|
Tuesday Jun 12, 2007
Orthodox Opinions: A "Core" response to Sderot Posted by Rabbi Tzvi Hersh Weinreb
Comments: 15
I have been discussing "core" concepts in Judaism. Torah study, Prayer, and kindness to others are some of the concepts I have discussed. In this blog, I would like to demonstrate an important thesis: that "Core" Judaism must inform every aspect of our lives, not just "religious" matters.
1 | Morton Friedman, Tuesday Jun 12, 2007
Another way of helping is for diaspora Jews to go there and volunteer. Do you know of a need and available lodging?
2 | Shalhevet, Tuesday Jun 12, 2007
Thank you! I truly appreciate your practical advice about what we can do to help!
3 | JfromC, Tuesday Jun 12, 2007
Well, my rabbi, no wonder things are as they are in Israel if this IS ALL you can do for your jews there. Actually to me it appears you HAVE ALREADY LET GO OF ANY RESPONSIBILITY TOWARDS YOUR OWN PEOPLE.(Just like the crooks there in Israel who are the government now)
I assume in your 'peaceful heart' you feel you have done all you could for them, but to me it seems there is a lot more you and your jews could do from N.Y. even if you are "NOT QUALIFIED" to give advice to the government how to prevent the killing of jews. Hell, I can give you a very nice advice, even not being a jew myself, but being one that saved jews when he was ONLY 6 YEARS OF AGE,and here it is:DO NOT TURN THE OTHER CHEEK! Your hesitation to just "feel" for people in mortal danger is appalling to me since we all know that IS NOT THE SOLUTION! The real solution is to take PHYSICAL ACTION AGAINS THE KILLERS AND MURDERERS! You somehow left that out of your available options for those who die day after day, and second after second have their lives destroyed by these murderous arabs.Come on now, you rabbi from N.Y. - you must "feel a bit more" for these INNOCENT AND UNFORTUNATE PEOPLE OF YOURS THAN JUST TIP-TOW AROUND THE ISSUES?
I did when I was 6, as even then I considered that my long time neighbours were more right to be hidden than hand them over to the "nice and friendly german uncles" to be "deported" as thos e who had the "yellow star were not good people little boy!!!" I could see through this easily as lies even being a 6 year old then, how is it you cannot see that with "feeling for my people" you will not solve this killing spree?
What happened to the famous saying:"never again", since it is obvious to me that IT IS AGAIN AND AGAIN? AS A RABBI I KNOW YOU COULD DO much better than just visit there! I sure do not see how that would help you, or your fight, if you feel this is a fight at all, if you got killed there? We both know there are much more powerful things we can do from here to stop the killing of jews there by arabs hell bent on extermination.I have done my part as a kid and as a non-jew, what are you going to do now as a jewish rabbi? Hope this reaches you and you will not ignore this from a person whose heart bleeds just watching what is allowed to happen there, by the Olmerts, Peretz,Livnis, Condis, etc! And all this because of the likes of you RABBI "helping your people with just feeling for them"! Really now - is that ALL you really CAN DO? May be donate to charity too to make you feel better? Get off your "peaceful rabbincal behind", to be nice to you, and DO SOMEHTING REAL THAT WILL REALLY HELP!STOP ALL THAT KILLING THERE!Then may be you can really "FEEL" for them and for yourself too! I also feel for you - mostly anger though for being so complacent after I RISKED MY LIFE TO SAVE THE LIVES OF YOURS AS A KID!You have done the first steps certainly by going there and writing about it - that IS ONLY THE FIRST STEP FOR YOU AND YOURS THERE IN n.y. if you really wish to do somehting!
4 | Simcha, Tuesday Jun 12, 2007
Kol HaKavod.
Brainstorming appropriate responses might also be helpful to the decision makers. My solution is to target a specific city in Gaza to be harassed by near-miss missiles that would only create material damages; and no ground-ops, in order to keep the price low in money and lives. Twice as much missiles a day, as Kassams fired at Sderot...until we find a better solution.
