Needed: Ministry of Home Front Security

The public debate following the Second Lebanon war does not stop. The discussion is undertaken by various commissions, in governmental, military and civilian frameworks, within groups and individually. It has become the most significant public discourse, starting with politicians and reaching idlers and market peddlers. Usually, the various reactions can be identified in advance according to socio-economic groups, while everyone waits for the final Winograd report.

Even so, I still dare use a general expression that characterizes almost all conclusions, and in my opinion, will also be the fate of the Winograd report, that is "hindsight vision is always 20/20". Therefore, it will not influence nor change the political and coalition-based situation in the government.

About this blog

Ravitz's Quiet Revolution UTJ MK Rabbi Avraham Ravitz offers a glimpse of the arena from his own perspective.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Velvel silver spring:

Dear Rabbi, I recently read of rumors that you may join Olmert's government due to political concessions he would make regarding organ transplants, as well as a "gift" of additional millions of shekels for your Torah institutions, a gift which really amounts to a bribe, don't you think? I just want you to know, that regardless of what your smiling nodding Chareidi drones accept or don't accept from you, I am a Torah observant Jew and if you do that, you are selling out Israel and selling out Jews all over the world by taking this bribe. Hashem is supposed to provide our sustenance.

Adam:

You better learn to teach other Charedim to stand opposed soon because one day there won't be enough secular and traditional Israelis to aid the religious Zionists in the IDF to protect the lazy free-riding Jews in the Kollels. They may be broke, but at least they have Torah!

So now we have tons of impovrished Jews supported by donations and government money. Money which can go to better places to aid Klal Yisroel like kiruv, medical research and a LIVABLE WAGE for the small percentage of Jews who would be an asset for Yisroel to learn for a living.

Just as society benefits from the best and brightest teaching in universities and sharing their knowledge, Jewish society derives a similar benefit from the best and brightest learning in Yeshivas. Unfortunately, those that are actually that bright make up a tiny proportion of those who learn full time. It is a selfish act if one does not excel in learning Torah yet does so for a living. Those selfish Jews can be of better use to themselves, their families and Klal Yisroel with a job and to learn part time and build more Nahal Charedis.

Ravitz, you should be ashamed of yourself to suggest bringing the bane of Eretz Yisroel's existence even closer. They brought this on themselves and you want to bring them on us. I guess its easy for you to say something so suicidal as the majority of your supporters have no idea what it is like to pick up a gun and protect Jews.

Dan Friedman:

They say war is too important to be left to the generals. How much more so rabbis?