Thursday Nov 15, 2007

Orthodox Opinions: Jerusalem: keep it one, keep it safe, keep it ours

Posted by Rabbi Tzvi Hersh Weinreb
Comments: 13
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

In my last blog I wrote about Jerusalem as a core concept in Judaism. I wrote about its special sanctity, a bit about its history, and about its religious significance. As I continue in these blogs to expand upon many of the core concepts in Judaism, such as Shabbat and Torah, I found it necessary to point out that Jerusalem is also such a core concept, and not merely an important capital city.
 
These days, certainly not for the first time, the world's attention is being directed to Jerusalem. Should it be kept united under Israeli sovereignty, or might it be shared with some Palestinian entity, or perhaps somehow internationalized?

To a person who has the perspective of "core Judaism", the very fact that such discussions are taking place is, to say the least, disheartening. The "core" spiritual experience of Jews throughout history has been the yearning for Jerusalem. The pain of losing the Holy City at the time of the destruction of the Second Temple was seared into the consciousness of every believing Jew. The Jew prayed, and prays still, for the restoration of a rebuilt City of Jerusalem to Jewish sovereignty every day. For one day a year we devote ourselves entirely to  reliving that pain, and even the most joyous  of holidays provides occasion for remembering the bitterness of the loss of Jerusalem.
 
Forty years ago, when Jerusalem was dramatically re-possessed by a Jewish State, all Jews felt that the pain suffered for two thousand years was now alleviated. This was no ordinary military victory, but a historic, if not messianic, event. I will not enter the debate here of whether or not the recapture of Jerusalem should be viewed theologically as a messianic event, but it certainly was experienced emotionally as something uncanny and spiritually thrilling. And no matter how jaded the Jew has become, and we certainly are jaded these days, it is difficult to visit Jerusalem without re-experiencing that thrill.
 
The Orthodox Union, of which I am executive vice president, has reacted to the discussion regarding the future of Jerusalem from this "core" experience of historical remembrance and spiritual enthusiasm. Although our traditional stance has been to not involve ourselves in the political process of the State of Israel (we are after all a Diaspora organization), we think it is necessary to make an exception in the case of Jerusalem. And so we have embarked upon a comprehensive program of "Defending Jerusalem". This program has involved us in advocacy, letter-writing, and discussions with political leaders in Israel and in the United States.
 
But our program also contains two other important components: education and spiritual response. Education for our constituency, to remind Orthodox Jews of the special place of Jerusalem in our religion, and of its special importance to us as a nation. We want to  help our people regain a sense of awe and wonder when the very word Jerusalem is mentioned, and we wish to instill within every feeling Jew a sense of gratitude to the Almighty for bestowing upon our generation a united, and easily accessible Jerusalem, something which our ancestors would have given anything to know.
 
To help achieve this we have designated Shabbat Vayetze, November 17, as Shabbat Yerushalayim. We have distributed to our synagogues, and to all interested institutions, a model schedule for this Shabbat, which includes materials regarding the current status of Jerusalem, the risks it faces, historical overviews, explanation of the ritual sanctity of the city, liturgical materials, excerpts from historical texts, and sermonic material for rabbis. We ask that special attention be given to those prayers which mention Jerusalem, and they are many. I certainly encourage the readers of this blog to look at our specially designed new website www.oujerusalem.org to access these useful materials.
 
I personally wrote a model sermon on the Portion of the Week, connecting it to the theme of Jerusalem. After all, Jacob's Ladder, planted firmly on earth but extending to heaven, was planted firmly, according to our sages, in the earth of Jerusalem. And it is in the week that the phrases "House of God" and "Gate of Heaven", phrases typically applied to Jerusalem, first appear.
 
We will stress, in our teachings and discussion and prayers this Shabbat, that we seek to displace no other faith from its Holy Site. Quite the contrary, we hope to continue the policy of the State of Israel to allow free access to the Holy Sites of all faiths to the followers of those faiths. Our dream of Jerusalem is indeed of a city at peace, and exemplifying peace. But we do not want to surrender the privilege of a Jerusalem united under Jewish sovereignty for the first time in two thousand years. And we do not want to be ungrateful to the Almighty who granted us this precious gift.
 
