Sunday Aug 31, 2008

Modesty Blasé: The pink blackberrys

Posted by Modesty Blasé
Comments: 15
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

Frum women dangle. Their car keys, usually attached to photos of their children and grandchildren, their house keys, iPod, supermarket card and gym locker tokens are all hanging off them. In one hand they are holding clunky wallets brimming with credit cards, dry cleaning receipts, parking tickets and cash. In the other, they are clutching onto an important database of sociological data currently held on the SIM card of their mobile phone. Find the phone and you will unlock all the important numbers a woman needs to know: shaytel macher, kosher butcher, mikvaot, rabbi, my cleaner and her sister in Poland

However, one item sits on the other side of the electronic mehitzah - the Blackberry. This symbol of manly achievement eludes most frum women, for it symbolises corporate power and importance. It means you've got a well-paying job.

However, this may all change now that the pink Blackberry has been launched in the UK. If a woman's accoutrements are her calling card, then surely the pink Blackberry will become a lifestyle item for the religous woman allowing her to retain her modest femininity while telling the world that she too, is a very important person with a very busy schedule.

Pink used to be an innocent colour: Barbie dolls, bridesmaids dresses, icing on the birthday cake. Our pinky was for pretending to be posh while holding a cup of tea and we had no idea that a pinko was a communist sympathiser.

How things have changed: now teenage girls around me are fully aware that the pink collar lapel is for breast cancer. Young mothers are dying around them, and many of these teenage girls are involved in charitable efforts to raise money for cancer research. They also know that lesbians have politicised the color pink, and that the pink pound refers to the disposable income of gay people. So, who is the pink Blackberry really for - drag queens, soccer moms or lipstick lesbians? 

Gay issues now have a prominent place on the social agenda. For example, Stonewall, a gay advocacy group recently put posters up all over the London underground railway, "Some people are gay. Get over it." When my children saw this they giggled, and then were embarrassed when they realised that I had also seen it. I am being forced to discuss these issues with my children at a relatively young age, long before they have had a chance to understand their own sexuality, let alone begin to understand how Judaism views homosexuality.

The media is a prominent vehicle for promoting a gay lifestyle: on YouTube, Lizzy the Lezzy, an English-born Israeli is emerging as a gay icon. In her feature, Lizzy the Lezzie does Gay Israel, she poses the question, 'Why is it good to be gay in Israel?' An attractive woman replies, 'Because there are so many gorgeous girls.'

Thousands of young girls are listening to Katy Perry's popular track, 'I kissed a girl.' The lyrics are very provocative and disturbing:

I kissed a girl, and I liked it.
The taste of her cherry chapstick.
I kissed a girl, Just to try it.
I hope my boyfriend don't mind it.

No, I don't even know your name,
It doesn't matter, you're my experimental game,
Just human nature. it's not what good girls do,
Not how they should behave.

I kissed a girl, and I liked it.

Us girls we are so magical,
Soft skin, red lips, so kissable,
Hard to resist, so touchable.
Too good to deny it...

Now I know why some parents only let their children listen to Uncle Moishy.

But I don't live in a bubble and our frum teenagers know a lot more about homosexuality than we can even imagine. The conversation in the religious community tends to focus on male homosexuality, and is usually summed up in a couple of sentences: 'Homosexuality is forbidden by the Torah. You can't be religious and gay.' The fiasco surrounding the Gay parade in Israel, or formal Jewish participation in Gay parades abroad distracts attention from the day to day, and often poignant struggle of religious Jews who realise that they are gay. 

I want to know how parents are discussing the complexities of this situation with their daughters, particularly just before they go to 'sem' on their gap year after high school. Eighteen-year-old girls, away from home, are very vulnerable and research has shown a high incidence of eating disorders in the close confines and somewhat  pressurized world of the religious seminary. What about sexual experimentation in such an environment where access to boys is usually quite limited? The rules of 'shomer negiah'  (the touching of the opposite sex which is forbidden before marriage) certainly don't apply.

