Wednesday Dec 31, 2008

Israel Stories: To all you "embarrassed" Jews

Posted by Jeremy Cardash
Comments: 142
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

When you come and live in Israel, that comfortable Diaspora fence you have been perched on all those years suddenly disappears. There is no more grey area; you're either for us or against us.

It's ironic that such a symbol of security should also be the symbol of indecisiveness. Such is the nature of The Fence.

It's easy to criticize Israel from afar, it's easy to be drawn in by the ludicrous political correctness, western liberalism and, in many cases, a sense of extreme embarrassment forced on and often embraced by Jews in the Diaspora. It's easy to shout and scream and criticize, worrying what your non-Jewish neighbors or colleagues may think, becoming the ultimate apologists. It's easy to scream from your comfortable pseudo-Jewish ivory towers. What seems to be harder is for you to muster some sense of loyalty and support for your own people (Jews) and your own country ( Israel). (Just a reminder.) And there aren't enough righteous gentiles to save us all.

'But it's for precisely that reason' you will cry, 'that we are so tough on Israel. We are enlightened, we understand because we live in the West where diplomacy rules. (Bosnia, Hamburg, Dresden, Iraq, Algeria, Congo, Falklands, we love Western diplomacy). Where we know Israeli concessions will bring peace and where we see an oppressed Palestinian people and a ferocious Israeli occupier.' Except of course Israel doesn't occupy Gaza.

Let me tell you something about you, you are not readily able to admit. You ignore the fact Israel no longer occupies a square inch of Gaza. You forget who created the infrastructure left there. You have no sense of history, are blind to the blatant anti-Semitic tide that drives most anti-Israel feeling. You probably receive all your skewed information about Israel through the media. You have never once tried to understand the facts from Israel's point of view. You have no idea of the reign of terror Hamas is conducting on its own people. You have no idea of the suffering of Israelis living close to Gaza suffering barrage after barrage of missiles. You conveniently forget all the facts in order to justify your hateful rhetoric against your own people (Jews) and your own country (Israel). Sorry for the reminder. You have never once asked why Hamas needs to attack Israel, when they could live side by side in peace. You have never asked why, if the people are impoverished, Hamas doesn't use its resources for food and education instead of hand-made bombs and more sophisticated weaponry. You will cry that the 'blockade' on Gaza is plunging the people into destitution. What you won't ask is why is there a blockade. Did I mention that Israel relinquished control of Gaza relocating 8,000 of its citizens?

Oh and you won't read this blog entry properly.

Your identity as a Jew has been stolen. You have turned your back on thousands of years of history siding with the media and Arab propaganda, not really understanding the true facts of the ground. Every other nation has the right to defend itself, show nationalism and expect support. But you deny this for your own people.

So now that Israel, after months and months of restraint and in the wake of thousands of rockets, has finally returned to Gaza to deal with Hamas, you say that you are "embarrassed" by Israel's actions?

You'll tell me I am insecure in my beliefs, that I am ultra right-wing, and that I am blinded by fanaticism. You'll tell me that you know what the problem is and what should be done.

I am not ultra right-wing, just a realist who takes the facts and history into consideration. This is not a simplistic view but a carefully considered opinion. This is not based on a persecution complex but a simple historical formula. They want us out. The President of Iran wants our total destruction. Hamas, Hizbullah, Islamic Jihad, Al Qaida are all vying for the opportunity to drive us into the sea. Many other Arab countries would love to see us gone. That's a fact.

There is no room for diplomacy with an organization that wants your total destruction and perpetuates terror for the sake of an anarchic, megalomaniac blood lust.