I hope, in your own way, that you will celebrate this Shabbat along with us as a Shabbat for Yerushalayim. Keep it one, keep it safe, keep it ours.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Thomas Ho, Sunday Nov 18, 2007
It's an inspired read to me and I would say it should be called "Jerusalem: keep it one, keep it safe, keep it ours, keep it for G-d!"
2  |  paul david swinford Christian truck driver, Sunday Nov 18, 2007
Amen
3  |  Allan Siegel, Sunday Nov 18, 2007
All of the comments so beautifully stated by Rabbi Weinrib also apply to Hebron, Shilo, Bet El, etc. and every millimeter of land that is identified as Kedushat Yisrael. The only way in which peace will come is when the Jewish people rise up to defend the land given to them with the same level of enthusiasm that is being voiced to defend Jerusalem.
4  |  DORIS TRAVIS, Sunday Nov 18, 2007
I appreciate your thoughts, so well presented. I regret that my own shul did not present your prepared materials last shabbos morning; maybe they did later in the day when I was not there, but I am confident that at my shul we are emphatically united in keeping Jerusalem one, safe and ours. I agree with you, that the question of giving up any part of Jerusalem continues to be broached, needs to be monitored carefully and continually, and acted upon.
5  |  abe, Monday Nov 19, 2007
There is not enough anger, Rabbi, at what olmert and his puppets are doing. There should be riots in the streets, both in Israel and in the US. Left to his own devices, Olmert will sell out Israel and then move to France, where he will be much more comfortable.
6  |  Susie Q, Monday Nov 19, 2007
Jerusalem belongs to the Jewish people..and to God! He has called this Holy city "the Apple of My Eye." Although as a Christian, I, too, love Jerusalem, I know it must remain only in Jewish hands! Do not let my government force you into giving any part of the city to any other people or state.Israel, all of it, was given to your people thousands of years ago, by blood covenant through God and Abraham! This covenant must never be broken by man, and CANNOT be broken by God!Fight for it, as many of us Christian Zionists are fighting for you over here. God bless you.
7  |  Dan Friedman, Monday Nov 19, 2007
Jerusalem may be the patrimony of every Jew in the world, but it will be won or lost by the Israeli people, not in shuls in America. And currently, Israelis are politically and spiritually unprepared to hold the line and all the strength the Jewish people have gained since WW II is in danger of disappearing. Zionists in America (religious or otherwise) should concentrate on reading the Israelis the riot act rather than handing out pamphlets and talking to ourselves.
8  |  Angela Rebekah Aharona Miller, Monday Nov 19, 2007
Jerusalem-Jerusalem-how I love thee.Cherished Crown of Israel G-d love and give thee Peace forever beloved City of our King David.
9  |  Eitan, Monday Nov 19, 2007
For those reading this from Eretz Yisrael, there will be a protest outside the PMs house in Jerusalem at 6:30PM this Wednesday, including a declaration against the division of Jerusalem. Come show that Am Yisrael won't stand for a divided Jerusalem!
10  |  dagoberto mensch, Monday Nov 19, 2007
Jerusalem is Jewish from a religious, social, psychological and emotional point of view (and every single other point of view too). I think Jerusalem belongs to all Jews so dividing it would be an act of theft not an act of peace. Besides, it is a bad idea to trade land for peace when the enemy thinks the more he attacks Israel the more land he gets. Remember Sderot and the kidnapped soldiers.
11  |  albert, Monday Nov 19, 2007
I would add my voice to yours. We must keep jerusalem united and Jewish. Only then will all religions be free to visit it.
12  |  albert, Monday Nov 19, 2007
I would add my voice to yours. We must keep jerusalem united and Jewish. Only then will all religions be free to visit it.
13  |  Michael, Chicago, Wednesday Sep 03, 2008
I fear that many gentiles are not going to be respecting the wishes of the leadership in Jerusalem and many will trample on the most holy sites there. It should be the duty of the jewish leaders to ensure the saftey of Jerusalem and keep ignorant gentiles out who's motives are not of the most profound, deepest respect for the Holy Ones of Israel. Rabbi's should act to keep peace within Jerusalem as long as they possibly can without putting their families in danger. May the G-d of Israel be with you all.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Orthodox Opinions Today's religious affairs as seen by the executive vice president of the Orthodox Union, Rabbi Tzvi Hersh Weinreb.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Top Rated Posts

Most Commented Posts

  1. Israeli Arabs need new leadership
    Posted in The Weekly Portion by MK Dr. Ephraim Sneh
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  2. It's the Palestinians' loss
    Posted in Window on Israel by Ira Sharkansky
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  3. Israel's 'Wild West' tendencies
    Posted in Center Field by Gil Troy
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  4. No place for political objectors
    Posted in Point / Counterpoint by Edwin Bennatan
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008

Recent Comments

Michael, Chicago: I fear that many gentiles are not going to be respecting the wishes of the leadership in Jerusalem and many will trample on the most holy sites there. It should be the duty of the jewish leaders to ensure the saftey of Jerusalem and keep ignorant gentiles out who's motives are not of the most profound, deepest respect for the Holy Ones of Israel. Rabbi's should act to keep peace within Jerusalem as long as they possibly can without putting their families in danger. May the G-d of Israel be with you all.
Michael, Chicago: Rabbi, The eyes of the G-d of Israel are in everyplace and I know that he loves his people very much, especially the dedication of the Orthodox Jews and those who dedicate their lives to the teachings of Moses and Torah. I also know that he sent his son into the world whom Moses spoke about and still until this day many jews reject Jesus Christ and the New Testament. The Holy Bible is meant for ALL jews and gentiles alike to be read in its entirety. Many should be reading the book of Daniel and Jeremiah right now to get a clearer understanding of what is happening to G-d's chosen race.
Al Strap, New York: Evidently, the Rabbi is quite funny: http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/127369