|
Monday Oct 22, 2007
Orthodox Opinions: 'Core Judaism' Posted by Rabbi Tzvi Hersh Weinreb
Comments: 10
I am happy to resume writing these blogs, representing, to the extent that I am able, the viewpoint of Orthodox Judaism on many aspects of contemporary life. In my earlier blogs I shared with the readers my discomfort with the word "Orthodoxy" and my preference for what I call "core Judaism". I outlined quite a few components of core Judaism, and today would like to describe another such component. And that component is Jerusalem. For the Jew, Jerusalem is not merely a city, a capital city, a historic city. It is also a sacred city and the city itself plays a role in our religious life in countless ways. These ways include the fact that wherever we are we face Jerusalem in prayer. We include Jerusalem in our three times a day prayers, and we pray for it to be rebuilt in the grace we recite after meals. The very word Jerusalem consists of two root words: Yirah and Shalom, awe and peace. As such, the word Jerusalem encapsulates two features of our religion: a sense of awe for the Divine, Yirat Shamayim, fear of heaven, which is a primary religious sensitivity; and shalom, peace, which is our constant objective in all of our relationships, interpersonal and international. We are also enjoined by the Torah to visit the city of Jerusalem three times a year: Passover, Shavuot, and Succot. For the past several years I have tried to spend Succot, and lately Shavuot too, in Israel. I would like to tell you a bit about my recent two weeks in Israel, over the Succot holiday, and how my experiences there relate to "core" Jewish values. The most outstanding feature of my sojourn in Jerusalem this year was the company I kept. First of all, I mean the quantity of that company. Jerusalem was thronged, the hotels were full, the taxis were busy, traffic was impassable. I recall no larger crowd than the crowd at the Birkat Cohanim by the Kotel, the blessing of the Priests at the Western Wall, that was there this year. Just being part of such a large number of people who shared one thing for sure, namely a reverence fro Jerusalem, was spiritually very uplifting. But the "quality" of the large number of "tourists" was even more dramatic. The variety and diversity of people who fill the streets, the parks, the malls, and the Holy sites, was astounding. They included Jews and non-Jews, religiously observant Jews and patently secular ones, young and old, Israelis and travelers from every corner of the Diaspora. The power of Jerusalem to unite people, hinted at in the Bible itself, was apparent and tangible. As I walked the streets I found myself less in touch with my individuality, and more in touch with myself as a member of a large collective, far larger than my own religious circle, even far larger than my own Jewish people. I was especially moved by the parade of the Evangelical Christians through the streets of Jerusalem during the Intermediate Days of Succot. The genuine faith that these people have, the beliefs that they share with us, only one of which is the sanctity of Jerusalem and its connection to the Jewish people, was so encouraging in these days of faithlessnesses and anti-Israel sentiment. I spoke to many of these individuals, and was struck by their friendliness, their sincere love for Jews, and their appreciation of our history and scripture, an appreciation which is sadly lacking in many of our own people. I so enjoyed attending one particular synagogue for almost all of the prayers That synagogue, the Yeshurun Synagogues in the heart of Jerusalem, has been there for almost a century, and remains to this day a vibrant example of a place where one can enjoy a highly musical and spiritual service, revering minhagim and tradition, while allowing for innovative "spins" on the prayer melodies that enchant and inspire. I also visited some of the Chassidic courts, and the huge number of people who participate in them. A heightened sense of connection to our history, and a deepened sense of the spiritual attractiveness of our religion, can best be achieved at these courts. And the welcoming attitudes of the Chassidim, especially to Jews who on the surface look so different from them is also very encouraging. I hope to return to the topic of Jerusalem and its place in our core in future blogs, but wanted to share, if only partially, some of my own experiences there this past Succot. I thought that this would be the best way to re-introduce myself to this readership, and thus to resume the JPost Blog.
1 | Jeffrey Blustein, Monday Oct 22, 2007
The Former head of Conservative Judaism's Jewish Theological Seminary also stated that "The centrality of modern Israel heads our list of core values. For Conservative Jews, as for their ancestors, Israel is not only the birthplace of the Jewish people, but also its final destiny."
2 | john walker, Monday Oct 22, 2007
Rabbi,
I really appreciate you getting in touch with your glorious past. It is very important that all Jews know where they come and how G-D protected them throughout the many years and restored them to the land that He promised to their fathers.
My question is why rabbis are not as convicted to make the Jewish people aware of the many prophecies that "Jewish" prophets put down on paper for future generations of Jews. I have many Jewish friends who I have had the pleasure of speaking with over the years about current events and the fulfillment of the events that the prophets predicted, one that you are discussing " the nation being reborn", Ezekiel 36. My friends say that the rabbis never discuss these things which I believe is a tragedy.
My friends wait for the Messiah. I ask them what will He look like. They do not know. They think He will be a ruler, but they do not know the descriptions that the prophets have already given for who He is and what He looked like.