There can be no more sitting on the fence. You need to understand that.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   John Blank Lakeland , Florida USA, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
I would like to think I am one of the "righteous gentiles" ,mainly because I support Israel and it's right to defend itself at anytime in any fashion. There is no rrom for diplomacy when the starting point for Hamas is the death of Israel. You cannot reason with these people.If Hamas wishes to live in 3rd world squalor, let them. Keep going with the disproptante response thats the only way to win.
2  |   Joeseph Wheeler, Liberty, USA, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
You are correct that Jews's identities have been stolen, but you are incorrect in saying that "Jews have a history in Israel that stretches thousands of years." Most Israeli Jews are immigrants from Eastern Europe, from the ancient land of Khazaria. Sorry you deny your own people's history.
3  |   Sergio de Leon Manez, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
For my opinion , I beleived to occupy again the Gaza Strip and give it later to PLO for the right leader later after a secured agreement of peace.
4  |   drdan, canada, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
I am a Diaspora Jew. I am also an Israeli. My identity has not been stolen - and I will not be lectured to about the myopia of the Middle East by someone who represents his right-wingery as "realism". Here's another dose of reality. We (if I can use "we" from "over here", sitting on the fence or whatever...) are the regional superpower. Hamas has neither the power nor the ability to destroy Israel. Hamas can make the lives of *some* Israelis utterly miserable... while others continue on with their day, working, going to school, sitting in cafes. So who's persecuting who?
5  |   Marsha Katz Johns Creek, GA USA, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
I felt my prayers were answered with Israel's stand. My distress comes from our giving up Land G-d gave us along with wrenching Jews from their homes and the loss of Jewish life. The Arab world will never allow peace so we must defend ourselves forever. No fence here. I'm an American Jew born the same year Israel became a State. I'm proud of my Judaism and Israel. They are my heart and my soul. We will never turn our backs. I am sorry you feel we are not with you... I am; we are.
6  |   Siegel, Palm Beach Co., FL USA, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
First, I'm greatful for my fellow American John in Lakeland for holding fast to the same original beliefs on which our country, USA, was founded and recognizing the same rights in other "Free" countries such as Israel. Jeremy Cardash...you are not alone!! It makes me sick to my stomach when I come across the "Embarrassed Jew" unable to stand out from the shadow of generations of our religious oppression. There are those of us jews whose fathers were not raised and did not raise their sons as "Momma's Boys" but as true men ready to stand up and fight for who they are as Jews and Americans.
7  |   LIBBIE, Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
I BELIEVE ISREAL DOES HAVE THE RIGHT TO DEFEND ITSELF AND BELIEVE THE BIBLE IS GODS WORD AND HIS WORD SAYS I WILL CURSE THEM WHO CURSE YOU(ISREAL) AND BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU.
8  |   Proud of Israel, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
What's the overiding vision at JPost? Tie Israel to Judea and Samaria and keep the millions of people who live in these lands apart, with no rights to Israeli citizenship, and no responsibility on the part of the state to look after the welfare of those whose borders Tsahal controls. That can't work. The idea of ethnic cleansing I'll grant has worked in the past for different peoples and states, but what has -never- worked for anybody is to seek to occupy hundreds of thousands (in Israel's case millions) of people and at the same time keep them apart and unintegrated and pacified too.
9  |   Proud of Israel, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
There are indeed many reasons to be proud of Israel. The overall excellent healthcare system (that was not built on oil wealth and is provided to all citizens) is one of them. The fact that there is a cultural Jewish home in a state that stretches from the Hula to Eilat and that this place is truly beautiful with dynamic people and towns is in and of itself a source for pride. While it might be a thrill for some to settle Judea and Samaria (or tacitly support those who do) that Zionist vision which places Israel on all the lands of the Bible will have to be left for the time of Moshiach.
10  |   Danny Alexander in Tokyo, Japan, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
To "Proud of Israel" #8 and #9: Failure to accomplish something realistically approaching "full" Yehuda/Shomron settlement has certainly been a failure of governmental will from the get-go -- with the blame for that probably best pinned on then-Defense Minister Moshe Dayan in the immediate aftermath of the 1967 war. But even if current conditions are a difficult tangle, making West Bank settlement much more daunting, that doesn't change the *security* imperative of holding onto the whole of that area. It's the highest ground, making the military choice for Israel binary and starkly simple.
11  |   Negev Girl, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
