'A hole in the sheet' - the life of a woman who escaped from Gur hassidut

Sara Einfeld, 25-year old mother of two, ran away from her Gur Hasidic life. In the process she began a blog, called “Hor Basadin,” which attracts many struggling haredi women. Yediyot Aharonot exposed her story in last weekend's newspaper, and has since caused a buzz in haredi and secular circles alike. I blogged about it in this week's Forward Sisterhood. You can read the whole post here. In the meantime, though, here is a heart-wrenching poem that Einfeld posted last week in response to the hubbub (translation mine):

I still cry when I remember
Me
A young women who tried to explain to a yeshiva scholar
Who sat across from her
Next to the dark wooden table in the living room.

Who made charts and asked, So what's bothering you?

Shame on you, Gila Katsav

I have my own Moshe Katsav story. When Katsav, then Israel's president, visited Australia in March 2005, and I was working at JNF in the Israeli-professional hub of Beth Weizmann, I was asked to join the president's local support staff for those few days. At the time it was a big thrill, and of course all of Jewish Australia was abuzz over the impending Israeli presidential visit Down Under.

Well, I had an even greater thrill when one of Katsav's senior staffers came into the back room and said, "The President would like a massage. Does anyone know a good massage therapist?" Well, I knew one! My husband, Jacob, was working as a massage therapist - and was a die-hard Zionist who would undoubtedly jump at the opportunity to serve the State of Israel in whatever manner happened to be available.

The massage required some logistical maneuvers: Katsav was staying in the city and was giving his big speech to the community on Saturday night (a speech which turned out to be a dud - he was thereafter noted for being an exceptionally boring orator, and that was before the three-hour flop we witnessed last week). So anyway, Jacob had to rush to the city as soon as Shabbat was over in order to get the president's massage in before the Big Speech. Jacob prepared his stuff on Friday, and the second Shabbat was out, he grabbed his table and jumped into the car. Within five minutes, however, the call came. "Forget the massage," the senior staffer said. "The President does not get massages from men. Only from women."

The next big thing: Orthodox women rabbis

I received a message last week congratulating Sara Hurwitz on the "historic event" in which she is being conferred the title "spiritual leader" of the Hebrew Institute of Riverdale, following her completion of the "required course of study in Yoreh Deah." In other words, the synagogue is making her a rabbi without the title. [Hat tip: Matthew Maryles]

First of all, I wish Sara Hurwitz a hearty congratulations on this terrific achievement, and I wish her well in her new role. HIR, under the leadership of the courageous and visionary Rabbi Avi Weiss, has always been a place that is willing to buck trends and break new ground on behalf of women. Sara Hurwitz has done some important work on gender and education in the Orthodox community, along with scholar and educator Dr. Chaya Gorsetman, also of Riverdale. I wish Spiritual Leader Hurwitz, Rabbi Weiss, and the entire Riverdale community a hearty mazal tov on this auspicious event.

A new vision of Israeli society: A safe environment

Saving the environment is not just a noble cause; it is a religious imperative. That is the message coming from an intriguing new political initiative of Rabbi Michael Melchior and Prof Alon Tal, who have recently joined forces to form a counter-intuitive and seemingly unlikely political merge between a religious and a green party. Tal's environmentalist Green Movement and Melchior's religious-liberal Meimad have decided to unite in order to lead the country not only towards intensive environmental and social activism but effectively towards implementing an entire vision of what it means to build a Jewish society.

"What kind of Jewish state are we if are not looking after our environmental and social needs?" Tal asked. "The answer is, we are not a Jewish state. We are not embodying Jewish values."

Homework, high school and other headaches

All these years, I thought I was alone. I thought I was the only one who struggled nightly for hours on end, letting go any hopes of having some relaxing time with my family after a long day of school and work. I did not realize that everyone else who has school-age children in Israel also spends every evening battling homework.

I really did not picture parenthood this way. Before the kids enter school, nighttime is often a time of bath, books, stories, and play. At 8PM, all gets quiet and my spouse and I can have some quiet breathing time to remember what the other one looks like. But as soon as school starts, the dream of creating a family life slowly fades into the distance. My kids are doing homework until way past my bedtime, and there is never, ever a release from pressure. I find myself telling young mothers who are deliberating over work and home balancing that the balance is easy when the children are little. It's when they get into school that they really demand your time. That's when we have to teach them all the subjects that teachers drop in our laps.

Vindication for rape victims

When "Aleph," one of the rape victims of then Israeli president Moshe Katzav, went on national television during prime time last year and told her story about how Katzav forced himself on her in his office, the nation was riveted. It was the first time many Israelis heard a graphic first hand account of how rape happens. This was not in some alleyway with a street criminal on drugs. Katzav did not hold a gun or a knife to her head. His main weapon was his position of power, and with that he had the incredible ability to control the world around him and destroy her life.