These descriptions, in detail, were given by Jewish men. Take a look and let me know what you think. It seems to me that if these men were inspired by G-D to write down what he intended for them to write down, then we should believe their account.
King David- Psalms 22- suffering messiah.
Prophet Isaiah 53- suffering Messiah
Prophet Daniel 9- timeline of the Messiah
Zecheriah 12:10-14- Israel's response to this Messiah
Blessings on you,
John
3 | Dr. E, Monday Oct 22, 2007
Like Rabbi Weinreb, I too was in Jerusalem for Succot and took in the same sights and sounds. It was a figurative and literal "homecoming" for our people as well as the non-Jewish community, with all of the pomp and circumstance that surrounds a holiday observance such as Succot. It presented an opportunity to catch up with old friends, both physical and spiritual, animate and inanimate. This only seemed to reinforce contention that a divided Jerusalem would not allow a replication of this experience as under such a paradigm, this could not happen. In a divided city, access to the sites that each faith finds near and dear, would be limited. Let us hope that all of future holidays as well as non-holidays can be celebrated in this same way, in an undivided Jerusalem.
4 | Ahmed Simjee, Monday Oct 22, 2007
well jerusalem is not only the sacred city for jews but it is also an undisputed holy city for the Muslims.
5 | holyclan, Tuesday Oct 23, 2007
Your description was wonderfull, the city seems to be so alive with all of these people from different parts of the worlds and with different religions... I wish I could be there to enjoy all of these feelings that you share with us in this article...
6 | Aaron, Tuesday Oct 23, 2007
I agree with the Rabbi on most of what he wrote, but I must comment on one thing.
While walking through Jerusalem last week, me and an American friend who is currently serving in the IDF struck up a conversation with a small group of elderly Americans.
While the man I spoke to was very curious about my yeshiva experience and life in Israel, my friend told me afterward that on of the women repeatedly urged him to accept Jesus and that only then would he get into Heaven.
In the holy land, we simply cannot tolerate such blatant missionizing
7 | Duane Broxson, Wednesday Oct 24, 2007
"Are you greator than our ancestor Jacob?"
"People soon become thirsty again after drinking this water."
Most of humanity stands in reverent awe of Jerusalem. But it is not Jerusalem the place that holds what we need to find. It is the spirit of the suffering souls of humanity that have cried out to enlighten us amid a Holy Land of war and hatred that has made it sacred.
"Is our worship spiritual and real"?
Jerusalem through the ages has been a view of the struggles of humanity with itself, the dastardly and the sublime. Pray that the love of G-D, and the love of our brothers will become a perpetual spring within us and Jerusalem the place where it begins. What a joy that would be to see! What a blessing for humanity!
8 | Daughter of Israel, Wednesday Oct 24, 2007
May I, respectfully, point out to both our Muslim (Ahmed Simjee) & Christian brethren who understand full well that Jerusalem is the world's most Holy City, that they do so only because of the Jews.
Is it not a fact that your faiths wouldn't exist if it weren't for the Bible & the Jewish religion, the original monotheistic belief?
So why do followers of both these youngster religions consistently through the ages, even to this very day, try in every possible way (whether by 'gentle' persuasion or wholesale bloodshed) to get Jews to forsake their heritage & convert to their religions? Can't they envisage what the world would be like if there were no more Jews because they had all become either Christians or Moslems? What then would be the point of the Jewish Bible(& consequently, Christian & Moslem holy books) if there were no more Jews?
Therefore, dear younger Christian & Moslem brothers, please respect your Jewish founding fathers, stop persecuting us &/or trying to exterminate us & let us remain Jews.
For without us, your religions would simply disintegrate as there would be no 'living' proof that the Jews, who founded monotheism & wrote the Bible, the foundation on which your religions are based, ever existed.
To put it in a nutshell - without a flourishing Judaism and its adherents, both Christianity & Islam will simply collapse & disappear into thin air.
9 | Duane L. Broxson, Wednesday Oct 24, 2007
Daughter of Israel Respectively:
Yes, but Christianity as a religion is not the point. Jesus was a Jew and cannot be divorced from Judaism. It is all one grand vision for mankind not just the Jew. Holy are the visions of your spirit!
10 | Ken Besig, Thursday Oct 25, 2007
While I am happy that so many Jews from abroad came to Jerusalem during Succot to get spiritually refreshed I have to ask myself why they didn't stay and be spiritually refreshed for the rest of their lives. Maybe Jochanan ben Zakkai was just a little too successful when Vespasian granted him permission to build his yeshiva at Yavneh and reformed Judaism into a Torah and Talmud based faith without a Beit Mikdash or any physical spiritual center whatsoever. Well folks, ben Zakkai is long since dead, and his form of "Reform Judaism" is no longer applicable since we are now an independent People with a sovereign state. So Reb Weinreb and all the other Orthodox Jews who reside outside Jerusalem and Israel, come home to your People and give up ben Zakkai's version of Reform Judaism.
|
All Categories
Tags:Blogroll |