# 2 - YOU are wrong. MOST Jews in Israel are from (or descendants of those from) the Moslem nations of North Africa, Iraq, Iran, Yemen, Egypt, TUnisia, Algeria, Morocco, Turkey, etc. When will THEY be compensated the billions of dollars that were stolen from them in property, belongings, etc.? The world must take care of them EVEN though Israel already has. The Arabs have billions of petrodollars but UNWRA takes care of the "Palestinian refugees" for 60 years! What a joke. And Europe, Israel , USA continue to give them billions$. They Bomb Israel and ignore the needs of their people!
12  |   Mosh, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Why don't you be specifice as to whom you are addressing. Let me be of assistance. Go to your big boss and ask him why he hires so many leftist columnists to bash Israel daily unlike yourself.
13  |   Yussle, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
"What seems to be harder is for you to muster some sense of loyalty and support for your own people (Jews) and your own country ( Israel)." MY first loyalty is to HaShem and His Torah, not to some secular, 18th century European nationalistic concept of nationhood. Perhaps I missed it, but I didn't notice a single reference to G-d or the Torah in your article. If being a "nation" requires us to kill without discriminating between combatants and civilians, then maybe the whole enterprise needs to be re-evaluated.
14  |   AARON BENEZRA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
RE#11 - NEGEV GIRL - KOL HA KAVOD! You say more in one short paragraph than most say page after page after page. If someone would fund me, I would leave my present home, go to New York City, and stand outside the United Nations every day from Sunday thru Erev Shabbath with a placard quoting your words! I wonder -- with all the bombs that Israel is dropping today on Hamas, can Israel afford to fund one man to stand outside the UN every day?
15  |   AARON BENEZRA, SYRACUSE, USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
RE#2 - JOESEF WHEELER - YOU MISUNDERSTAND THE MEANING OF THE AUTHOR: "Jews have a history in Israel that stretches thousands of years." This is a true statement. There has always been a Jewish presence in Israel, even though most Jews have lived in exile or assimilated into host nations. An excellent example of forgotten Jewish presence is the violent expulsion in 1929 from Gaza City of an historic Jewish community, which existed long before the modern State of Israel existed.
16  |   AARON BENEZRA, SYRACUSE, NY, USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
RE#4 - DRDAN - "WHO'S PERSECUTING WHO?" Do you mean to suggest that Israel is persecuting Hamas? You must be blind! Go to Sderot and live there for a while! See how your nerves hold up from day to day, wondering if 15 seconds is time enough for you to run into a shelter to avoid the Qassam rocket that, like a lottery ticket, you may just win! Better yet, enter your own negotiations with Hamas; perhaps you are the reasonable one to whom Hamas will also be reasonable and acknowledge Israel's right to exist and all that is meant by that including the safe, healthy freedom of Gilad Shalit!
17  |   Joe, New York, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
To Post #4 "drdan, canada": I'm trying to understand you're post. You say "Hamas can make the lives of *some* Israelis utterly miserable..." are you trying to say they do????? Are you just stating their capability's?????? We all know they've launched thousands of rockets into Israel which have killed MANY innocent men women and children! What do you want Israel to do, tell the the suffering orphans and widows that we're sorry but there's nothing we could do because Hamas doesn't have the capability's to whip us ALL off the map???? Explain!!! I'm just trying to understand.
18  |   Gábor Fränkl Budapest, Hungary, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Dear Author, Although I am a diaspora Jew, I perfectly understand the gist (and the desperation) of your post. I fully agree. I am convinced this description applies to the great majority of the Jews "outside" whose only source of information is the one-sided, seriously biased, and anti-semitic media. Well done! The majority of Jewish youth in my native Hungary for example has indeed NO identity - I am acutely aware of this problem, if this can be called a problem any longer. They have no identity and no spine unfortunately. Fränkl Gábor
19  |   Gábor Fränkl, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Oh and if I failed to appreciate enough I do now: THIS ARTICLE WAS TO THE POINT AND SIMPLY BRILLIANT! (But one thing is clear: those whom this justified outburst REALLY pertains to are those Jews, who live in societies, which are challenged by the swelling number of Muslim (and other) immigrants primarily in the West. This does NOT apply to those diaspora Jews whom are NOT targeted by the "Israel-thing", and they are mostly in post-communist Central-Eastern Europe. One thing you overlook: Jews in Poland, Hungary, Slovakia,the Czech Republic are incomperably much secure than those in W Europe!
20  |   Jeff, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Not all Diaspora Jews are what you accuse us of. I happen to agree with you and many others do too. By the same token, it appears that Israel has a significant number of its own citizenry that should read your article. The difference being, they are there, and that makes it even more difficult to understand.
21  |   David Jerusalem/Philadephia, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Jeremy Cardash, Phenomenal article, as an American Jew that moved to Israel and Joined the army I appreciate your view on Some of the Diaspora Jews, as well as your conviction and steadfast belief in Israel's need to defend itself. The world needs to start asking the Arab world why these people are so destructive? Why instead of using their money and resources to create a stable life for their people, they use them for terror and violence? Why the Arab Nations do not care for the Palestinians but rather use their plight as a tool for propoganda against Israel and the Western World?