Hip Hop, Lipstick and Orthodox feminism

Beyonce Knowles may be leading a gender revolution through her music. Beyonce, known primarily for the shimmying body accompanying her spectacular voice, and for the way she taught Oprah how to booty dance, is hardly an anticipated source of feminist activism. Yet, check out some of the lyrics on her newest single, "If I were a Boy:"

If I were a boy
Even just for a day
I'd roll out of bed in the morning
And throw on what I wanted then go
Drink beer with the guys
And chase after girls...
I'd put myself first
And make the rules as I go
Cause I know that she'd be faithful
Waitin' for me to come home

No, this is not Feminist Theory 101. This is Beyonce protesting that women have a double shift at home, while men continue to live carefree lives, that men put themselves "first" while women take care of everyone, that women are "faithful" in relationships while men can sleep with whomever they feel like it, and that women continue to wait by the window while the men are out gallivanting. That's a lot of stuff!

A whole new kind of mikva

"Eyes, ears, navel!" is the typical drill that naked Orthodox women are subjected to seconds before their dip in the mikva, or ritual bath. In most mikvas, the attendant inspects the woman's body from head to toe, checking and picking off specks of dirt or hair under nails, between eyelashes, and on the torso. Women deemed free of all interference are then observed descending and dipping, while the attendant cries "Kasher!" The woman ascends, clean from menstrual impurity and ready for intercourse with her husband, and wraps herself in a towel, as the attendant calls out, "Who's next?"

All this may be about to change. In April, a new mikva opened up in Givat Shaul, Israel, which is unlike any other mikva in the world. "Ivriya: Spa Boutique, Bridal Center and Kosher Mikva," replaces the cold, sophistic factory-like mikva with an environment of care rather than compulsion. Ivriya, literally "Hebrew woman", offers an array of massages, manicures, hairstyling, waxing, and holistic treatments, thus taking a whole new approach not only towards mikva, but also towards the needs and desires of religious Jewish women.

Where is the 'Women for Livni' group?

On Tuesday, the National Organization of Women and five other feminist groups in the US announced the formation of "Women for Obama" to actively campaign for Obama. "We don't think it's much to break a glass ceiling for one woman and leave millions of women behind," said Eleanor Smeal, president of the Feminist Majority Foundation. In other words, Sarah Palin as VP may be good for Sarah Palin, but her policies on issues such as abortion, health care, and the environment will ultimately hurt many more.

This turn of events has gotten me asking myself, where are the "Women for Livni" groups?

There are none.

From agunah to freedom

It doesn't happen all that often, but I recently received a phone call that filled me with hope and optimism. My friend Sara, who had been an agunah [literally 'anchored' or 'chained', refers to a Jewish woman who is chained to her marriage because her husband's whereabouts are unknown or because he is unable to write her a binding get (divorce) due to mental or physical illness. A woman in such a situation is unable to remarry according to halacha] for over six years, whose story is saturated with some of the most painful and trying aspects of human manipulation and abuse, called to tell me she has remarried and has a baby. I must admit, there were times when I never thought she would reach this point. "You see," she said, "miracles do happen."

About this blog

A Woman's Own The Talmud says there are seventy faces to the Torah. I believe there are seventy faces to the person. I am a teacher, writer, researcher, activist, educator, thinker, organizer, fundraiser, feminist, parent, spouse, daughter, sister and friend. Or, if you prefer, I am an Israeli, American, energetic, opinionated, passionate, religious, determined and generally optimistic Jewish woman. It's not quite seventy, but we're getting there.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

DALevit Palm Springs, CA USA: With all due respect, your post implies that the "separation" is indefinite, and yet it is only for the two weeks during the time of the female's flow. Is the morbid sentiment expressed really necessary, when all will all go back to normal soon? Is that 2 weeks enough to nullify everything else good about the relationship? Won't there be plenty of hugs and kisses in a few days, after the period of uncleanness passes? Anyone reading this with no knowledge of the Orthodox ways would get a terribly distorted view of things from reading this. DAL
Dr S McCosker Australia: I have a suggestion for Tal & Melchior. Google 'Peter Andrews' 'Australian Story' 'Natural Sequence Farming', 'Natural Sequence Association'. What Andrews does in arid infertile Aussie landscapes, to turn flash-flooding gullies into healthy streams, recharge aquifers, heal salinised soil, stop erosion, build soil fertility, restore biodiversity [& thus boost farm productivity & animal & human health]- ought to work in Israel. I urge Tal & Melchior: invite Andrews to Israel & show him the Negev & give him a wadi & an eroded hillside to work his magic on, for a demo project.
Joseph London: An interesting alternative interpretation of the saying of the Sages. Many of us understand it to refer to a chavruta in learning, i.e. a partner to share one's learning, not a marriage partner. There are, of course, many sayings praising marriage such as all the blessings a man receives are because of his wife, etc..