Wednesday Apr 30, 2008

Big Jew on Campus: The big "Oh"

Posted by Ben-Zion Jaffe
Comments: 4
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

It's the sound people make when they are both dumbfounded and stripped of their dignity in one shocking motion.

"Oh."

It's the sound they make when they are curious for more information, yet feel that they have sufficient knowledge of the subject to make a conclusion before they get the bigger picture.

I first heard the perplexed "oh" when I told my English professor that I wanted to go into the field of counterterrorism after I graduate college. The "oh" definitely made sense for the woman who formed her world and political views in the 1970s and literally still wears those clothes and that attitude almost forty years later.

But she was lucky. I watered it down for her. When I am too bashful and don't want to sound like a war-mongering right-wing hawk I say, "homeland security," hoping that the use of the word homeland invokes a peaceful domestic image filled with American family values devoid of the conflict raging outside. And "security" is purely a defensive, almost passive word, not nearly as upsetting or scary as the proactivity of "counter" combined with the politically charged and volatile subject of the word "terrorism."

Sometimes the word "oh" comes as a surprise when a professor of mine hopes that I will stay in the academic world. When my British history professor was pleased with my progress in the class and asked if I would continue to research the field, especially since I had prior interest in the subject, his "oh" was less because of the political bombshell I unloaded against him, but more like a roadblock, stopping him in his tracks with a big red sign declaring "No Intellectuals Allowed Beyond This Point."

I don't think the "oh"s I get are from people opposed to what I plan on doing, but they simply are surprised, like I am going into some obscure occupation or off to a distant land that most don't venture to. After all, why would a bright student go off into a field so far removed from academia? Why engage in a discussion about such a stimulating subject such as literature or British history one moment, then in such an unbecoming and boorish topic of counterterrorism the next moment?

Part of the reason the "oh"s I get come with such surprise is because this society still is not used to the reality of terrorism and war. American society has never been able to stomach long military engagements, and the thought of domestic institutions dedicated to war is a scary thought for most, including myself.

I don't think that I get the "oh" from discontent, but rather from befuddlement. They are confused about my personal choice and life-situation and about the situation of society as a whole. When I say that scary word, "counterterrorism," it reminds them that there is a world beyond the confines of the American home and classroom, and it's not always a pretty place.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Dr. Hannah Joy, Jerusalem, Wednesday Apr 30, 2008
Ben-Zion: In the 1980's, When I was an English professor, in the States, one of my students told me that he had just finished his tour of duty with the IDF. I answered his announcement with an "oh!" I was very proud of him. Come home to Israel and enroll in one of our many fine counterterrorism programs. Our country awaits you.
2  |  Rochelle Karina, Phoenix, AZ, Friday May 02, 2008
I think you're very correct - the reaction is not one of disapproval, but one of surprise and an instinctive recoiling from that which we as Americans don't wish to face: the reality of homeland terrorism. It's a reaction born of complacency, which we can ill afford. And kudos to you for being one who isn't willing to sit idly by, but is instead ready and willing to take action.
3  |  David, New York, New York, Sunday May 04, 2008
I am also in college and many times have been asked by my grandmother and leftist aunt and uncle of what I would like to do when I finish my degree. I tell them my interest in counter-terrorism and soon hear the long explanation by my uncle of how counter-terrorism is a failed policy. When looking at this disapproval I quickly changed the counter-terrorism interest to a more soft role of homeland security. I gave in and told them I was also interested in med school. Hopefully, becoming proctologist will regain their respect
4  |  S McCosker Australia, Tuesday May 06, 2008
Jaffe - to REALLY shock them, say ''counter-jihad' and 'self-defence against the Third Jihad'. There ARE other threats - N Korea, China - but resurgent Islam is worst. Have you read: S K Malik, 'Quranic Concept of War'; Khadduri, 'War & Peace in the Law of Islam', Bostom 'Legacy of Jihad', Spencer 'Onward Muslim Soldiers'; also S Coughlin, Emerson, Joseph Myers? Know thine enemy.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Big Jew on Campus A religious moderate American student shares his take on the Holy Land.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. Israel's actions are lawful and commendable
    Posted in Double Standard Watch by Alan M. Dershowitz
    Sunday Jan 04, 2009
  2. "We are Hamas"
    Posted in The Warped Mirror by Petra Marquardt-Bigman
    Sunday Jan 04, 2009
  3. Averaging one grad per hour
    Posted in Living with Rockets by Ashkelon
    Tuesday Jan 06, 2009
  4. The impact of Palestinian rocket terror on Israeli children
    Posted in Living with Rockets by Anav Silverman
    Sunday Jan 04, 2009
  5. Peace, but not 'Now'
    Posted in Israel Stories by Jeremy Cardash
    Thursday Jan 08, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Dr S McCosker Australia: Ben-Zion. If you have not yet done so, you MUST read Andrew Bostom, 'The Legacy of Islamic Antisemitism: from Sacred Texts to Solemn History'. It is the Rosetta Stone for the middle east conflict & much else beside. It explains EXACTLY where Hamas, Hezbollah, Ahmadinejad & all the rest are coming from. It also explains just why Pakistani Jihadists in Mumbai, supposedly aggrieved by India's possession of Kashmir, went out of their way just to kill a Jewish rabbi & his pregnant wife. The Muslim world seeks nothing less than the total erasure of Israel. Talking to such haters is useless.
Tzvika Israel: I was burn in Israel. The first time I felt the antisemizm was in my lates 20th while being abroad. I was amazed by it. hate for itself will allways be exist,the antisemizm is just another tunel for the hating people to deliver it out. In a way,it is honor to be one of the subjects to suffer from it and it should make us perform better. I realy admire your chalange by living throu those kind of things. take care,keep luthing(: and come visit in Tel Aviv sorry about my english... SHABAT SHALOM
Bob D. JOHANNESBURG: Coming from an era of a legalised racial environment, (the "old South Africa"), I am rather bemused by the reaction of some of these readers. Wake Up!!!! Anti-semitic and other racial concepts are here to stay. The JDL is alive and well. Contact them and let them break a few bones. These morons who perpetrate anti-Jewish sentiments only undertand one thing - force and strength. They dont have the mental capacity to undertand any type of rational dialogue.