22  |   Tim, Ottawa, Canada, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Mr. Cardash - I am merely a secular Protestant but your article provides the kind of hard truth that would aspire others to want to be Jewish. Good job on your article and please know that one doesn't have to be Jewish to love and support Israel and its people. I know - I do. I promote it wherever I go. Israel has many things I wish were transportable to the society in which I live - proving we can all learn from each other.
23  |   Peter Bochner, Wayland, Mass., Thursday Jan 01, 2009
In the past week the Boston Globe has printed several letters from hand-wringing Jews expressing the sentiment "I'm so ashamed to be Jewish because of what Israel is doing to the poor inhabitants of Gaza instead of negotiating with the people's elected party of Hamas." They use the Globe's letters column as a podium to proclaim their liberal lunacy and express solidarity with terrorists. It makes me furious. Thank you Jeremy for writing this and G-d bless and protect the Israeli troops.
24  |   concerned former democrat. USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Great article. I am not Jewish but I support Israel. Those that are naive don't see this as the latest installment of the Crusades with steady encroachment of Islamist Jihadists throughout Europe,Asia,Africa and America. This is a time for Christians and Jews to unite...out of self preservation. I am praying for Israel and refuse to drink the politically popular Muslim Koolaide. Muslim extremists have made their intentions clear. This is a war on the West and it is that simple. Israel has the right and duty to defend herself.
25  |   Alan, Japan, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
The only winners in the conflict are the media. Neither the Israelis nor the Palestinians can win and it seems that both sides have came to terms with the situation. If neither side is willing to move and both sides are willing to kill then large numbers of dead bodies and a tidal wave of hatred will inevitably ensue. To the West, Israel is a useful thorn in the side of Islam. A thorn which changed dimension when OPEC raised the price of oil and Islam redeveloped a little clout. If Israelis/Muslims cannot stop killing each other, other countries think 'better there than here' & life goes on.
26  |   Alan, Japan, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
However if I were Israeli I'd be looking at new ways to face up to the situation. Most of the planet sees Israel as a bully no matter what the truth is. Diplomacy has failed. The future now facing Israel is to always live with the bombings from Gaza (not an option), to ethnically cleanse (not an option), to give up and go away (not an option) or to take on the rest of the region in an all or nothing war and to actually become the regional superpower it is always accused of being. The West know the consequences of an Israeli defeat. When G_d isn't listening you must shout louder.
27  |   Mike Carroll, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Actually there are thousands of "Goy" (Ephraim) in America that would sell all that they have and move there and help out in a heartbeat if they were accepted. I make a good living in the construction industry but would sell everything to be with my brothers to help out in any way I could...If you let us we will come. mcarroll4prjc@gmail.com
28  |   PW Virginia USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Great article...I am often engaged with these leftist Jews...It is a chore because of their emotional responses...History and facts do not sway them...sad, sad...Yet I will continue to stand against Arab propaganda and the Stockholm syndrome that follows in its wake. BTW I am progressive on domestic issues and voted for Obama. Israel will stand up for herself and no American president will defy the will of 70% of the population on issues concerning Israel.
29  |   Rex Barney, USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Stop it! This notion that Jew must be against Jew or that Muslim must be against Muslim (fill in your own verus here, Christian vs, Christian, Hutu vs. Tutsi etc, etc ad nauseum) is the worst of the worst when it comes to human strife. We have many enemies. We should not be our own enemies. The things that unite us are far greater than the things that divide us. Do you dislike Diaspoar criticism? Less so, I suspect, than Arab rockets. Do Sabra's look down on you for being "newly arriviste" the way you look down on Jews from the Diaspora? Stop it! All of you! You. Me. Jews.
30  |   Lina Seatle,WA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
#21 David Jerusalem of Philadelphia: You just tookt the words out of my mouth! I could have not said it better.
31  |   Amadeus, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
I am not Jewish, and I agree with you 100%. People who think all the Israelis have to do is make nice to Hamas et al have their heads in the sand. Don't they hear when Hamas et al says that will not give up until the state of Israel is destroyed? Do they think Hamas et all are just exaggerating? I say Israel should take them at their word and destroy all weapons, government buildings, and even the jihadist leaders (if the IDF can find their hidey-holes). Why did Israel's so-called leaders wait so long?
32  |   Ber, Ireland, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Joe Wheeler seem to think that Eastern Europe has been around for thousands of years, hence his opinion that most Jews in Israel are from eastern Europe. But where does he think the Jews arrived from to eastern Europe in the first place? Judae dummy, the historical homeland of all Jews. The wheel has tuned full circle. Meantime, here I am, Catholic having, to point this out.
