Monday Oct 06, 2008

Jewlicious: Today, I killed a chicken

Posted by ck
Comments: 6
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

kaparot 5769

 

As you can see from the photos - I'm being quite literal. Today was the first day of Machane Yehuda's annual Kaparot Market. Every year, Jerusalem's central market hosts this temporary slaughterhouse where those that follow the Kaparot ritual can go and kill them some chickens.

The ritual, which is performed between the end of Rosh Hashana and the beginning of Yom Kippur, involves reading Psalms, then buying a chicken, waving it around your head three times while saying 3 times "This is my exchange, this is my substitute, this is my atonement. This rooster chicken will go to its death, while I will enter and proceed to a good long life and to peace." It's kind of a controversial ritual and Rabbis are divided regarding whether or not one should do it with Maimonides saying no and the Arizal (Isaac Luria) saying yes.

But me? A dedicated vegetarian? Why do I do it? Well, I don't eat the chicken. I give it to charity. That alone justifies Kaparot. But more importantly, if these images make you squeamish, then good! For those of you meat eaters who think this is barbaric, think about that next time you chow down on a plate of wings. As a society we eat so much meat and never think about where it comes from, how it gets to our plates - that a living creature was bred and killed so that you could enjoy a yummy meal. We think even less about the environmental impact of our meat consumption.

But not me. I saw that chicken die. I was there, and while it was kind of gross, I appreciated its sacrifice and was thankful that it gave up its life so that I could do a mitzvah and help a poor family eat a meal.

Gmar Chatimah Tova!

PS: Be thankful I didn't bring a video camera

This post originally appeared on Jewlicious.com

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Betty Jerusalem, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
Barbaric custom, give money to charity instead
2  |  Ari, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
I dont recall any scriptures in Tanach that even call for the slaughter of chickens! Please help me see where.
3  |  Joseph, London, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
Kapporot with a chicken is even more controversial than Tashlich by the stream and the excessive piyutim that break up our Yomim Noraim davvening. Most people probably do Kapporot with money and give the money to charity. This is preferable to giving the poor a chicken that has taken on all your sins and possibly been shechted by an overly busy shochet. In NY and London, as in israel, there are many problems with how kapporot is done with fowl.
4  |  Ariel, Jerusalem, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
Which part of chicken kapparot is controversial here: the twirling of the bird above your head, or the ritual slaughter (shchita) and then donating it to a hungry family to eat? People eat chickens all the time without thinking how they got killed...how is kapparot any different? In fact it's a mitzva because it's going to feed a poor family...
5  |  S Judah, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
You are all getting your , how shall I put it "Chickens in a Twist " 1. The blogger is a veggi, what has being a Veggi got to do with Kapporot? Suggest you use a Soya Chicken instaed then. 2. The Rambam does not mention this subject (but I agree he would not approve). 3. Kapporot is mentioned by the Gaonim, but not with chciken. 4. The Ari Hakodash does approve and how are we better then the Ari to disagree with him? 5. The Chicken has to be slaughtered according to Halacha and is distributed to the poor - how is that wrong? 6. Using money as I just have is a good substitute.
6  |  David USA, Wednesday Oct 08, 2008
Chickens die every day. I fail to see what is barbaric about this. A shochet, even a busy one, should take care that the chicken does not suffer. The flesh of the bird is used as food, not wasted, and a ritual of significance to some takes place. Really, I think there is a beauty in the symmetry of this. How does this become less barbaric if one simply donates money which is then used to purchase a dead chicken for the needy? I personally fell that, if anything, we need more opportunities to reflect on these matters: life and death, sin and redemption, human wants and spiritual needs.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Jewlicious Jewlicious. Irreverent. Ironic. All Jew, all the time from the leading Israel/Diaspora Jewish group blog.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. A moral army
    Posted in Army Life by A.J.
    Monday Nov 17, 2008
  2. Ben Hur loves Zion
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008
  3. How did a small tribe from Samaria get all the way out here?
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Tuesday Nov 18, 2008
  4. Indian airports spell chaos
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Tuesday Nov 18, 2008
  5. Yes we can (stop talking about Obama)
    Posted in Majoring in Aliyah by Lahav Harkov
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

David USA: Chickens die every day. I fail to see what is barbaric about this. A shochet, even a busy one, should take care that the chicken does not suffer. The flesh of the bird is used as food, not wasted, and a ritual of significance to some takes place. Really, I think there is a beauty in the symmetry of this. How does this become less barbaric if one simply donates money which is then used to purchase a dead chicken for the needy? I personally fell that, if anything, we need more opportunities to reflect on these matters: life and death, sin and redemption, human wants and spiritual needs.
S Judah: You are all getting your , how shall I put it "Chickens in a Twist " 1. The blogger is a veggi, what has being a Veggi got to do with Kapporot? Suggest you use a Soya Chicken instaed then. 2. The Rambam does not mention this subject (but I agree he would not approve). 3. Kapporot is mentioned by the Gaonim, but not with chciken. 4. The Ari Hakodash does approve and how are we better then the Ari to disagree with him? 5. The Chicken has to be slaughtered according to Halacha and is distributed to the poor - how is that wrong? 6. Using money as I just have is a good substitute.
Ariel, Jerusalem: Which part of chicken kapparot is controversial here: the twirling of the bird above your head, or the ritual slaughter (shchita) and then donating it to a hungry family to eat? People eat chickens all the time without thinking how they got killed...how is kapparot any different? In fact it's a mitzva because it's going to feed a poor family...