Monday Feb 18, 2008

The Weekly Portion: Mughniyeh and the war on terror

Posted by MK Ephraim Sneh
Comments: 16
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

There is no one in the security and defense establishments and counter-terrorism organizations who did not express joy and relief at the assassination of Mughniyeh. We've been hearing his name since the 1980s. He was one of the founders of Hizbullah which operates directly under the auspices of the Iranian regime. It was in this organization that he rose up the ranks to become 'terror chief'. Our list of scores to settle with Mughniyeh is long. It includes the Buenos Aires Embassy bombing in 1992,  the bombing of the Jewish Center in that city two years later, the kidnapping and murder of 3 soldiers at Har Dov in 2000. The Americans also have a bone to pick with Mughniyeh; the marine barracks bombing in Beirut and the American embassy bombing in that city and the death by torture of the head of the CIA in Lebanon, Bill Buckley, who was kidnapped in 1984.

Mughniyeh served not only as the head of operations but also as the contact between the intelligence and operational branches of Teheran and Damascus.

His creative and wicked mind planned more severe and sophisticated attacks that were clearly disrupted by his death.

There are those who wonder if targeting terrorists of various ranks serve a purpose, since a replacement is often found and there are times when the rebuttal is cruel and fatal.

We must remember the following:

  • Terrorist organizations do not need the excuse of revenge to launch attacks. It is their raison d'etre.
  • The assassination of a senior terror official always arouses suspicions of his leadership and launched a search for "moles" who aided in the operation which in itself disrupts terror activity.
  • As long as senior terror officials are preoccupied with their personal survival and self-preservation, they can direct less attention to terror planning and operation.
  • Not always is there an obvious replacement for the assassinated terrorist chief; in his operational sophistication, in his professional knowledge and in his range of contacts.

This is the war on terror. There are no easy, speedy or complete victories. It is a war based on the principles of perseverance and focus. The elimination of terror leaders is a useful and essential part in this war. The more focused and precise the assassination the better since it also prevents the deaths of innocents.

It serves no purpose to discuss the question of 'who killed Imad Mughniyeh'. He had many victims, not just Israelis and Americans but other nationals, from Kuwait to Argentina. Whoever has many victims will also acquire many enemies. And whoever lives by the sword will die by the sword.

Iran and Hizbullah point fingers at us and we must act with caution and and diligence in Israel, abroad and in Jewish communities. 

