Sunday Feb 22, 2009

Center Field: A pledge to fight anti-Semitism

Posted by Gil Troy
Comments: 6
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

I have considered myself a "Daniel Pearl Jew." Like that Wall Street Journal reporter Islamist terrorists kidnapped then beheaded in Pakistan - whom I never met - I was born in the early 1960s into the post-Auschwitz covenant. The world had sinned against our people, but now condemned anti-Semitism. We felt especially protected as Americans. Welcomed by America's meritocratic openness, we were lucky enough to attend elite schools, I went to Harvard; he went to Stanford. Our final layer of protection came from working as professionals for world-class institutions, me at McGill University, him at the Wall Street Journal.

Pearl interviewed Islamic fundamentalists unafraid - he was a Wall Street Journal reporter in a post-Holocaust world, after all. Pearl's brutal beheading after being forced to say "I am a Jew," symbolized the new surge of anti-Semitism from Islamist barbarians. This resurgence, fueled by genteel enablers on campuses and in the media, violated the post-Auschwitz covenant. Few of us have paid the price Daniel Pearl and his family did. Nevertheless, too many of us have experienced an unhappy step back toward our grandparents' world, a world populated and marred by too many anti-Semites.

For that reason, the London Conference on Combating Anti-Semitism held February 16 through 18, was so significant - and potentially healing. Watching 125 parliamentarians from 42 different countries devote two and a half days to discussing this curse, was sobering yet inspiring. The magnificent setting in the House of Parliament and historic palaces generated a mystical sense of historical tikun, repairing, as so many non-Jewish politicians denounced this old-new malady in halls of power that once helped perpetuate it.

Cocktails at Lambeth Palace, the Archbishop of Canterbury's majestic home adorned with severe portraits of pinched predecessors who detested Jews, felt particularly redemptive. The words spoken were even more splendid than the buildings, evoking a collective power repudiating this hateful prejudice. John Mann, the member of Parliament who hosted the gathering, is an altruist with no Jewish connection, few Jewish constituents, but an aversion to injustice. "We have drawn a line," he thundered in closing the conference, "and those who cross it - we will re-educate or we will knock down."

Earlier, the Canadian MP Irwin Cotler, co-founder with Mann of the Inter-Parliamentary Coalition for Combating Anti-Semitism, explained the need for such a conference. He described the new anti-Semitism's "globality and toxicity," generated by a pathological Islamist ideology, fueling genocidal threats against Israel from Iran, spread by the Internet, echoed by useful idiots who overlook Islamist's fascist tendencies in their zeal to tag Israel with the sins of Nazism and Apartheid. This demonization transforms the traditional hatred of the individual Jew into an unreasoning prejudice and unremitting campaign against Israel, the collective expression of the Jewish people. Amid all these eloquent ministers and righteous legislators, a highlight was the appearance of that hero who showed that sometimes good men can triumph over evil systems, Natan Sharansky.

Beyond the rhetoric, and the ringing tones of the London Declaration the parliamentarians ratified, a parallel conference of experts analyzed strategies for combating anti-Semitism. The conference showed that:

  • It is possible to criticize Israel without degenerating into anti-Semitism; it becomes anti-Semitic when Israel is treated as individual Jews have been treated over the centuries, singled-out, disproportionately criticized, demonized.
  • Islamism is the enemy. Dennis MacShane, Labour MP, writes in his important new book, "Globalising Hatred": "Islamism the ideology ... has unleashed new twenty-first century anti-Semitism and it is impossible to discuss the problem without dealing with Islamism."
  • There are many ways to criticize Israel but those who call Israelis Nazis or invoke the historically inaccurate analogy of apartheid racism malevolently link Israel with the 20th century's two great national sinners to justify Israel's ostracism and destruction.
  • Thanks to the Internet, anti-Semitic material that marginal characters once peddled wrapped in brown paper can now be cited unwittingly by students who stumble onto information manipulated to appear at the top of the Google search engine.
  • In April, the review of the infamous Durban conference will probably give modern anti-Semitism renewed respectability. Inviting other countries to join Canada in boycotting this farce, the Canadian Minister Jason Kenney challenged Europeans for waiting for the Americans or worrying about the UN's sensibilities, saying: "I always thought Europe prided itself as having its own independent foreign policy aligned with its own values and interests."

The fight against anti-Semitism must be proactive not just reactive. Smart coordinating strategies between Jewish institutions and local police forces in both England and Canada have improved community intelligence, increased police effectiveness, while empowering individuals. On the Internet, defensive strategies are insufficient. Educators must envision Citizenship 2.0, teaching students to avoid polluting on-line discourse themselves, to combat on-line hate, to be critical of sources on-line, and to use the net's grassroots power to defend democratic values against purveyors of hate.