5 | sarah hecht, Tuesday Jun 12, 2007
Thank you for your suggestions. You are right. I have avoided this subject because it just keeps going on and on, and I am waiting for someone to do something. But I can do what I can do, and I can do what you have written.
6 | Paul David Swinford Christian truck driver, Wednesday Jun 13, 2007
"G-d hears the voice of the rightous".
I don't know a better reason that we should live a rightous life than to have G-d hear us in a time of need. I humbly ask Christians to join in the prayers for Sderot.
7 | Moshe Morgenstern, Wednesday Jun 13, 2007
I understand Rabbi Wienreb is not a military expert but he misses the point by stating "Core" Judaism does not address the military issue here.
The Rambam, in Hilchos Shabbos declares that when a gentile nation even comes close to the border (as opposed to Sderot when our enemies cross the border with missiles) it is imperetive to mobilize the army and strike them even if this means violating Shabbat. His reasoning is that if we don't stop them at the border the entire land may then lay open before them.
8 | Dan Friedman, Wednesday Jun 13, 2007
"I refrain from prescribing military solutions that the Israeli government might take. My knowledge of the "core" of Judaism does not qualify me as a military expert." It doesn't, Rabbi? Then I guess you haven't read much of the Torah you're supposed to be living by. It's chock full of military lessons, instructions and commands we're supposed to follow when confronting our enemies. Why are these any less binding than keeping kosher? You're not a butcher are you?
9 | Abagail, Wednesday Jun 13, 2007
Rabbi you hit the nail on its head there needs to be more proactive responce to such violence.May it be.
10 | Marla Lynch, Wednesday Jun 13, 2007
I am a Catholic, and I believe that this article represents the attitude that Jews and Christians must share in regard to this situation. I believe that the Lord did give the Jewish people the land of Israel. And I believe that the more we pray and engage in actions that are pleasing to Him, the more he will grant His blessings and healing to our nations and the world.
11 | Joe Feld, Wednesday Jun 13, 2007
As a Rabbi in New York you are 100% correct not to offer military advice. This is up to the IDF, in line with the government and the electorate. Those of us in chutz leAretz [Diaspora] must show we care and keep Sderot in the public domain. The extra mitzvahs and our extra kavanah [concentration in performing mitzvahs] can help those in need.
12 | harold, Thursday Jun 14, 2007
to #1. Volunteering in Israel is not much use. Its a 1st world country remember. However economy is. Remember that that highest form of charity is to provide people with a living. Buy products from Israel and go on holiday there. 1. you will have a wonderful holiday. 2. you are contributing to the economy. its a win-win situation!
13 | Johnson, Thursday Jun 14, 2007
Well Rabbi, your advice to Jews seems to be empathy for suffering.
This "understanding," which replaces rational responses to violence is typical.
You need to be aggressive in defending your people. What's holding you back. The Israeli government has abandoned its people to depredations. Nature abhors a vacuum, and Jewish uncertainty and vacillation will bring even more aggressive and deadly responses to kill Jews. Get a life.
14 | Kumiko Kondo, Thursday Jun 14, 2007
"I refrain from prescribing military solutions that the Israeli government might take. My knowledge of the "core" of Judaism does not qualify me as a military expert."
Funny, the Torah is full of explicit military advice regarding dealing with, and destroying, our enemies.
15 | guillermo jose garciavasquez, Friday Jun 13, 2008
ii would like to say that not all are bad guys in the jurusalem the people are wrong and justified fro his acts alove americans but alove all the races remmberd god love you the way youare not materd what color or religion you are remmberd we fighting for a cuse that we can handel it put the cars fuction wiht no pertrelum why we can put him to work with fuild gas how is going to take to make that 1000 lives are diying pelesed stop this war
|
All Categories
Tags:Blogroll |