Thursday Sep 11, 2008

A Woman's Own: From agunah to freedom

Posted by Elana Maryles Sztokman
Comments: 10
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

It doesn't happen all that often, but I recently received a phone call that filled me with hope and optimism. My friend Sara, who had been an agunah [literally 'anchored' or 'chained', refers to a Jewish woman who is chained to her marriage because her husband's whereabouts are unknown or because he is unable to write her a binding get (divorce) due to mental or physical illness. A woman in such a situation is unable to remarry according to halacha] for over six years, whose story is saturated with some of the most painful and trying aspects of human manipulation and abuse, called to tell me she has remarried and has a baby. I must admit, there were times when I never thought she would reach this point. "You see," she said, "miracles do happen."

Sara was married for 12 years to a man who is publicly revered in the religious community of Jerusalem. He can be charming, charismatic and eloquent. Yet these same qualities are the very ones that turn him into a monster behind closed doors. Sara was trapped for years in his patterns of emotional abuse, and it took her that long to understand what was happening to her.

The now-ex-husband would systematically put her down, insult her, and demean her. He would toss the dinner she made into the rubbish, he would tell her how terrible she looked, he would isolate her from friends and family and would make her feel like she was worthless.

He was also a control freak, so that even when it seemed like he was being "nice," he was putting her down. "Don't you worry about the shopping, the banking, the driving," he would say, "I'll take care of it all." He demonstrated distrust, controlled her money, her time and her friends, and robbed her of her sense of self-worth. "It doesn't matter how intelligent or educated you are," Sara says. "It happens gradually and slyly. You internalize it all and before you know it you have no self-confidence left and you self-esteem is at an all time low."

What changed the trajectory of her life, significantly, was the help of a friend. "One day, my friend said to me, 'You know, Sara, this is abuse,'" Sara recalled. "That changed my life. That's when I started to see, and started the process of getting out."

Sara is not alone. She is in fact just one of tens of thousands of abused women in Israel and around the world who are stuck trying to figure their way out of abusive relationships. According to Haifa University, one in seven Israeli women are abused. In the United States, it's one in six. In Australia, studies show that one out of every four women will be in an abusive relationship at some point in her life.

Abuse takes many forms - physical, emotional, verbal, sexual, financial. Sara said she "only" suffered physical attacks twice in her marriage. But the emotional and verbal abuse takes its own toll, and is in some ways harder to heal, as well as to recognize. Mavoi Satum, the organization helping agunot that Sara cites as having helped her tremendously, has adapted some wonderful materials from Jewish Women International and the Crisis Center for Religious Women and made them available here.

"I think physical abuse is in some ways easier than emotional abuse," Sara once reflected. "If you look in the mirror and see a black eye, you can say, something is wrong. But with systematic emotional abuse, you sort of think, maybe I'm crazy."

One of the most trying aspects of Sara's story was the ex-husband's manipulations of the children, and phenomenon that is known as Parental Alienation Syndrome. This is where an abusive spouse verbally and emotionally manipulates children to despise the other parent. Sara suffered from this terribly, as she found her children keeping their distance from her. Her lawyer could not even fight this pattern, and tragically advised her to give up certain custody rights in exchange for her get.

To this day, even as she has rebuilt her life and worked on her relationships with her children, they are still somewhat under the husband's control, afraid of confronting or challenging him, unable to tell him no. Sara has yet to spend a weekend or holiday with her children.

Still, the children, like Sara, are healing. They all now see through the manipulations and are all working through the issues in their own ways. She has rebuilt a strong relationship with her children and is helping and supporting them, in their own processes of healing. They are lucky to have her.

"There are so many scars," she says. "It's not easy. But we're working on it, and thank God, there really are miracles."

Sara, an Anglo-Saxon, is now married to a man who she describes as "very sweet". "I did it right this time," she said. "There are a lot of men out there who are not nice to women. But I found one who is."

