JPost.com  »   BlogCentral  »  Rosner's Domain
Monday Nov 10, 2008

Rosner's Domain: Bill Clinton as special Mideast envoy?

Posted by SHMUEL ROSNER
Comments: 8
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

I didn't see this Financial Times' piece but Marty Peretz did. Apparently, it was published Friday, and was calling on Barack Obama to appoint Bill Clinton ASAP to be the special envoy for Middle East peace (as we all know, Clinton must be the man since he had such great successes). Anyway, here's Peretz:

A special envoy for the Middle East is an old hat idea.  In fact, it is not exactly an idea and certainly not a new idea. By my count, there have been perhaps a dozen special envoys to the region in the last dozen years, perhaps more, and many of them appointed by the president of the United States as his personal representative to the disputants.  Here are the a few of the designees of the White House: Philip Habib, William Burns, Anthony Zinn, James Jones, Curtin Wilson. Didn't George Tenet also play this role for President Bush? And wasn't James Wolfenson a special rep of someone or other, as well? Then, of course, there is the present special envoy of the Quartet, come straight out of 10 Downing Street to the Middle East bazaar, Tony Blair.  Very important person, accomplished nothing.  Someone once suggested that George Bush Sr. be appointed to this prestigious office. And someone else suggested that James Baker be the one to do the miracle of Middle East peace. The problem with the last two men is that they don't much like Jews. This might be called a disqualification.

In his short piece, Peretz quotes something I wrote quite a while ago, "a special envoy for Middle East peace...is a diplomatic tool that has become a cliche, an envoy in the guise of a messiah" (it is a good line - is it not?). Most Israeli officials assumed way before the election that such envoy will be appointed as way of showing "involvement" in the peace process (the involvement presumably lacking during the Bush years), and Clinton's name was bound to come up, as the "envoy" scheme is also a tribute to the peace making days of the Clinton era.

And Clinton is free, and somewhat bored. And his good friend, Tony Blair, is already in the region, making peace. That's why we added Clinton's name to the list of possible envoys presented to the Israel Factor panel last week. As you can see here, the panel, generally speaking, liked the idea.

But Peretz doesn’t like it:

Bill Clinton is by now a very frivolous man. He is full of self-love and, thus, can no longer be trusted with an important public chore, as Obama must have noticed during the campaign.  It is true that Clinton is invested in the historic struggle between Israel and the fissiparous Palestinians.  It is hard to imagine that he is not still committed to the Camp David principles to which Ehud Barak committed but Yassir Arafat would not even discuss.

My guess: it will not be Clinton.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  ROSALIND FOX CAMBRIDGE MASS USA, Monday Nov 10, 2008
CLINTON WOULD BE A BRILLIANT CHOICE. PERETZ' ANIMUS TOWARDS HIM BLINDS HIM FROM SEEING THE PROFOUND KNOWLEDGE AND ENORMOUS DIPLOMATIC SKILL CLINTON WOULD BRING TO THE TABLE. THE LESSONS OF ARAFAT ARE NOT LOST ON HIM, EITHER. I BELIEVE A SECURE ISRAEL WOULD BE HIS PRIMARY VALUE.
2  |  , Monday Nov 10, 2008
3  |  Aroleflin, Tuesday Nov 11, 2008
Bill Clinton is a known liar and has been convicted of lying to a federal judge not to mention lying to his wife ever since they were married. He is a dis-barred lawyer and cannot practice law in his own state. He has committed criminal sexual acts in the White House oval office. He has lied to get elected to the presidency by lying about his marital affairs. He lied on television to 90 million television viewers about having sex with Monica Lewinsky. What does it take for someone on the left to earn disfavor from others on the left? Murder? Or is that ok too?
4  |  Brian US today, Aliyah in ten days, Tuesday Nov 11, 2008
Why can't anyone after all this time and many failures, based always on Israel bending over backwards and the Arabs just getting what they can and then continuing on and on with their terrorist proxy war, forget this peace b.s.. How about Israel do what it needs to do to establish self determination without being pressured by Nations who have their own interests at heart, and a history of antisemitism (all of them even the US). How about the next time these animals attack, the IDF crushes them, once and for all and pushes it's enemies into Egypt and Jordan where they belong.
5  |  Howard Smigel, Tuesday Nov 11, 2008
The smartest action and the most valuable contribution Obama could make upon ascending to the Presidency is to take a hands off policy vis a vis Israel and the Palestinians. Every president since Carter has come a cropper when they have stuck their noses into this morass. Obama will have enough on his plate without the Middle East. Stay away!
6  |  thomas, Tuesday Nov 11, 2008
I think Bill Clinton would be an asset to the Obama Administration's foreign policy objective, and I also think that both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama would be flexible and more favorable for Israel. Bill Clinton is a most needed personality in the U.S. State Department.
7  |  Esav Benyamin - US, Tuesday Nov 11, 2008
Slogans and figureheads will not solve the underlying problem, which is the unresolved hostility of the Arab-Muslim world towards the State of Israel. A strong American leader, speaking privately with influential Arab-Mulsim leaders might insist on such a resolution. Until then, Israel does crisis management, its Arab enemies live in a fantasy world, and their peoples, especially the so-called Palestinians, continue to live in various states of degradation.
8  |  Erastus CoupeDeVille - Ong's Hat, NJ, Tuesday Nov 11, 2008
Hide your women!
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

Search this blog

The Israel Factor, Sep. 2009: Obama is rapidly losing favor with panel of Israeli experts

Recent Comments

Mike Feldman, Canada: Tom. In response to Rafael, you mentioned your familiarity with the leaflets, but I guess you didn't read what he said about water and food deliveries. I can see where you think if Hamas takes to hiding in civilians structures, the IDF should be obliged to wait outside until they come out and avoid property damage at all cost. It seems to me that the brave Hamas sought the protection the Geneva Conventions provides to cililians by acting as if they were civilians and hiding among civilians. You want the IDF to be responsible to the wreckless endangerment of the Gazans perpetrated by Hamas. Like Hilary RodHAM its not kosher.
Dan J USA: Tom..US 68...I heard you are trying to get a hearing on the bombing of the following cities we USA military did in WW2...Munich, Dresden, Frankfort, Berlin, Tokyo, Nagasaki, Hirsohima. Was killing all those civilians necessary to win that war. Oh well, I suppose that if a nation is attacked they should expect to be hit back ! Israel, by bashers like you is not allowed that priviledge! Aren't we in the USA fighting those same guys in Iraq and Afghanistan...By the way Tommy ole bean does the US military send out "warnings to the Taliban before attacking them. They do have e mail.
Leroy Padmore,Liberia: They called themself human watchdog,watching over what?Israel so the terroristic group should killed the jewish people?let me tell the world something these are not like the days of Hilter,no no no.if you killed a Jew, you will be kill too .if you fire rockets into Israel believed it or not Israel will hit back big time.I my wife and children love Israel to our death.we will tell it to our childrens children.every single day we pray for Israel and the peace of Jerusalem.we blessed Israel with our pray.we are standing with Israel.let the Star of David fly high.SHALOM.
Archives