|
Thursday Jul 24, 2008
Life and death on King David street Posted by Rabbi Michael Marmur
Comments: 25
For much of my adult life I have studied, taught and worked on King David Street in Jerusalem. It is certainly no ordinary work address. World leaders stay there - in recent months we have played host to Bush, Blair, then Bush again, Blair, Rice, Blair Carter, Sarkozy, Blair (I'm beginning to think that man has nothing better to do), Brown, Mc Cain, Obama - and that doesn't do justice to the tens of less famous officials - Fishing Ministers from Ruritania and Tax Inspectors from Uzbekhistan. Then there are the Life Cycle Events. Families compete with each other to hold the most opulent and often gaudy events: barmy Bar Mitzvahs, wild weddings, and far from circumspect circumcisions. And let's not forget the welcome crush of tourists, staying in comfort and often returning home with some expensive artifacts purchased at one of our street's many upscale emporia. More hotels are on the way, along with a plethora of swanky apartment buildings aimed at visionaries and speculators. It is perhaps a surprise that one of the street's most famous and significant landmarks is the YMCA, an oasis of dialogue and culture and encounter and health. If you've never been, you owe it to yourself to drink in the architectural attractions, climb to the top of the tower, and stop off for a Pilates class at the same time. Jews and Arabs (both Muslim and Christian) feel at home at the YMCA. Over the last years King David Street has also played host to the Annual Gay Pride parade. Visitors to similar events might mistake the throng of men dressed in police uniform walking by the YMCA as some kind of hommage to the Village People, but in our city's parade they are actually policemen, on hand in order to protect the crowd from the taunts of those who combine theological certainty with personal insecurity. A variety of Jewish institutions grace the street: on avenues nearby some of the most important foundations and philanthropic agencies are to be found. AIPAC is across the street. The Gesher Institute is opposite my own institution, the Hebrew Union College, and our campus plays host to Merkaz Shimshon and Bet Shmuel - the world headquarters of the Reform Movement. In recent years an Ultra-Orthodox Yeshiva has opened up in close proximity. With the international center of Conservative Judaism a couple of blocks away, we are arguably situated in the most denominationally diverse address in the Jewish world. It is truly the High Street of the Jewish People. The street is no stranger to acts of violence. The most spectacular and deadly event took place back in 1946, with the notorious attack on the street's most famous eponymous hotel. 45 years later, a planned suicide bombing succeeded in killing the man with the explosive jacket, but no innocent victims. And now, earlier this week, King David Street saw the second example in as many weeks of Tractor Terror. A man driving a construction vehicle started ramming and squashing vehicles, although he was killed before he managed to kill anyone else. Five of my students were in close proximity to the attack this week. Four of the College's Israeli students were enjoying a break at a local café, and were afforded a grandstand view of the grim and swift proceedings. More directly still, one woman recently arrived from the US on our Year in Israel Program found herself directly behind the tractor. As soon as the gunshots began to ring out she took cover behind a tree. Once the emergency was over, she dusted herself off and went to her apartment. When I saw her soon after she was shaken but not stirred, and we spent some time talking about her road to the Rabbinate. For her and hundreds of others, the first Road to the Rabbinate is King David Street. When I passed the scene of the attack a couple of hours later, an assortment of characters had shown up - a Government Minister in search of a photo opportunity, and some Kahanist crazies in search of a hatred opportunity. Chabad were also there for some reason, with a large banner promising Messianic days. Somehow the bizarre nature of the scene seemed natural in a road in which the incongruous is inevitable. Those who try to bring death to this place of life will not succeed, even if (Heaven forbid) a future attack yields casualties. Somehow the untidy yet intense drama being played out in the street - Jews and Arabs, locals and tourists, Liberals and Traditionalists, wealthy and modest - must not be curtailed. It may have its tractors and its detractors, but the spirit of King David Street cannot be bulldozed.
1 |
Cheryle Tacher San Juan, Puerto Rico,
Thursday Jul 24, 2008
Having just left King David Street which has become my 'home' during the summer for the past three years, I feel as though the terrorist has invaded my own livingroom. What he will never know, is that he, and others like him, serve to strengthen my resolve to make Jerusalem my permanent place of residence. They can't break my spirit either as it has become one with the magical stones upon which I step as I study and pray and shop surrounded by the beauty of this historical street.
