Monday May 12, 2008

Eye on Lebanon: Hizbullah's temporary triumph

Posted by A.M.
Comments: 12
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

All pictures in this entry were sent to me by friends and colleagues in Beirut. A.M.

As I start to write this post, a friend wrote to say that,


The fighting has spread throughout the country. In Tripoli and Akkar in the north, Sunnis are fighting and killing Alawites and vice versa. Hizbullah and the Druze PSP have been settling scores in the Chouf Mountains just east of Beirut, including heavy shelling. Muslim-on-Muslim, Sunni-Shi'ia violence has broken out in the ancient cities of Sidon and Tyre in the south and the Bekaa Valley near the Syrian border. The way it looks now, things will be getting a lot worse before they get any better; the dieing continues. To date, the minority Christian population and the Palestinians have managed to stay out of the fighting. However, with would-be president General Michel Aoun gloating on TV yesterday about the successful siege of Beirut having "put the cart back on the right track" and that we can now return to business as usual, it seems to be only a matter of time before his predominantly Maronite Free Patriotic Movement starts taking some flack from the utterly humiliated Sunni and Druze population."

In these past few days I've spoken to many people in Lebanon . The division could not be clearer. Some were glad that Hizbullah and Amal took the streets. Well, they were glad that the above-mentioned private armed forces took, and I quote, "Hariri's gang down", "cleared the streets of PSP and Future Movement thugs", and that Hizbullah protects the country against conspirators that want to transform it into a second Iraq. Oh boy!

Others said that Hizbullah revealed its true colors by turning their arms against fellow citizens, the same ones that offered the Shias shelter in July 2006. Moreover the army did not lift a finger against Hizbullah, pretending it plays the neutral role. Don't forget that General Michel Suleiman was appointed by the Syrians.

Conspiracy synopsis

March 14 sides with the United States (indirectly Israel) and the treason of this illegal government went as far as to betray the holy resistance, Hizbullah. Who did it? All of March 14, but Jumblatt and Hariri were the spokespersons. They (allegedly) revealed crucial information about the telecommunication networks and Sheikh Nasrallah to those who want to bury the resistance, and get rid of  Nasrallah in the fashion of Mousawi and Sheikh Yassin. The communication network is yesterday's news. This network is for years in Lebanon. Prior to the July conflict, Hizbullah updated it, and ever since it is in continuous expansion. The government knew, the army knew, and of course all the countries affiliated with either one group knew about it. The understanding was that as long as Hizbullah does not extend it to Christian, Sunni and Druze areas, everything is peachy.

Add to the list the disclosure that Hizbullah controls the airport. Should we be surprised that it put a man loyal to the party to manage the airport?

Hizbullah has infiltrated all state institutions. We can start with the army, the police, the intelligence services (plus Hizbullah's own top notch intelligence service), the government, the Parliament, the media. . . Shall I go on? This is a group working its way up since the early 80s. It cannot be taken down easily.

Jumblatt's recent speech was for Western consumption. If the move was made to provoke Hizbullah and Amal to resort to violence against fellow Beirutis, then the plan was successful. Hizbullah promised that it will never, ever use its weapons inside the country. This promise was broken no matter how the party tries to justify it. On the other hand, if the plan was to intimidate Hizbullah, then it failed.  

March 8 used the syndicate demonstration to take the streets. Not any streets. The road to the airport, and the streets in the vicinity of Saad Hariri's castle (really, it's a castle) in Qoreitem. There were reported clashes in Clemenceau as well, near Jumblatt's residence. That did not happen by chance, as you can imagine.  
 
A quick note about a technicality, that might be exploited in the months to come. Amal fought on the ground together with Hizbullah's regular supporters, while the trained Hizbullah army men coordinated the attacks. Aha! Therefore, Sheikh Nasrallah could say, that the party did not bring the resistance into the struggle.   

I cannot resist the temptation of saying, that I struggled (kind of) to imagine the Speaker of the House, Berri, plotting with his militia to take this street. Everyone has weapons in Lebanon, and most political leaders have a militia. Seriously now, can you imagine, the reality of Lebanon? The Speaker of the House with his own private army.

The party proves its military might on the streets, sends messages, and, as expected under current leadership, it involves the army into its plots. Still with me? Fine, because the next sentence will blow your mind (so to say).

Hizbullah and Amal took the gangs' weapons and handled them to the army, together with the areas they "secured." How splendid is that?! Do you think that Amal and Hizbullah also handed their weapons to the army? I'm sure they'd wanted to, but you see, so many conspirators in the country. . . 

Hizballah should not have said, 'my way or the highway'. That means civil war (at some point in time) followed by partition (federalism and confederalism implies a common foreign and defense policy, and this precisely is on opposite poles).

How ridiculous is it to say that March 14 works for foreign powers, when March 8 allies are Syria and Iran? Is the United States more foreign than Iran?! Or Iran more Lebanese than US?

The funny thing is that I admire Hizbullah for what it has done for the Shias. The Shias were literally put on the map by Musa Sadr and later on by Hizbullah. Amal too had a role to play. Furthermore, Shias are one step ahead of the other sects. They got rid of the feudal lords.

Resistance is a temporary solution, and the fact that in Lebanon every party I can think of, has its own private army/security firms/militia/resistance, is in itself a lack of respect for fellow citizens. I don't even dare to mention that it goes against a state of law. Which state? And what law?

