I hope are also feeling the same way. Welcome to reality!
2  |   Adina Kutnicki,Israel, Tuesday Mar 03, 2009
Some advice-the confusion you are feeling surely is a confluence of events, the times that we live in, and the natural confusion of those on the cusp of adulthood. One point worth considering might help your confusion. It sounds as if you are conflicted between the known comforts you have at home, and the unknowns of life in Israel.It appears that aliyah is pressing on your mind. Why not have both? Do what my dear sons did.They took advantage of their Ivy league educations, then promptly made aliyah.Come to Israel, newly Ivy minted degree in hand, and join your people.Best of both worlds.
3  |   HJ, Tuesday Mar 03, 2009
Interesting. Thanks for posting this, I've always felt this way and still do. I wanted to make aliya during my year in seminary, but after college and meeting my husband, I'm living in the US, married with a baby, feeling something more needs to be done. I have the same sene of impending "something," considering what's happening around the world, like we're on the verge of something. The granddaughter of survivors, I grew up obsessed with the holocause. It's surreal to see antisemitism alive again, I almost don't believe it. It could just be my age, or it could be events, or perhaps both.
4  |   dovid Monsey NY, Wednesday Mar 04, 2009
Don't you have a rebbi? Doesn't your yeshiva have a mashgiach? Don't you have a Rosh Yeshiva? Your questions are legitimate, but your expecting to get answers to existential issues from unknown people, most likely ill-qualified or at best unqualified people is dumb. Go to your rebbis.
5  |   Non-Believer US, Wednesday Mar 04, 2009
Young people have the impression that the future exists for them. Such is not the case. The future does not exist but is yet to emerge. What takes shape always remains unknown to us until it comes into being. There is also the false consciousness of bearing an imagined weight upon one's shoulders: feeling the imperative of making decisions that bear significantly on one's destiny. Such is rarely if ever the case. Our own trajectory remains indifferent to our vascilations and is molded as much by uncontrolled events as our own decisions the latter being mere responses to circumstances
6  |   mark obermeister, Wednesday Mar 04, 2009
interesting confusion!
7  |   Father of 4 non-insipid adults, Potomac MD, Wednesday Mar 04, 2009
Why this dichotomy between "aliyah" and "comfort"? This aint the 1950s. You can be comfortable living in Israel.. But worrisome is the fact that you are so young and yet sound so old, one whose whose parents must be very happy with him, because he has never questioned their values, has always done what's expected of him. That's abnormal. It makes for a nice, yet insipid adult. People who contribute to civilization tend NOT to do what's expected of them.. I suggest you take another year off and travel by backpack around the world. You'll thank yourself for it.
8  |   bannister USA, Wednesday Mar 04, 2009
Deciding to be part of the problem. Rather than the solution. Every person deciding to move to occupied Palestine is making a statement of belief they own the Palestinians land. You will go and put the bit more pressure towards the development of your enemies capacity to remove you by force.
9  |   Moish, Atlanta, Wednesday Mar 04, 2009
For the rest of your life, you will never ever forvie yourself if you do not 'seize the moment', and take a part in the Israeli experiment
10  |   JK, New Zealand, Monday Mar 16, 2009
Nathaniel, I found your comments very interesting and something springs to my mind immediately. I visited Israel last year and I'm so glad I did. There is something very special and compelling about Israel and I believe you have discovered it. Whether you believe in God or not, it is God calling His people back to their land and something deep inside you is responding (like to your friends also). You want to be part of Israels future, whether good or bad. Go for it!
11  |   Student, UMass Amherst, Monday Mar 23, 2009
Dear Nathaniel, College in America is a boring experiment. Israel is a worthwhile one. I suggest you choose Israel.
12  |   Roddy Frankel, Thursday Jun 18, 2009
Nate, make alliyah as soon as possible. Commit to the decision in your own mind, and let your friends know about it. When you date, let your girlfriend know of your intentions. Life has a way of making decisions for you. That is why it is important to take control of your life as soon as possible.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
Your Blog/Website
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Yeshiva Boy What do you get when you take thousands of Jewish teens from around the world and send them to Israel to study at yeshivot and seminaries for the year before they attend university? A year of maturation, religious growth, and a greater attachment to Israel? Or one giant party? One student reflects on the lessons, challenges and surprises of his gap year in Israel.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. Time to be put out to pasture?
    Posted in In the Trenches by David A. Harris
    Sunday Nov 01, 2009
  2. Hillary's Middle East saga
    Posted in A Point of View by Abraham Foxman
    Thursday Nov 05, 2009
  3. The end of anti-Semitism?
    Posted in Guest Blog by David Turner
    Thursday Nov 05, 2009
  4. 'The Jewish Terrorist'
    Posted in Green-Lined by Yisrael Medad
    Thursday Nov 05, 2009
  5. The downfall of a cynic
    Posted in Guest Blog by Ruth Lande
    Tuesday Nov 03, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Jean - Georgia: I find your writing to be very open and from-the-heart. I found myself listening to his innaugural address and actually wondering if he was for real or still just a 'community organizer'. However, within a few minutes, it wore off - it was rather (well, to put it like it was) 'creepy'. I'm back with the 'community organizer' opinion. A question for you - what would you write about President Obama today?
Roddy Frankel: Nate, make alliyah as soon as possible. Commit to the decision in your own mind, and let your friends know about it. When you date, let your girlfriend know of your intentions. Life has a way of making decisions for you. That is why it is important to take control of your life as soon as possible.
Chaim, Brooklyn,N.Y.: Very well written. If Nathaniel is representative of this generation, we are in good hands.