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Jonathan Gray, Madrid, Spain, Tuesday Feb 19, 2008
Mr. M K Ephraim Sneh, why do you not ask yourself about the causes of these acts of violence? If you did in an honest way you might find an answer that will show you the way to find peace in your part of the Middle East. Take a good look at yourself, sir!
2  |  Educated Scientist, USA, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Mr. Gray from Spain who commented earlier, Since when is cold blooded murder of innocent people justified by any cause ? Islamic Jehadi's in particular subscribe to a primitive ignorant superstition-based mindset which sickens the civilized world.
3  |  Robert Rosenfelt, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Come now, Mr. Gray. Are you implying that the raison d'etre for the likes of Mughniyeh are somehow because of Israel's actions to defend itself? How tehn, would you expalin away his hand in the murder of the Amercian marines, the French apratroopers and many others? If a Basque seapratist denoted himself in the Prado, in your safe city of Madrid, would you chalk it up to Spain's agression and brutal occupation of the Basque homeland?
4  |  Tod Zuckerman , San Francisco, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Response to Poster #1 : Dear Mr.Gray : Assuming that you are not a Jew hater (doubtful), please be aware that simiilar comments have been made to Jews throughout the centuries , namely - it must be your fault that people hate you so much that they would do these terrible things to you. Well, Mr.Gray, please take your "root causes" , list them, one-by-one on a sheet of paper, fold it sideways, and then stick it where the sun does not shine !
5  |  Greg Berkowitz, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Mr. Gray's comment is ridiculous. He is blaming MK Sneh for the cause of terrorism, as if he (Sneh) is controlling the terrorists! Shame on Gray and the rest of the Anti-Semites who go around blaming the victim, adding insult to injury. This is the typical m.o. of his ilk to do this, and it needs to be unmasked for what it is: hatred of Israel and the Jewish people.
6  |  Devin, USA, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
MK Ephraim Sneh...Amen. Killing terrorist filth like Mugniyah is ESSENTIAL to the war on terror. The more top people you kill, the more they are replaced by less skilled, less competent underlings. This may not happen the first time out, but the more you do it, the less ability organization will have to "replace" the dead commander with a person of equal calibur. Mugniyah deserved what he got, just as Bin Laden and Nassrallah deserve the same. Anyone who claims otherwise is dellusional and cowardly.
7  |  Nuchem, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Why does it take 16 years after Argentina bombing to get him? And why act only defensively instead of offensively? And do personal hits only prevent terrorist attacks? And will you DO not SAY to change the above?
8  |  Jonathan Gray, Madrid Spain., Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
I must admit I half expected rabid comments in response to what I wrote. The point was, however, that it is useless to go down the path of the critics as it leads to nowhere. What could I have said? Make references to the Stern Group (Gang), David Ben-Gurion and so on . What you need to do is to go beyond your own hatreds and try to learn what your neighbour wants and come to agreement. Learn their culture, tradition, get to know them and step out of your blind hate. Only then will you begin to go down the path to peace.
9  |  Morton Friedman Lanham, MD USA, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
I will suggest that Mr. Gray first read the Koran. Then the public statements (and actions) of Hamas, Fatah, Hezbollah, Saudi Arabia. Might be very interesting to read the mass of literature that the Saudis flood Islamic schools with. Apparently the 'neighbor' wants no less than your total annhilation. A great beginning for a 'dialogue'. I sincerely hope that I am wrong. Please show me where I am in error.
10  |  Peter Canada, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Mr. Gray, “try to learn what your neighbour wants”? Grand Mufti al-Husayni explained it very well in his speeches on Radio Berlin during WWII: genocide. Prior to that, the neighbour clearly expressed his intentions on many occasions leading to Peel Commission that preceded Stern Gang (read before you write, Mr. Gray!) and partition was proposed for a good reason. In 1947 partition was proposed again. Guess who chose war rather than 2 states for 2 nations?
11  |  Educated Scientist, USA, Wednesday Feb 20, 2008
Mr. Gray of Spain, I'm an atheist, but I support the jews of Israel and am deeply proud of their brains, conduct and incredible restraint (most Americans feel this way too). These are not people of hate. These are educated humanist who indeed understand their neighbors and have welcomed a dialogue since before you were born. The Islamics just want to kill and take over. The Stern Gang was a sad chapter, but the Islamic attacks on the jews have been repeated ten thousand fold more. Israel reacts rather than perpetrates.
12  |  Jack Denver, Thursday Feb 21, 2008
I see that Mr. Gray writes from Spain, or as Mughniyeh and his friends would call it, al-Andalus. We'll see how much Mr. Gray blames himself and his own people when Islamic terrorists begin to attack Madrid. Oh, wait, they already have.
13  |  Jonathan Gray, Madrid , Spain., Thursday Feb 21, 2008
Correspondents 9 to 12 et al. You still have not gotten the message, or is it perhaps that you don't want to accept the truth. For every accusation you throw at the Arab/Muslim world the same can be returned. That is not the way to go about finding the road to peace. Are you all so full of hatred that you cannot learn to live in peace? Are you so full of hatred that you cannot put the past behind you and look forward to a life of harmony with your neighbours? Drop your historical past, rethink who you are , ask yourselves where you are going and finally step into the modern world.
14  |  Peter Canada, Thursday Feb 21, 2008
Since you asked the question, Mr. Gray... One of the most significant causes of Arab/Muslim terror (as opposed to Tibetan non-violence) has its roots in their barbaric values regarding the most essential aspects of what we call humanity. They hang teenagers, stone women, include amputations in their penal code and execute those accused of performing witchcraft (fairly recent events). Life is cheap. In 2006 alone more than 30,000 Arabs were killed by Arabs in Iraq.
15  |  Peter Canada, Thursday Feb 21, 2008
I mentioned history – which I sense you know nothing about and urge me to drop - to show that Arab terror and openly declared genocidal aspirations against Jews precede what you no doubt refer to, and justify by, as occupation, Jenin massacre, humiliating check-points, apartheid wall and Israel itself.
16  |  Peter Canada, Thursday Feb 21, 2008
How do you propose to negotiate with those who want you dead? How should the black people of Darfur negotiate with Janjaweed and their masters? How should have Kurds negotiated before they were gassed? When you think you just reached common ground with cannibals you discover that they value human life as an alternative to refrigeration. By the way: Love, Truth and Peace are wonderful things deserving better context than your platitudes.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

The Weekly Portion Former Deputy Defense Minister Dr. MK Ephraim Sneh comments on the headlines of the past week.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular Posts

  1. Why are Palestinian refugees different from all other refugees?
    Posted in In the Trenches by David Harris
    Wednesday Aug 06, 2008
  2. Blaming the Jews as a form of intimidation
    Posted in A Point of View by Abraham Foxman
    Sunday Aug 03, 2008
  3. Peace and the media
    Posted in The Warped Mirror by Petra Marquardt-Bigman
    Sunday Aug 03, 2008
  4. Everything in triplicate
    Posted in Israel Stories by Jeremy Cardash
    Monday Aug 04, 2008
  5. Knesset lobby group for Sderot?
    Posted in Living with Rockets by Anav Silverman
    Wednesday Aug 06, 2008

Recent Comments

Mark, Israel: Disgusting! Any corruption, any breaking of the moral norms are forgivable - if they move they us on "road to peace"?! It's that kind of moral corruption and hypocrisy that has been eating away at our society since Oslo accords were purchased at a discount price of Mitsubishi for the renegade MP becoming minister. Want to make peace? Do it cleanly and not by using dirty leverage on failed PMs!
H.H Israel: I have no idea what the shooting of Ms lautin has to do with the resignation of our PM. If this was an attempt to express Mr. Sneh disrespect to the police and the security forces in one article it is also a proof of the writer political agenda. I agree with Sneh that Olmert is innocent till proven guilty, but he is the most despised PM in Israeli history. He led Israel from failure to failure. He should have resigned after the 2nd Lebanon war and take responsibility for all the people that died in vain.
Ben Menachem: The entire political system stinks and if not changed will lead to more of the same.