33  |   Izzy New york, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Part of the criticism is due to Israel's lousy showing in Lebonon. You invaded with a meager force . Now the force is correct and make sure you keep it that way. I believe that the arab countries such as Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Egypt want Israel to wipe out these extremist factions. For some reason or another theyare mute on the subject to the public. Just don't let the big guys talk you down. None of them want to get involved to save Hamas. Its to bad that there are civilian casualties but when you store weapons in mosques and launch missiles from civilian areas its what happens.
34  |   Vakoc, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Dear Author, Your post seems to come with a hint of desperacy in search of support for Israel which is rapidly diminishing. You may have noticed that Non Muslims (including Rabbis who understand Judaism better than yourself) and Muslims are coming together to defeat Zionism. As for Hamas, remember they were democratically elected and remember that a handful of Israelis have died from rocket attacks as compared to the thousands of Palestinians that have died. The world has had enough of the deception and games played by the Zionists.
35  |   Rosanna, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
You say "embarrassed" Jews, what about "embarrassed" Jewish media who give publicity to anti-israel and anti-semitic views? Aren't there enough sites given to these radicals and their supporters? Freedom of the press is one thing, but half the world is unaware of the real reasons why Israel has to fight to exist, the other half knows, but supports Israel's enemies anyway. The time is not for Jewish liberals to feel good about themsleves nor for those who scream "injustice", cry for the armed wing of Iran but ignore the plight of innocents in Darfur, Congo, Zimbabwe & the people of Israel.
36  |   United States, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
I am an American and I am proud of Isreal,s response.. It amazes me that the clueless among our countries expect Isreal to sit back and do nothing.. In our country we have the same clueless masses.. Just look at the election of Barak Hussein Obama.. He,s gonna talk to Iran. Has That worked ever? . America has allowed Iran to kill it,s brave soldiers and Maime them in Iraq with I.E.D,,s and done nothing as WE HAVE GROWN TIRED OF THE WAR. To bad most of these Americans have not had to live in Isreal. Or our women had to live in Iran and these places they want Barak to negioate with..
37  |   Dagoberto Mensch, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
To #4. "Am I my brother´s keeper?" If what you say is right, Hamas has missiles with ZIP codes so they strike only "politically incorrect" Jews? Hamas amd Hezbollah hate ALL LIVING JEWS, they are not specific on whom to kill with their Iranian missiles of (common sense and brain neurons) mass destruction. Regarding the article, may be going to live in Sderot for some time would give a little perspective to some people.
38  |   Ken, Manhattan,NY, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
I agree with the writer of the article being addressed by these responses. Israel is fighting terrorism. These terrorists groups are supported by Arab & Muslim countries looking to destroy Israel. The innocent muslim families living in Gaza are being used by Hamas as a shield for them to attack Israel. It is Israel who is trying to root out Hamas fron the area. They are trying to create peace in those terrorist held areas so peace can finally be achieved for all concerned..
39  |   Edward, Irvine CA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
I'm another Christian "righteous Gentile" supporting Israel and the Jewish people's right to defend themselves from daily terrorist attacks being launched from their own border. Hopefully one day the embarrassed Jews living in NY and elsewhere will stop electing representatives who are only marginally committed to Israel at best. Hopefully the embarrassed Jews in the US will come to realize they should start fearing the fanatical Islamic terrorists more than their Christian neighbors ard start voting Conservative.
40  |   JACK SPRAT, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
GOOD FOR YOU JEREMY: THESE JEWS WHO WOULD ALWAYS SIDE WITH THE ENEMIES OF ISRAEL IN ORDER TO SHOW HOW FAIR THEY ARE, ARE THE DUMBEST PEOPLE IN THE WORLD AND THE BIGGEST HYPOCRITES IN THE WORLD. AND TO PROVE IT, THEY WILL ALWAYS BEND OVER BACKWARDS. I ONCE KNEW SOMEBODY WHO BENT OVER BACKWARDS, AND NOW HE CANNOT STAND UP. THESE DUMB JEWS, AND THAT'S WHAT THEY ARE HAVE FORGOTTEN HOW IT WAS WITH THEM PRIOR TO THE BIRTH OF ISRAEL. VERY PAINFUL TO REMEMBER THAT, SO THEY CHOOSE TO FORGET. I HAVE NEVER SHOWN THEM ANY RESPECT. THEY NEVER DESERVE RESPECT.
41  |   Mike, Boise, Idaho, USA, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
It is completely mind boggling to hear the UN, Arab States, the West and especially Jews who live here in the USA complain that Israel is using too much force or somehow we can setup a diplomatic office in Iran and all will be well. Israel has been a model of restraint when it comes to using military force. The Isreali military needs to do far more, beginning with cutting off the head of the Islamic terrorist supplier Iran. It is pretty sad that Israel's best friends in the west are Evangelical Christians like me and not their own Jewish brothers. God's speed.
42  |   Jan, Australia, Thursday Jan 01, 2009
Mr Cardash, you are right. Israel's existence is decisively divisive. One is either for it or against it. Woe to those who fence sit. Every fence sitter is assumed to be on the other side, and will be targeted by both sides. Israel is not just any nation. It was not a creation made by Jews. It was made by the God of Israel, for His purposes and to His plan. Woe will be to those who lie and oppose this plan. Woe will be to those who fence sit!