Monday Sep 15, 2008

Koch's Comments: US safer in Obama's hands

Posted by Ed Koch
Comments: 54
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

The time has come to declare whom I will be voting for.

When I made my decision four years ago and supported the reelection of George W. Bush, I said at the time the overwhelming issue for me was international Islamic terrorism, including al-Qaida. The goal of Islamic terrorists was and still is to reestablish the Caliphate encompassing most of the Muslims living in a host of nations from Spain to Indonesia and placing them under a single religious leader with full authority over the civil affairs of the countries, in the style of Iran. That goal includes the deaths or forced conversions of Christians and Jews as infidels or the payment by them of tribute, and the elimination of the State of Israel.

In 2004, I concluded that the one person running for president who understood that danger best and was prepared to fight it and defend America and its allies was George W. Bush. Even though he is now at a low ebb in popularity, I have no regrets for having campaigned and voted for him. I said at the time I didn't agree with him on a single domestic issue and so far as I can currently see that is still true with the exception of drilling for oil off our coasts and building nuclear energy plants. 

I believe that Bush and Tony Blair, Bush's main international ally with regard to the war in Iraq and against Islamic terrorism, will be redeemed by history. President Harry Truman was reviled when he left office, but is now honored for his courage and vision.

Now, once again, I have to make a decision to either endorse the Democratic ticket of Obama and Biden or support the Republican ticket of McCain and Palin. I am 83 years old. If I am lucky, I may yet vote not only in this election, but in the presidential election of 2012 and perhaps, if luckier, even in that of 2016. I believe I must vote my conscience, and that means for the presidential candidate who in my estimation will best protect the US over the next four years.

I personally know two of those running: Joe Biden and John McCain. I like and admire them both. John McCain is a genuine war hero and patriot. Joe Biden is a friend well versed in foreign and domestic affairs, who had made judgment calls on domestic and foreign policy and legislation that I agree with. I do not personally really know the Democratic presidential candidate, Barack Obama, having spoken to him only once and briefly, or the Republican vice presidential candidate, Sarah Palin.

One foreign policy issue that particularly concerned me in 2004 was the security of Israel. I thought in 2004 that issue was better left to President George W. Bush, and I believe I was right. President Bush understood the need to support the security of Israel and did so. I did not feel that way about Senator John Kerry.

That is not an issue in this election. Both parties and their candidates have made clear, before and during this election campaign their understanding of the need to support Israel and oppose acts of terrorism waged against it by Hamas and other Muslim supporters of terrorism.

So the issue for me is who will best protect and defend America. 

I have concluded that the country is safer in the hands of Barack Obama, leader of the Democratic Party and protector of the philosophy of that party. Protecting and defending the US means more than defending us from foreign attacks. It includes defending the public with respect to their civil rights, civil liberties and other needs, e.g., national health insurance, the right of abortion, the continuation of Social Security, gay rights, other rights of privacy, fair progressive taxation and a host of other needs and rights.

If the vice president were ever called on to lead the country, there is no question in my mind that the experience and demonstrated judgment of Joe Biden is superior to that of Sarah Palin. Sarah Palin is a plucky, exciting candidate, but when her record is examined, she fails miserably with respect to her views on the domestic issues that are so important to the people of the US, and to me. Frankly, it would scare me if she were to succeed John McCain in the presidency.

I reiterate the question each of us must answer in making our choice, who will best protect and defend America, domestically and with respect to the literal defense of the country? I hope I've made the right decision but only time will tell.

