Tuesday Jul 08, 2008

The Weekly Portion: Gaza communities need actions, not just words

Posted by MK Dr. Ephraim Sneh
Comments: 6
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

I spent the past week-end with my wife in the Gaza periphery. More precisely, I was hosted by my friend and fellow MK Shay Hermesh who extended the invitation to stay with him and his family at his kibbutz in Kfar Aza. The area's civilian and security problems have been known to me for some time. However, the 2 days I spent there allowed for a closer look at the reality on the ground.

The most impressive thing I noticed was the spirit of the people there. I met proud people, strong people, unpretentious people, heroes and certainly people devoid of the typical, whiny 'sense of entitlement' attitude so prevalent whithin Israeli population. A visit to a local kindergarten, whose walls were made of thick cement and whose windows were elevated and decreased in size so they almost looked like small shootout points, was enough to understand the continued difficulties such communities have endured for the past 7 years. The swings and slides stand alone in unused sandboxes since these small children are forbidden to play outside and spend their days in a room where very little sunlight comes through.

Those who wish to understand the Israeli economy's strength are advised to visit the Gaza periphery. Amid the Kassams and the mortars, top industrial factories continue to operate. Potatoes are planted up to a meter away from the road that leads directly to the border fence that separates Israel from Gaza and are picked at night so as to make life harder for snipers. From the huge packaging plant owned by the Ovitz family, agricultural products are exported to countries all over the world. Flags on display make the place look like the UN in New York and not a factory outside Gaza. Perhaps I got carried away with my colorful descriptions but there is no Israeli who is not impressed by this Zionist achievement done under the most impossible conditions.

Most cars in the Gaza periphery are adorned with large stickers of the Israeli flag with the sentences: "If I am not for myself, who will be for me?" and "The State of the Western Negev". This sticker expresses the feelings of separation and isolation people there feel from the rest of the country and the government. The main complaint is the snail's pace with which aid is provided and how little is actually offered. Added to the general lack of support and backing that is felt. As a Kibbutz Nir member who's seen hundreds of Kassams and mortar shells land near him said: "My dream is to be part of an inclusive community, not a peripheral community. When I'll say that I'm from Nir, people will say "wow" and not "poor man". Such a community would be on the front lines of a proud state, a peripheral community is neglected to the sidelines.

What brought about this situation? When I looked into some of the unsolved problems, I was met with a familiar bureaucracy. Complicated procedures, overworked legal consultants and clerks and so on. These scenarios are known to me from the time I focused governmental attention on the area, as Deputy Defense Minister. Only a ministerial authority who applies pressure on the clerks from the top can get things moving. It is my understanding that today, there is no such authority. But we mustn't hold the governmental clerks solely responsible for the alienation that Gaza periphery communities feel. Most are doing the best they can. The government's most significant error is the missed moral issue. If the government were to make a move that would obviously favor communities on the Gaza periphery, it would send a moral message to everyone. In other words, these are the favored sons of the state of Israel - people who work and create under fire. Appreciation for the work and the steadfastness should finally be demonstrated with actions and not just words.

When I determined the principles of the 'Israel is Strong' campaign, I wrote that first and foremost, "the government is responsible for the welfare of every citizen", before mentioning security or peace. As I was driving north, I realized how right I was in doing so.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Nach, Tuesday Jul 08, 2008
Dr. Sneh, you had your chance as deputy defense ministe etc.r. Why wasn't what you preach now done then?
2  |  Tod Zuckerman , San Francisco, Tuesday Jul 08, 2008
Sneh is a big phony. If he were in power , he would do the same as Olmert and Barak, namely, NOTHING. Lastly, it is a disgrace that an ex-Deputy DM advocates releasing the child murderer Barghouti - what does Sneh think Israel will gain from yet another sickening effort to appease those intent on its destruction ? Sneh himself has no idea - however, he exemplifies the Israeli quick fix/let's hope for the best rationale for appeasement.
3  |  Adina Kutnicki, Tuesday Jul 08, 2008
Let me be a little more blunt than Sneh is willing to be - a leadership which is willing, for ANY reason, to throw tens of thousands of its most productive citizens to the dogs, is capable of ANYTHING. Therefore, asking this regime to fix even a leaky faucet is to whistle past the graveyard.
4  |  Arnold - Canada, Wednesday Jul 09, 2008
Gen. Sneh, I would have thought THE thing the Israeli govt should do for those living near the border with Gaza is to re-take the other side of the border, & hold the land from which rocket & shooting attacks on Israelis are being carried out, in order to prevent such attacks. Isn't this possible? Risk to soldiers within Gaza would have to be weighed relative to the risks faced & continuous harm suffered by Israelis near the border. What you describe here, plus the attacks on Sderot, etc. would seem to show the former risks justified. Why hasn't the govt done what is needed?
5  |  Irving Newton, Friday Jul 11, 2008
A leadership that is willing to cede Israel to be 8 miles wide and give up 40% of its drinking water to a terrorist state (syria), AND take in stuffed envelopes under the table (olmert) plus 5 criminal investigations-deserves to be in Jail- not Jews who defend theselves againts arab attacks (who are put in jail by this government. It has gotten so bad that poilice are afraid to shoot the terrorist & instead it took a solider citizen to the do the job the police are PAID to do. Instead the police enjoy taking their horses & arresting ZIONists- of course they took credit for killing terorist
6  |  criticstan Florida U.S., Friday Jul 11, 2008
Dr Sneh, I encourage you to form your own party, or bring a faction into likud. You were well received at by many at AIPAC.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

The Weekly Portion Former Deputy Defense Minister Dr. MK Ephraim Sneh comments on the headlines of the past week.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Top Rated Posts

Most Commented Posts

  1. Israeli Arabs need new leadership
    Posted in The Weekly Portion by MK Dr. Ephraim Sneh
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  2. It's the Palestinians' loss
    Posted in Window on Israel by Ira Sharkansky
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  3. Israel's 'Wild West' tendencies
    Posted in Center Field by Gil Troy
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  4. No place for political objectors
    Posted in Point / Counterpoint by Edwin Bennatan
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008

Recent Comments

Isaac B: This kind of thinking is the only thing that will allow the Israeli Arab problem to be worked out. However they con only receive the benefits of being part of the stat if they take up full responsibility for the duties of the state. The distrust most people will feel towards them means that this type of thing should come in incrementally, and be pushed forward with the meeting of performance benchmarks.
Ken Besig, Kiryat Arba, Israel: Israeli Jews need a new leadership too, one that is Zionist, proud, and intelligent, unfortunately, Dr. Sneh, his Labor Party, and much of the Kadima misleadership doesn't have any of these qualifications and much of the time can be found financially and politically supporting the most dangerous and radical Israeli Arab leadership. Indeed, an Arab Knesset member from Sneh's own Labor Party refuses to sing or stand up for Israel's national anthem, and has even characterized himself as an Arab and a Moslem first and foremost, and lastly as an Israeli, and a Palestinian Israeli at that.
John Reilly: When Israeli Arabs show the same kind of loyalty to Israel which Druze Arabs and Bedouin Arabs have demonstrated, then, and only then, should they receive a fair portion of Israel's highly advanced political, economic, educational, and social amenities.