2 |
Rabbi Daniel,
Thursday Jul 24, 2008
Dear Rabbi Marmur, we were really hoping you were going to address the issues brought up in the Jack Wertheimer article about Reform Judaism today. As a leader in the Reform world, you owe it to us - your loyal readers - to explain why Reform Judaism is failing us as a whole and what justification you can give for continuing to head such an institution. The spirit of King David St. will continue without this article, but if you do not have remedies to the above article, the Reform movement may just be bulldozed along with your theological uncertainty and wishfull personal security.
3 |
nuchem,
Thursday Jul 24, 2008
you mean all I have to do to write nonsense and get paid for it is to become dean of reform college.
make way,
4 |
Sam Bluefarb,
Friday Jul 25, 2008
Do you really mean that those who are Traditionalists are "insecure"?
5 |
john boy,
Friday Jul 25, 2008
may the true and living god bless the jews. AMEN
6 |
Carol-Maryland,
Friday Jul 25, 2008
Two years ago I had the opportunity to visit with my daughter in Israel when she was a first year student at H.U.C. The war in Lebanon broke out the day we returned home. I worried for her safety and she informed me not to worry, that things never happen in Jerusalem. I appreciated the way you comforted the first year student and I am sure her family is shaken but grateful.
7 |
Lloyd,
Friday Jul 25, 2008
Cheryle (1), many thanks for what thus far (to 4) is the only relevant and thoughtful comment in response to Rabbi Marmur's blog. These are regrettably few and far between, but well appreciated by me and others who read the comments.
8 |
Neil Ambercrombie,
Friday Jul 25, 2008
Reform Judaism will go the way of the Karaites, Saducees, Essenes, etc. as soon as all of the Reform Jews completely assimilate. History has a way of repeating itself.
9 |
John Preller South Africa,
Saturday Jul 26, 2008
I'm not sure what you mean when you write "by those who combine theological certainty with personal insecurity" but my understanding is that there is clear judgement against homosexual activities in all scriptures.
10 |
Daniel,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Lloyd, with all due respect, one does not have to agree with the writer inorder to be thougtful or relevant. As a member of the Reform movement, I would expect you to be a little more tolerant and respectful of differing views......even if they disagree with yours. I questioned the good rabbi why he does not address a more pressing and relevant issue as nuchem as well pointed out that the article itself is just bland and meaningless (no great words of wisdom unfortunatly). and Sam took exception to the Rabbi's absurd and condescending comment that traditionislts are insecure.
11 |
Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Hi, Neil (#8), while your prediction may be accurate, may I ask why you posted it? If you are more traditional / religious, the thought such a terrible loss should be horrible. If so, wouldn't you want to be a part of the solution? A respectful dialogue because you care--if you truly love G-d--might possibly help; insults will only encourage others to assimilate however, because who wants to be connected with a nasty group who only want to be holier than thou, anyway? Shalom
12 |
Daniel,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Shalom, I disagree with your post. An honest person who is Reform will at times read such a comment and take the words to heart. A Reform Jew must understand that there has been a very sad precedent to the Reform movement and all of these movements only lasted a few hundred years. Unfortunatly, they have been denied a Jewish education all of their lives and they should take their clergy to task. A reader should ask himself why Rabbi Marmur shies away from discussing the Jack Wertheimer article about Reform which confirms all this. This is not a case of holier than thou....
13 |
Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Hi, Daniel, while your post is true, the question is whether a Reform Jew who is unaware of "the very sad precedent" because "they have been denied a Jewish education all of their lives" will react well to that kind of post. It seems to me that in most cases the "honest person who is Reform" will say that the writer is ....(fill in the unpleasant words of your choice)... and ignore anything they have to say. I would also be interested in reading Rabbi Marmur's response to the Wertheimer article. (kol hakavod for being polite in using his title in this context) Best wishes, Shalom
14 |
daniel,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Shalom, You see, there is hope for us insecure backward right wing (fill in the blank) after all. But, I disagree. The honest Reform Jew will accept the truth from who it comes from. When they see that the form of Judaism that they have been fed is empty and not fulfulling and then they read these posts that this is not authentic Judaism, they will seek out the truth. But, other fine people like Lloyd will be offended....can't please them all.
15 |
Lloyd,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Ah, Daniel, (10) it is not a question of agree or disagree but of having some relationship with the subject matter of the blog which is what relevance is about. (12) you believe that reading (another) prediction of the imminent demise of the reform movement will suddenly cause me to repent and become orthodox? Because history repeats itself? Like you know what will be in a few hundred years? Like in the past Jews never went through periods of evolution in thought and practice (with traditionalists such as yourself predicting the worst all the while)?