Hizbullah can win a conflict, two or ten, but it will never win the war. Fact is that at the end of the day, a minority with a highly sophisticated, disciplined and loyal resistance, is still a minority. It cannot win in Lebanon, and it will never be allowed to win in the region. Will the Sunnis sit idle while Shias take over? Never.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Dennie, Tuesday May 13, 2008
And the free world waits and does nothing exactly as in the 1930's. They were hoping for democracy then too. Bush still preaches democracy to Syria, Lebanon, Iran, Iraq, Turkey, Palestine. No wonder World War 3 is getting closer and closer.
2  |  Alawi, Tuesday May 13, 2008
Please be advised that daily I read Israeli newspaper. Could please let me know : Do you like Shia or sunni won ? Fo support Sunni Muslim or Shia and why ? Do you back Regimse andwho are do they ?
3  |  Keiper, Tuesday May 13, 2008
I hope and pray the conflict does not grow. As you said, a well-armed minority is still a minority, but that doesn't mean there won't be any bloodshed as that minority tries to make it to the top. Lebanon is really one of the forgotten hot spots of the world, and it really makes me sad.
4  |  AB, NJ, US, Wednesday May 14, 2008
"A minority is a minority"? Hmm. In 1917, a party that counted just 14,000 members produced a revolution in a country of 150 million. By the same token, a street gang of 10-20 thugs will terrorize an inner city neighborhood, home to a few thousand people. Are we idealists?
5  |  AVI CHASSAN JERUSALEM, Wednesday May 14, 2008
TEROR
6  |  AVI CHASSAN JERUSALEM, Wednesday May 14, 2008
THE EYE OF LEBANON
7  |  raf from australia, Wednesday May 14, 2008
my name is raf ,it gives me a great pleasure to put few words down to you and i hope you as israel consider the problem and pass it thru to your leader.i as lebanese christian and love my country would like to say that mr olmert has not done and finish his job properly,he should have finished from nassr alla head and the shiat in south lebanon with bonbarding all the south because israel and the christians still at risk.
8  |  A.M, Wednesday May 14, 2008
AB, NJ: Agreed. A minority can terrorize a majority, which Hziballah is already doing and with results, I may add. I looked at it globally. Will the Sunnis of the region, let the Shias take over the oil (for Iran the goal is imperialistic in nature)? I don't think so. Hizballah can manage to have Lebanon transformed into a 2nd Gaza, but that's pretty much it. I believe in the power of revolutions, and the such, I don't believe that Hizballah's coup can be successful, not in the way they'd like to. Nasrallah knows that and for now they're not looking to have chaos. In the future, perhaps.
9  |  Gil Yashar - Beit Shemesh, Israel, Wednesday May 14, 2008
"Hizbullah...is still a minority. It cannot win in Lebanon, and it will never be allowed to win in the region. Will the Sunnis sit idle while Shias take over? Never." What a naive statement considering that Lebanon is just west of Syria, a country where a much smaller minority (in percentage), the Alawis rule and Syria is just west of Iraq, a country where until the US invasion, a Sunni Arab minority ruled. Unfortunately Hizbullah has a good chance and a strong charismatic leader in Nasrallah, the only Arab leader to admit erring (had he known Israel's response he would not have kidnapped).
10  |  Amnon, Jerusalem, state of Lemmings, Wednesday May 14, 2008
If Israel had leaders, not the same scum (except Shamir) who betrayed the Lebanese Christians, first in October 1990 (and remember, one A. Sharon was part of the Nazi collaborator Shamir's gov't at the time) and again in May 2000 under the gutless Ehud Barak, Hizbullah might have been crushed by now. Indeed, Israel had its chance two years ago when two boys were abducted (just like the four who were later killed after Barak's shameful retreat). Those boys are still rotting in Hizbullah torture camps while you stupid Israelis allow Olmert to remain in power.
11  |  M. A . S. SOUTH LEBANON, Wednesday May 14, 2008
MR RAF FROM AUSTRALIA , WHY ARE YOU ASKING MR OLMERT , WHY YOU DO NOT COME TO LEBANON AND TRY TO DO THE JOB .
12  |  A.M, Wednesday May 14, 2008
Gil Yashar: Hizballah can't do it in Lebanon. Don't compare Iraq and Syria to Lebanon. The struggle for the Sunnis is not even against Hizballah per se. Its against Hizballah as the Iranian implant. I liked what the Salafi from Babed Tabani, an allawi, pro-Hizballah area, did when Hizballah reached Tripoli. They allied themselves with the pro-government Salafi, saying that although they are all Muslims and hate Israel and the Christians, Sunnis will not be the servants of Shia period. So, its a different dynamic, and Lebanon is a special case.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Eye on Lebanon

Young political analyst on the ups and downs of living and working in Lebanon.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Top Rated Posts

Most Commented Posts

  1. Leaders and leadership: Is something missing?
    Posted in In the Trenches by David Harris
    Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
  2. The mental challenges
    Posted in Army Life by A.J.
    Sunday Oct 05, 2008
  3. Iran's apologists
    Posted in The Warped Mirror by Petra Marquardt-Bigman
    Sunday Oct 05, 2008
  4. Jobs for the boys
    Posted in Israel Stories by Jeremy Cardash
    Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
  5. News and features
    Posted in Behind BlogCentral by R.B.
    Sunday Oct 05, 2008

Recent Comments

yona loriner tel aviv: nah i dont see an end to this anywhere in sight!!!
jaime mexico: estan re locos todos son unos fanaticos eso no es lo que Dios quiere
Sergio Sorge: I fought in '82. So I know the lay of the land when it comes to Lebanon. Better men led us back then. I won't scapegoat just Olmert ,although it is rather easy given his apparent incompetence. The Jewish state needs new leaders, passionate about Zionism and whose hands are clean. Our cause is just and we will prevail no matter what. Shalom le kulyam.