At the opening breakfast, England's Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks praised the gathering's cross-party and international nature. "I want to bless you for being here," he said. "One of the worst things about being hated is the fear that you are alone. We are not alone." We are blessed. In the name of Daniel Pearl and other victims, in the name of the Holocaust martyrs who had no such conference to try saving them, in the name of Jewish students harassed on campuses, in the name of French Jews beaten by fresh converts to Islam forced by their new co-religionists to prove their loyalty, the 125 honorable parliamentarians proved this is not the 1930s. We cannot let the Islamists and their enablers Left and Right win. We should follow leaders like John Mann and Irwin Cotler, spearheading this army of righteous people to repair the post-Auschwitz covenant, and combat Jew hatred as part of the broader fight against bigotry worldwide.

The writer, a professor of history at McGill University, is the author of Why I Am a Zionist: Israel, Jewish Identity and the Challenges of Today. His latest book Leading from the Center: Why Moderates Make the Best Presidents, was recently published by Basic Books.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   Lauren Singer, Sunday Feb 22, 2009
" This resurgence, fueled by genteel enablers ...". That is a quote that I will remember. Genteel enablers. Absolutely brilliant. As alcoholics need enablers to prop them up, so Islamists need enablers to prop them up. And these enablers can't even begin to recognize the harm they do. Well educated, well meaning [well some of them anyway!] they don't see they are being manipulated. And in South Africa we have a Deputy Cabinet minister spewing hatred with ideas born from the Protocols no doubt. But we have others, "genteel enablers", who are more frightening because they speak so beautifully.
2  |   Christopher Wolf, Washington, DC, Sunday Feb 22, 2009
I was there on behalf of the ADL and this captures the gathering perfectly, and eloquently! I appreciate the references to my report on online anti-Semitism.
3  |   Manuel, Buenos Aires, Argentina, Sunday Feb 22, 2009
World anti -semitism has found a channel to vent its hate and that is current Israeli defense policy in Gaza. I must point out that the media has had a strong influence in the recent hate spike, and media relations has always been an issue where Israel either did not know how to manage or did not care. It seems to me that World Jewry should change the strategy and that is to come forward and fight daily in the media. Arab network. Al Jazeera has done a great job showing only the Palestinian position, harming Israel badly in front of international viewers. How about an entire Jewish CNN ?
4  |   Len NYC, Sunday Feb 22, 2009
That conference and its declarations and a Metrocard will get you on the NYC subway. An Israeli jet fighter carrying a full payload will keep the Jews alive.
5  |   Maurice Kabili Ft myers FLorida, Monday Feb 23, 2009
"one of the worst things about being hated is the fear that you are alone"says Rabbi Sacks.For me as a jew it is heartwarming to know that there are groups who stand with us.The highest grade goes to our supporters the fundemantalist christians.
6  |   Yechiel Shlipshon, Wednesday Feb 25, 2009
When I was in the 7th gread I learned about Gentle help, when I was attacked with antisemitic spile. The most help I receive from the compassionate principal was the Shrugg. Later I learned about the Shrugg of the 30's, when a 3rd of my people were murdered & the world shrugged. Now we watch to see if this is prelude to another great shrugg. If so, we should maintain a fleet of loaded planes to prevent the Genacide of the rest of our people. Is all we can do is smile and pray, or is there Justice, instead of theShrugg??
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
Your Blog/Website
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Center Field McGill history professor Gil Troy - a passionate moderate - looks at the American presidency, American history, Zionism, Judaism and Israel today.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. World opinion: who cares?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Glen A. Fritz
    Tuesday Nov 17, 2009
  2. Mr. President, bring the troops home
    Posted in Koch's Comments by Ed Koch
    Thursday Nov 19, 2009
  3. Our base is broader
    Posted in Green-Lined by Yisrael Medad
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  4. The shawl and the hood
    Posted in Reform Reflections by Rabbi Michael Marmur
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  5. Interfaith dialogue - naïve or necessary?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Ruth Wasserman
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

J.M.Jordan, Germany: Professor Troy, thanks! It would be just lovely to hear more abt everyday simple harmonic normal life, with like here somewhere a discrete hint at the place's real mix so it's even more of a joy. Best of all naturally, as a wise man of an Indian tribe once put it, never judge before having three weeks worn "the other's'" shoes. (What if everybody besides reporting beautiful normal things they experienced themselves tried to get a chance to do just that!)
Scott from Philadelphia: Right on point, as always. What a breath of fresh air it is to hear Israel referred to in a context other than one embedded with discord. Prof. Troy, home run yet a gain.
Colin Bradley DK: citizens of a new host nation, yet still with some Palestinian affiliation: in fact rather like todays Jewish Diaspora many of whom still choose to remain in their original lands, but keep close contact with Israel?