Sunday May 25, 2008

The Weekly Portion: The fall of Lebanon and the rise of the West Bank

Posted by MK Dr. Ephraim Sneh
Comments: 10
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

Amid the excitement of last week's events - the announcement of  negotiations with Syria and the developments in the latest Olmert  corruption scandal - not enough attention was paid to the most significant event of the week: the fall of Lebanon in oil-rich Qatar.

In negotiations that took place under the sponsorship of the Qatari  ruler, the Lebanese government surrendered to the demands of Hizbullah and Syria: the pro-Syrian military chief General Michel Suleiman was  nominated for the presidency, Hizbullah would appoint a third of  cabinet ministers (11 out of 30), Fuad Saniora would no longer remain  prime minister and Hizbullah's demands for the renewed division of  voting areas which would enhance its Parliament representation in the next election was also approved. Under Lebanese law, a third of government ministers have veto power on every decision. The moment 11 ministers are Hizbullah members, every decision made in Lebanon has to first be approved by Teheran and Damascus.

What brought all parties to the negotiating table in Qatar was the latest round of violence in Beirut and northern Lebanon initiated by Hizbullah and which lead to the deaths of dozens of citizens. Iranian terror in the region was victorious once again.

Vis-à-vis Israel, the deal essentially spells the end of UN Resolution 1701. It also means that our achievements in the Second Lebanon War have been wrecked. Now, the Lebanese Army in the south of the country, meant to distance Hizbullah from Israel's borders, will receive orders by a Hizbullah-led government. UNIFIL's presence will be at the government's behest.

Syria made an important achievement last week. It brought Lebanon back under its control. The timing of the announcement of Turkish-mediated negotiations with Israel alleviated and, in fact, deflected international criticism from Syria. World leaders who did not support Saniora praised the capitulation agreement he signed.

Last week's events worsened Israel's strategic position and handed Iran yet another victory. The need for military readiness for another round of fighting in the North has not lessened. On the contrary. There is no more comfortable way for Iran to sabotage Israeli-Syrian negotiations than to fan the flames on the Israel-Lebanon border.

I write these words from Bethlehem where I was invited to attend the Palestinian Investors Convention, not as a potential investor. Over 1,200 business people from the West Bank, Gaza and the Gulf States attended the event. Security arrangements under the responsibility of Palestinian Authority security forces were effective and professional. Palestinian companies delivered their presentations with professionalism on an international scale. On Thursday afternoon, the foreign investment deals that were signed passed the $1 billion mark. However, even before one job is created in the West Bank, it can be said that the convention's biggest achievement was its mere existence.

I met with PA Prime Minister Salaam Fayad who initiated the convention and remains the main reason for its success. He proved that under his leadership, the West Bank is becoming a place in which investors are prepared to conduct business. Security forces that were deployed in Jenin and Nablus and who reached Bethlehem to secure the convention significantly changed the face of personal security and public order. The convention was a show of force against Hamas. A non-violent show of force proving that modernism and economic development trumps Hamas' dark terrorism.

I regret that, except for myself, no other Israeli MK, no other Israeli official and none of the media's Arab affairs correspondents were present. I met a small number of Israeli businessmen who decided to break through for the sake of economic cooperation.