Whoever wins should and, I hope, will, following the election, receive the support of all Americans, no matter how they voted, especially in these perilous times. God Bless America and the next president and vice president of the US.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Basefare, Monday Sep 15, 2008
I have liked and appreciated this man Ed Kock since before he ran for mayor of New York. What I liked about him for the most part was, I agreed with him and what I appreciated was the depth of his thinking and his clarity in voicing his thoughts. I thought he was a good mayor. I'm glad to know he has a blog and I'm glad that the JP carries it. Ed, I hope you do vote in that 2016 election. I hope too, I'll be there to supplement your vote or to counterman it. If there is a God (and we have no way of knowing) I hope he blesses Ed Koch.
2  |  Odesa, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Mr mayor. Your endorsment of Obama is well supported, and I agree. There is however one problem. Why you felt, to mention on this occasion, the importance of religious cults. Do you really think, that Jewish cults ie.:judaism and christianity have some special mission in this world? God, if one exists, have no preferences in this respect. History is proof. Cultizm and tribal ties, need to be minimized, for civilization to progress.
3  |  Yussel, Monsey, NY, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Mr. Mayor, Your "voice of reason" has become a "voice of UNreason". Mr. Obama said he would meet with the president of iran, without preconditions. If your love of Israel is so strong, how can you refuse to acknowledge the difference between a cadidate who would meet with the man who calls for Israel's destruction and the candidate who refuses to do so?
4  |  Great Plainer - USA, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
I enjoyed Ed Koch's comments very much, and his comments on more nuclear energy and off-shore drilling, I can agree with, but this is far as it goes. It appears that his choice of Presidential candidates is of a consistent quality-- wrong. I cannot see where the "Golden Mean" in social or political action can be associated very closely to either set of candidates. However, John McCain does come the closest to that ideal than any of the others. Senator Joseph Lieberman, was and still is more supportive of McCain than he is of Obama.
5  |  elliot-usa, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
no reason given for trusting obama's inexperience more than palin except a laundry list of liberal 'values' on domestic issues..it is amazing how someone as bright asmayor koch-and he is not alone-fail to recognize that liberal left values lead inevitably to tolerance of evil,are anti-religion, and lead to maling the nation weak.bush's strong response to terrorism and support for israel which led mayor to vote republican last time are conservative,not liberal;the road to peace is not thru damascus!
6  |  R. Gittens Jr., Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
America needs socialist democrats like an unborn child needs planned parenthood.
7  |  Dave, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Who is Obama? What has he accomplished besides successfully promoting himself? McCain appointed a nobody from nowhere to be his VP? Perhaps America is no longer capable of leading the free world. America is incapable of thinking past the external appearance of a candidate, and gets its politics from daytime television. America hasn't achieved anything great since it landed on the moon. Time to go to Brazil?
8  |  Hilla halevi, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
With all due respect to the ex mayor of NY- this is the shallowest article I have ever read. I do not believe that Obama government will support Israel. All his associates are pro Palestinians and to ignore it is dishonest and misleading. If Mr. Koch is scared by the possibility that Sarah palin might take McCain place – I am scared of the possibility that Obama will be elected. I trust Liberman judgment- he had more logic in his speech than Ed Koch has in this disingenuous blog.
9  |  Ger---Raanana, Israel, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Koch does not mention Brzezinski, Power, Farley, and Susan Rice, all anti-Israel, who are Obama's foreign policy advisors. He doesn't mention Rita Hauser and Jim Leach, Republicans who have endorsed Obama, but who are pro-Palestinian. There must be a reason for them to think Obama will look at the situation differently. He does not mention Biden's desire to send $200 million dollars to Iran, or his vote against the Kyl-Lieberman Amendment to declare Iran Revolutionary Guard terrorists. He doesn't mention Biden leading the fight against confirmation of John Bolton as Ambassador to the UN.
10  |  Steve Fla., Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Yussel #3, I believe you have answered your own question, as did Mayor Ed Koch in this piece. Mr. Koch's love for Israel is eclipsed by his defense of a woman's right to choose to have an abortion. The right to an abortion trumps Israel, her welfare and her security. I am not a McCain supporter -- McCain, like Bush, supports Israel's dismemberment -- nor am I an Obama supporter Let's be honest. Israel is not upper most amongst Mayor Koch's priorities.
11  |  Jo Ellen Davey Cohen, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