Being slightly pinko myself, I try not to judge people's personal relationships and I don't want my children to be homophobic, racist or sexist. If biology is destiny, then surely we are obligated to support a religious person who acknowledges their homosexuality and does not want to lead a double life that will inevitably end in tragedy for all those he or she duped. Nevertheless, a gay religious person is also destined to a life on the margins, whether that be within their own community or when they venture out into the general society that may not understand their religious convictions. Do we want our children to have conventional married lives merely because it removes the angst of not belonging?  

So, until our daughters are married they may just have to settle for a pink Blackberry which advertises itself as  "the phone that gives you everything you need - without sacrificing everything you want."  Yes, the pink Blackberry may just be the man that every single frum woman is waiting for.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  YP in Bait Shemesh, Sunday Aug 31, 2008
Please do not count my reading of this inane blog as a show of support - I was curious if there was anything of value here and there was not. If this blog was viewed 101 times this month please correct that to 100. This kind of blog makes me think that the JPost likes to 1) do its share to weaken people's positive connection to an orthodox lifestyle and 2) throw up on the web any blog\editorial\racy picture in order to get readers - which makes the JPost a US News & WR wannabe serious news) with one foot in the tabloid world. If she has personal issues with her orthodoxy, get help, DON'T BLOG.
2  |  Avrohom - Israel, Monday Sep 01, 2008
The blogger writes, "If biology is destiny, then surely we are obligated to support a religious person who acknowledges their homosexuality". Forunately, we know with certainty in Torah that biology is not destiny and that all mitzvot are within reach and natural for all people. Baruch sh'hivdilanu min a toyim.
3  |  Chava, UK, Monday Sep 01, 2008
YP and Avrohom, I couldn't disagree more. Modesty is engaging with real issues in the Orthodox world, be it acknowledging homosexuality in the community, or women's necessarily complex relation to work and family life. I'm glad she's writing about this stuff; your responses seem rather blinkered.
4  |  Susan in Florida, Monday Sep 01, 2008
The Torah has a definite view on homosexuality and anyone who calls themself orthodox needs to know, that the Torah forbids homosexuality. While males are specifically forbidden and it is called an abomination, female homosexuality is considered prostitution. If the Torah forbids something, it means that people may have the urge to do the thing but they also have the ability to overcome the urge. Just like the Torah forbids stealing and murder- people may have the desire to steal or murder but the Torah is telling us that it is wrong. Homosexuality is an illness, not a right.
5  |  sarit, Monday Sep 01, 2008
YP--nobody forced you to read it. Other frum Jews may not have their heads stuck so far down in the sand as you, and the writer is correct--these are issues that confront our children, so isn't it better to prepare them for the issue than let them be ambushed by it? Avrohom, we need to address how we reconcile Ahavat Yisroel with our people who are born gay and lesbian -- and they are BORN that way, much as one is born with Down's Syndrome or blue eyes or cerebral palsy or red hair. Punishing them for being the way they are is not the answer. Hatred and contempt aren't either.
6  |  Susan in Florida, Monday Sep 01, 2008
I wanted to add that in the America, there is a strong pro-gay voice in the media and in Left wing society in general, and anyone who doesn't agree with them is considered "NOT COOL". The gays have convinced people that theirs is a valid alternative lifestyle and the power of suggestion spreads this deviant behavior. There are organizatons such as NAARTH and YONAH which counsel people who wish to refrain from gay behavior and understand what motivates it. Unfotunately, the breakdown of the family unit and widespread sexual deviance are undermining Torah values in the US and elsewhere.
7  |  Dan J USA, Monday Sep 01, 2008
With all the tzouris we Jews have.."frum" Ortho to reform and don't forget the secular..we have this pink I pod? Oi vey. The perrenial pogromchiks are out there want to destroy us and we have to worry about homosexiality? Iran and the clone of Hitler are walking the globe again. Thats what we Jews (and the Western civilization) should worry about.
8  |  Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ, Monday Sep 01, 2008
To Avrohom and YP, I heard a tape by R' Avigdor Miller in which he spoke about the issue. He mentioned an Orthodox Rabbi who was gay, who refrained from any forbidden activity, and who became a longtime Rabbi of a small community that could not keep Rabbi's because of the dayschool issues that would arise. As he never married and had kids, this wasn't a problem, and he helped the community to grow larger and stronger. This is a kiddush Hashem, and an argument for how one can support a religious person who acknowledges the issue, within halacha--don't you agree? Shalom
9  |  MG, Englewood, NJ, USA, Tuesday Sep 02, 2008
I must say, I agree a bit with everyone here. (The old Fiddler on the Roof - you're BOTH right!) My issue is with Modesty's amateur "writing voice". We started talking about a Blackberry and segued into homosexuality. Ok, so the JPost wants a blog from a frum women's viewpoint. Kol HaKavod. But this is the best writer they could come up with? And frankly, ANYONE frum or otherwise, who wants their children to grow up with an appreciation for good music should ban Uncle Moishy from their home, permanently.
10  |  Modesty Blase, London, Tuesday Sep 02, 2008
A few rejoinders: 1. If you read my blog carefully, I am not advocating nor supporting a gay lifestyle. I am trying to raise an issue that touches the lives of more people than the Orothodox community is willing to acknowledge 2. I am in fact very happy being an observant Jew - if other people choose to project their unresolved issues and ambivalencies onto me, then perhaps it is they who might benefit from therapy. 3. Some of you have no sense of humour, or at least the ability to laugh at the innocent foibles of others 4. I'm not SUCH a bad writer for an amatuer. My segues are creative.
11  |  MG in Englewood, NJ, USA, Tuesday Sep 02, 2008
Point taken on your writing:-) At least you don't claim to be a music critic!
12  |  Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ, Wednesday Sep 03, 2008
Hi, Modesty, I think that you write very well, as well as raise some important issues. In fact, your blogs are better than most of the columns in the paper itself. Shalom
13  |  Jason, Wednesday Sep 03, 2008
Modesty, you are doing a great job, please do keep it up and dont be discouraged by those intolerants who attack you on this blog. You raise an interesting point which merits much discussion. Unfortunately, however, i need to get back to work! :)
14  |  Modesty Blase, Thursday Sep 04, 2008
Dear Shalom and Jason and of course anyone else who agrees with them. Your kind words are much appreciated - it's a lonely road, so it's good to have some fellow travellers. And MG - I think you might like me more than you imagine.
15  |  HW Jeru, Saturday Oct 04, 2008
I'm curious - if homosexuality is something that a person's born with, then how comes most gays "come out" during their college years? Nice attempt at sounding liberal MB, but unfortunately your blog cannot adequately contest your ambitious point of view.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Modesty Blasé