Things are happening on the other side of the fence and in Israel no one is listening. If we strengthen the Palestinian economy and help it develop - and we are capable of doing so - we will essentially be strengthening the moderates and those who oppose terror. Therefore, I dismiss the term "a gesture to the Palestinians" when referring to the dismantling of a roadblock or as a step toward strengthening the Palestinian economy as nonsense. It is first and foremost meant to serve Israel's interests.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   Vinegar Hill, Madrid, Spain., Monday May 26, 2008
Dr. Sneh once again you portray, what has been a victory for democracy, as a victory for a terrorist group. The election of Sleiman has been a victory for democracy. Why don't you admit it? His election has the backing of many countries including the USA and the EU. International observers took note of the event and nothing untoward took place. For once, will you please recognise a truth!
2  |   Reuven Ben-Daniel Israel, Monday May 26, 2008
Prosperity has been shown to have nothing to do with terrorism. Most if,not all, of the terrorist leaders come from,if not wealthy, prosperous families. When the first intifada began the standard of living in Gaza and Judea/Samaria ( I know of the Bank of Israel., Bank Hapoalim, Bank Leumi but I have never seen a branch of the West Bank) was higher than when they were under Egyptian and Jordanian rule, and was steadily going up. Dr.Sneh and his fellow travelers should realise by now that the Arabs will not tolerate A Jewish Israel, however small.
3  |   Hofikoman, USA, Monday May 26, 2008
When Nonie Darwish went onto Al-Jazeera to share her "Arabs for Israel" perspective, the producer informed her that one third of all the telephone calls received by the station were positive. It is simply a mistake to assume the eternal enmity for Israel on the part of all Arabs or Muslims. Those who look soberly to their own development and prosperity in the Arab world understand that perpetual war with Israel is a disaster. Dr. Sneh did well to attend the economic conference. However, his view that the new Lebanon government is a victory for Syria is debatable. Iran definitely gained. Syria?
4  |   Louis New Jersey, Monday May 26, 2008
Vinegar Hill (wonder what the significance of that is?)- The unfortunately large group of people who survive on wishful thinking are a greater menace than the terrorists themselves because their approval of raw force as long as it comes from their side encourages and gives an unmerited legitimacy to the fascist principles they rule by. The victory of Hizbollah is widely seen both in and out of Lebanon as a result of Hizbollah's forceful takeover of parts of Beirut. As a consequence they have attained by force of arms what they couldn't do otherwise. Democracy? More likem reckless gangsterism.
5  |   Louis New Jersey, Monday May 26, 2008
Hofikoman- Good point. There are large numbers of Arabs who want only to raise their families, educate their children and live comfortably and who also, implicitly or explicitly, realize that Israel's accomplishments and presence in the area enhances their opportunities. Unfortunately, the extremists and thugs, those with the guns, keep these people from speaking out.
6  |   Sy Dill-Providence, USA, Tuesday May 27, 2008
Dr. Sneh should stick to what he knows best; fighting. We need steady triggers, people who can defend the lives of their loved ones in our ancient homeland. Playing footsie with mass murderers may make him a hero in a left-oriented society, but it won't keep the river away from our door.
7  |   Izzat Sajdi, Jordan, Tuesday May 27, 2008
There are, today, around 560 roadblocks established by the Israeli Occupation forces in the tiny area of the West Bank, which is an incredible number. No roadblocks have been removed; each and every one of them stands in witness to the fact that Israel's promises are not fulfilled and that their declarations and statements on peace are hollow and meaningless. The $7 billion that were promised at the recent Paris conference to jump-start the Palestinian economy are useless, for without a minimal freedom of movement, there is no way that the economy of the Palestinians can be put on its feet.
8  |   Donna Fischer Tiberias, Tuesday May 27, 2008
Amazing how intelligent people are so deceived. Like the US presidential canidate years ago that admitted that he had been "brain-washed". Sad. The Arabs have stated over and over that they intend to destroy Israel and annialiate the Jews. Why don't some people believe them?
9  |   Nach, Tuesday May 27, 2008
Dr. Sneh, I think you are a victim of your leftist convictions. Why didn't you ask those present if they recognize Israel and if so what borders do they recognize. Instead, you are guided by momentary impressions that has nothing to do with what those opposite you are thinking about your own country. It's only you projecting and generalizeing your own wishful thinking not reality on the ground. Peres too says it's all about economics. But I guarantee you both it's got everything to with ideology and nothing else. The facts on the ground show Israle's loss of deterrence period.
10  |   J.J.BIo, Wednesday May 28, 2008
Mr Sneh,stop dreaming! They all (98 percent) want to destroy us!Why don't you drive a little more to the Right?Politics are not religion ,if you see a failure of the left why an intelligent mind like yours refuse the evidence,and refuse to revue his actual political stands?
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
Your Blog/Website
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

The Weekly Portion Former Deputy Defense Minister Dr. MK Ephraim Sneh comments on the headlines of the past week.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. World opinion: who cares?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Glen A. Fritz
    Tuesday Nov 17, 2009
  2. Mr. President, bring the troops home
    Posted in Koch's Comments by Ed Koch
    Thursday Nov 19, 2009
  3. Interfaith dialogue - naïve or necessary?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Ruth Wasserman
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  4. Who will take care of my fruit trees?
    Posted in Making Aliyah by Jonathan Feldstein
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  5. Our base is broader
    Posted in Green-Lined by Yisrael Medad
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Brian Sandridge CT, USA: If America won't even establish a naval blockade on Iran, and do all the other things mentioned above like economic boycott by the Anglosphere with maybe EU support, why would anyone believe that the US would retaliate with a nuclear strike on Iran. What if Russia places an "umbrella" around Iran? Will the US trade say Seattle for Tel Aviv? No, Israel better recall that only the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob has brought them like Wings of the Eagle back to the land promised their ancestors. Do not lean on weak reeds!
Daniel Gritsky, London: What's interesting is that americans tend to view guns and weapons differently than non-americans do. For instance, if you check out http://www.thegunpoll.com you can see a survey that clearly shows americans want to be in control of weapons much differently than internationals do. Pretty interesting
Lars, Mad City, USA: This is a joke, right? You can't possibly believe that the United States, the UN, or ANY other country is going to prevent Iran from getting their bomb? If it isn't already in the protective shelter, it sure will be. Dr. Sneh, you are correct that the powers in the United States, occupied as they are with a finanacial crisis, NEVER intended to do anything but talk about Iran and a Nuke. It is, as it always has been "an Isreali problem"...if not now, it will be. The UN and Europe won't lift a finger either. Peaceful men like you shall one day know that "talk" is only good for tea parties.