"So the issue for me is who will best protect and defend America?" Mayor Koch, please validate your decision to support Obama as the defender and protector of the American public interest with respect to the following issues: 1) civil rights, 2) civil liberties, 3) national health insurance, 4) right of abortion, 5) social security, 6) gay rights, 7) privacy rights, 8) progressive taxation. Please provide for the public interest Obama's record of legislative accomplishments on each of the listed issues. Obama's "Change we can believe in" is an inspirational topic for a sunday church sermon.
12  |  NIK - USA, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Extremism clothed in any religion, any race and any arena is not acceptable. Aren't there enough lessons in history to make this clear? Once EVERYONE realizes this, humanity will exist, otherwise, we're dinosaurs!
13  |  Tod Zuckerman, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Koch has not even convinced himself - jeez, this probably the most unenthusiastic endorsement in history. Reading between the lines, it is clear that Obama SCARES THE HELL out of Koch. Well, I admire and like Koch, but he knows he made a mistake : he should have exercised the same courage he displayed in 2004, and endorsed McCain. Israel will be lucky if it survives an Obama presidency, and Koch knows it.
14  |  Manny, Chicago, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Saying that the security of Israel is not an issue in these elections is irresponsible. It is more important now than ever, given the weakness of the current government in Israel, and the advance of Iran toward nuclear weapons, embolding their allies Hizballa and Hamas. McCain is a known entity, with a long record of support for Israel, with deep understanding of the middle east and terrorism. Obama is unknown, has no record, and his declarations are ambiguous. His associations with far left activists and Israel haters are suspect, to say the least. I am not takeing a chance on Israel security.
15  |  Manny, Chicago, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Saying that the security of Israel is not an issue in these elections is irresponsible. It is more important now than ever, given the weakness of the current government in Israel, and the advance of Iran toward nuclear weapons, embolding their allies Hizballa and Hamas. McCain is a known entity, with a long record of support for Israel, with deep understanding of the middle east and terrorism. Obama is unknown, has no record, and his declarations are ambiguous. His associations with far left activists and Israel haters are suspect, to say the least. I am not takeing a chance on Israel security.
16  |  yona loriner, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
kool stuff
17  |  Victor Galindo, CA, USA, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
I too am frightened by the vision of Palin becoming President. Whereas I was very much for McCain, I am now very much for the Obama/Biden ticket. Even if Palin should drop out of the race, I would not vote for McCain. He has shown that he does not have the capacity to lead the nation properly. Maybe he does not have the brains (I suspect that is the case), or his domestic views are totally opposite of what decent people should want. They are Palin's views - horrible. I do not understand Lieberman supporting Palin. I believe and hope that his political days are over
18  |  Ruth I., Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
More scary, Mr. Koch are Obama and Biden's judgment and actions post 9/11. Biden said it was "a good time to send...$200 million to Iran" and linking Al Qaeda to an ideology "is evidence of profound confusion." Obama post 9/11 raised money for Rashid Khalidi, former Arafat staffer. Obama was against the Iraq War maybe because he owed Tony Rezko for buying O's house (Rezko owed money to Nadhmi Auchi, a Saddam Hussein friend). Biden took campaign cash from a pro-Iran group, so his credibility on Iran is zero. Both are pro-Muslim appeasers and that does not make the US or Israel safer.
19  |  paul williams St Petersburg Fl, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
I agree that Obama/Biden is the better choice. Their administration will attract Americas best and brightest to address it's many problems During my 50 years in the GOP I followed the career of and admired Joe Biden. His approach to military matters and his worldview is impressive
20  |  Jack Sprat, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Race riots, Mr. Mayor, unabated, and emboldened, with the police terrified to respond.
21  |  Judah Boca Raton, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
I like the way the Mayor states that he knows Biden and McCain. He does not say that he KNOWS Barack Obama. Does anyone really know what he stands for? And what has he done, other than run for President? Though Bush made mistakes we knew where he stood. He was steadfast in his ideals and never wavered. We also know where McCaine stands. One of his first trips as the nominee was to go to Israel and show his love for the only democracy in that part of the world. Barack, on the other hand said that Jerusualem should be the capital. And backtracked soon after. He is not to be trusted.
22  |  Walt, Michigan., Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
Woe is Israel if Obama is elected.
23  |  Chad, USA, Tuesday Sep 16, 2008
You think he will protect America? Stop deluding yourself. He's said himself in one of his ads that he will "Cut military spending", "achieve deep cuts in our nuclear arsenals", "slow our development of new combat systems", etc. etc. This guy wants to destroy the military and you're saying America would be safer with him as president? What color is the sky in your world?