16 |
Lloyd,
Sunday Jul 27, 2008
Shalom, thanks as always for your kind words although I am disappointed you wish to acquiesce to Daniels assertion that we Reform Jews have all been denied a Jewish education. Be that as it may, your plea for respectful dialogue is appreciated as always. I will have to bow out for a few weeks now, may you all enjoy respectful dialogue in my absence. By the way, I also might enjoy Rabbi Marmur's response to the Wertheimer article - but if and when he chooses to write about it, and not in response to attacks as in (2) above. Meantime, how about some comment about what he did write?
17 |
Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ,
Monday Jul 28, 2008
Hi, Lloyd, I used quotation marks to attempt to make the point to Daniel that if I grant him what he believes, he should see that a change in tone is in order. Having said that, I have to say that in the US the characterization is largely accurate--which is Wertheimer's point. While Rabbi Marmur has a pleasant writing style, I think that this was a weak effort. It seems to me that in his understated way he is equating the Irgun action and the suicide bombers, which is intellectually dishonest, and saying that Chabad is among those bringing death, like the Kahanists. Best wishes, Shalom
18 |
Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ,
Monday Jul 28, 2008
Hi, Daniel, I guess I would have to ask if you have seen evidence that supports your belief that some Reform people respond positively to that type of post. It seems to me that you have complained in the past that people have reacted negatively, so perhaps you might rethink your position on it. I think most people have enough pride to reject those they perceive as insulting or unplesant even if they do have a desire to learn or change. You might want to read 'How to Win Friends and Influence People' by Dale Carnegie. Kol Tuv, Shalom
19 |
daniel,
Monday Jul 28, 2008
Lloyd 15 - That's plain silly.I was challenging Rabbi Marmur to stay relevant to the days issues which are pressing. After all, this is a reform blog - not about terrorisim. It's simple amazing that as a leader of Reform is Israel cannot face a scathing report on the failures of his community. When Reform was invented 200 years ago, the traditionalists predicted the consequences of the movement. So I guess our leaders are quite capable of seeing the future. After all, it wasn't the first time it happened in history.
20 |
Daniel,
Tuesday Jul 29, 2008
Shalom - I'll be in Princeton in about two weeks - (my daughter is taking college tests) for three hours 6-9 in evening. I understand Cherry Hill is not far away. Would you like to meet somewhere? I would really enjoy to meet you. I don't bite in person....If not, I understand as well. Up to you....
21 |
Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ,
Tuesday Jul 29, 2008
Hi, Daniel, I certainly wouldn't mind meeting you, depending on the day and time. You can email me at sgittler@yahoo.com. Good luck to your daughter on her tests. Shalom
22 |
H Jerusalem,
Tuesday Jul 29, 2008
In response to the posts that seize an opportunity to attack the perspective of a Reform rabbi, I feel obligated to point out that this is a wonderfully-composed article with an invigorating message, and as an Orthodox resident of Jerusalem I recommend appreciating the Rabbi M's positive words and taking his political references with a pinch of salt and a sense of humour.
23 |
Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ,
Wednesday Jul 30, 2008
Hi, Daniel, I responded with my email address this morning, and don't see it, so perhaps the moderator didn't want to include it. I'd be happy to get together with you, if time and schedule allows it. If you call Rabbi Rhine he can give you my email or telephone number. Good luck to your daughter--should I express surprise that she's taking college tests? By the way, I'm a lot nicer online than in person.
Shalom
24 |
Daniel,
Wednesday Jul 30, 2008
H from Jerusalem, we agree totally with Rabbi Marmur and we appreciate his deep penetrating message as always We are just somewhat perplexed why Rabbi Marmur who heads Reform does not address the issues in the Jack Wertheimer article which essentially labels Reform as a failure. We are sure that the good Rabbi can defend himself and his organization with an equally wonderfully-composed article and we are anxiously awaiting his invigorating message.
25 |
Avrohom - Israel,
Tuesday Aug 05, 2008
"With the international center of Conservative Judaism a couple of blocks away, we are arguably situated in the most denominationally diverse address in the Jewish world. It is truly the High Street of the Jewish People". Hahahaha! Keep hallucinating!
|
Top Rated Posts
Tags:Blogroll |