And G-d created Modesty. And Modesty grew up to be an Orthodox Jewish housewife and mother in London. She has a Pesach kitchen and a Polish cleaner. Her skirts are long and she often sports a trendy baseball cap with a fake ponytail. But lately, Modesty has been having some doubts. This is her commentary.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. A moral army
    Posted in Army Life by A.J.
    Monday Nov 17, 2008
  2. Ben Hur loves Zion
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008
  3. Yes we can (stop talking about Obama)
    Posted in Majoring in Aliyah by Lahav Harkov
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008
  4. Expectations from Sderot
    Posted in Living with Rockets by Anav Silverman
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008
  5. An unfortunate drop of discrimination
    Posted in Israel Stories by Jeremy Cardash
    Thursday Nov 20, 2008

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ: Hi, David, My question about the application of 'Daas Torah' is whether it covers ALL topics that touch our lives? For example, does it necessarily apply to whether one should have moved from Poland to No America in the early 20th century? Why should it deal with teaching science--such as whether there were dinosaurs and the age of the universe? Rambam wrote in Moreh Nevuchim that one should study physics before metaphysics, but much of today's 'daas Torah' is to teach as little science and math as possible. How does this make sense? Shalom
Jason: David (83) as in Daniel's case you have an answer to deal with any discrepencies in your hashkafa/world view; its amazing what a talmudic mind will produce.I find that academics and secularists are more likely to acknowledge deficiencies in their specific approaches (as they will not claim that they are necessarily God given/sanctioned). If the gedolim failed us during the Shoah then its b/c God blinded them (Daniel). If some chacham "did not turn out so well" its because of their enormous evil inclinations (David). Or my favourite, if things dont turn out right, its because God is testing us.
DJStahl, USA: Daniel, I'd be glad to look at the sources you mention. You can email me at DJStahl1000@AOL.com