Sara is an amazing woman. Her wisdom, strength and goodness never faltered. I think about her often, and pray that more women find the ability to exit abusive relationships and rebuild their own sense of who they are. And I am reminded of the enormous power of women's friendships, of women supporting one another and being there for each other. This is how women are changing the world.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   ariella-lea-, Thursday Sep 11, 2008
I-exsperienced-the-same-life-with-a-religious-man-who-is-publicly-revered-in-the-religious-community.-Last-spring-I-was-thinking-to-be-free-from-this-situation-that-has-been-a-nightmare.I-met-him-again-for-getting-my-books--that-were-still-in-his-house,unluckly.-It-was-two-months-ago.Now-I--can't-see-well-from-my-right-eye,all-the-things-I-was-trying-to-build-again-in-my-life-are-destroied-another-time-maybe-forever.And-so-on-But-to-read-about-your-own-exsperience-is-ok.So-you-don't-think-to-be-the-only-one-in-the-Jewish-world-like-a-pariah
2  |   Mikha'el M., Jerusalem, Thursday Sep 11, 2008
It really is disgusting. Now, I will grant that an abusive husband can hide his abuse behind closed doors, and that therefore the wider community cannot wholly be blamed for tolerating it. Nevertheless, the fact remains that if a certain man who recently was caught selling treif meat disguised as kosher meat, was forced to appeal to the US government to safeguard him, as he literally feared for his life from the religious community, should not abusive husbands and those who abuse their employees and workers, fear the same from the religious community? Glatt kosher? Glatt yoshor [yashar]!
3  |   James, Thursday Sep 11, 2008
One can also argue that the story here is a view of one of the sides. The fact that the man was reverred in the community meant that the man was respected for his standards of piety prior to the marriage. The fact that the woman married the man and had difficulties accepting his stringencies shows that she married a wrong person for a wrong reason. Typically, people seeking honor and prominence do not have much to show for it except for good looks. When it comes to showing effort, which is demanded by pretty much every Jewish book, people like that accuse of physical and mental abuse. Shame!
4  |   B Israel, Thursday Sep 11, 2008
Kol HaKavod to you Sarah. You inspire people who really need it.
5  |   Gil Ronen, Harish, Israel, Friday Sep 12, 2008
This week feminism in Israel sank to a new low when the Knesset's Committee for the Advancement of Women held a televised session on the subject of "the hardships that lead women to murder their children in view of the recent cases". Your ideology is bankrupt and it is now making excuses for child murderers. The agunot spiel has been discredited too: for years you claimed there were 100,000 agunot in Israel but rabbinical court statistics show that the number is 180 (without the added zeros) and that the number of men who are refused a get by their wives is 190!
6  |   RBendavid (Haifa), Saturday Sep 13, 2008
The problem with our religion is that we have not changed an iota in 4000 years. We are still practicing slavery. If I were born a female I would convert and marry out of my religion!
7  |   J, USA, Saturday Sep 13, 2008
Other groups have similar dificulties. When I was in high school I would notice scratch marks on my dad's face on several mornings. Years later, I recognized my ex-wife's tendencies toward violence. When her temper flared, I would leave the appartment rather than let it escalate to violence. After 9 months of this, I told her I wanted a divorce. She slammed the front door on my leg as I tried to leave, but I got out with "only" a large bruise. The divorce took 3 years, because of the delay tactics she used in the secular courts. I'm relieved that it is finally over.
8  |   07044 - usa, Sunday Sep 14, 2008
I wish to add my voice to those who are complaining about vicious spouses. I had endured it too. Mental abuse. Threats of divorce. Public embarrassment. Lies to the children. Manipulative behavior. Now my kids are alienated. One detail - My ex-spouse is a female. After a separation of 2.5+ years, when I told her that i wanted to give her a Get, she said, "Oh no! I'm not going to accept your Get until you agree to my financial terms (read, demands)." She held up our civil divorce as long as she could. I am now happily remarried to a spiritual, righteous, lovely lady.
9  |   New Jersey, Sunday Sep 14, 2008
It is true, the Hebrew word for a "Chained woman" is Agunah. Less known is the Hebrew word for a man who cannot remarry because his wife refuses to accept his Get. The male form of Agunah is Agun. Some mean, nasty, vengeful women who accept a Get attempt to delay a civil divorce as long as possible to delay the remarriage of their Get-giving ex-husband. I imagined starting a self-help organizatioon for men so victimized - A.G.U.N., Aggrieved Gentlemen United for Nuptials. slogan: You gave a Get now get AGUN.
10  |   Keren, Bnei Brak, Sunday Sep 14, 2008
To all the agunot out there and to all the abused women in abusive marriages, AM Yisrael is with you. Our prayers go out for you getting out of abusive marriages and finding caring spouses to build a bayis neeman beyisrael!
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
Your Blog/Website
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

A Woman's Own The Talmud says there are seventy faces to the Torah. I believe there are seventy faces to the person. I am a teacher, writer, researcher, activist, educator, thinker, organizer, fundraiser, feminist, parent, spouse, daughter, sister and friend. Or, if you prefer, I am an Israeli, American, energetic, opinionated, passionate, religious, determined and generally optimistic Jewish woman. It's not quite seventy, but we're getting there.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. Mr. President, bring the troops home
    Posted in Koch's Comments by Ed Koch
    Thursday Nov 19, 2009
  2. Interfaith dialogue - naïve or necessary?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Ruth Wasserman
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  3. Our base is broader
    Posted in Green-Lined by Yisrael Medad
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  4. The Syrian illusion revisited
    Posted in Levant in Focus by Tony Badran
    Tuesday Nov 24, 2009
  5. The true desecrators of our Jewish tradition
    Posted in Masorti Matters by Rabbi Andrew Sacks
    Tuesday Nov 24, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

DALevit Palm Springs, CA USA: With all due respect, your post implies that the "separation" is indefinite, and yet it is only for the two weeks during the time of the female's flow. Is the morbid sentiment expressed really necessary, when all will all go back to normal soon? Is that 2 weeks enough to nullify everything else good about the relationship? Won't there be plenty of hugs and kisses in a few days, after the period of uncleanness passes? Anyone reading this with no knowledge of the Orthodox ways would get a terribly distorted view of things from reading this. DAL
Dr S McCosker Australia: I have a suggestion for Tal & Melchior. Google 'Peter Andrews' 'Australian Story' 'Natural Sequence Farming', 'Natural Sequence Association'. What Andrews does in arid infertile Aussie landscapes, to turn flash-flooding gullies into healthy streams, recharge aquifers, heal salinised soil, stop erosion, build soil fertility, restore biodiversity [& thus boost farm productivity & animal & human health]- ought to work in Israel. I urge Tal & Melchior: invite Andrews to Israel & show him the Negev & give him a wadi & an eroded hillside to work his magic on, for a demo project.
Joseph London: An interesting alternative interpretation of the saying of the Sages. Many of us understand it to refer to a chavruta in learning, i.e. a partner to share one's learning, not a marriage partner. There are, of course, many sayings praising marriage such as all the blessings a man receives are because of his wife, etc..