|
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
In the Trenches: What's in a name? Posted by David Harris
Comments: 28
I was born with a simple, straightforward name - David Harris. Thankfully, it never generated attention, much less teasing, while growing up. Yet it was actually quite unique in my milieu. I was surrounded by Jewish kids, and Harris was not exactly a common surname. How my peripatetic father ended up with the name is a story for another time. On the other hand, this was an era when assimilating Jewish parents were thinking about first names far from the likes of David. But once I left my little corner of the world, I discovered that my name was anything but unique. I arrived at university. It was the late 1960s and many campuses were in turmoil. Student protests over the Vietnam War, military education programs, and CIA recruiting were widespread. And who emerged as one of the student leaders of this movement? None other than David Harris. But it wasn't me. No, it was a student at Stanford University who achieved national fame and later married the popular folk singer Joan Baez. And suddenly, when I introduced myself, I was often confronted with the question, "Are you the real David Harris?" Of course, in the mind of the questioner, I was anything but, thus triggering my first name-generated identity crisis. Years later, my family moved to Westchester County, just outside New York. One day, the phone rang. The caller identified herself as a reporter for The New York Times. Here's more or less how the conversation went: "Is this David Harris?" she asked. "Yes, it is," I replied. "How can I help you?" "I'm calling from the New York Times to get your reaction to a breaking story." "Sure, what is it?" "How do you feel about your mother's release from prison today?" "Not sure I understand. What exactly did Mom do this time? Jaywalk? Drive below the minimum speed limit on the New York Thruway?" "Mr. Harris, I don't think murder is a laughing matter!" Well, it turned out that Jean Harris, the Virginia school headmistress who had killed her lover, Dr. Herman Tarnower, in a case that generated huge media attention, had a son. Yes, his name was David Harris and he presumably lived in Westchester County. Then, a few years later, I was sitting on a plane headed for Houston. I'm one of those travelers who tries to build an invisible wall between me and the person sitting next to me. From long experience, I've discovered that the chances of meeting someone who will chew your ear off are far greater than the chances of meeting someone scintillating, so why risk it? But my neighbor was determined to puncture the wall, and eventually succeeded. After some aimless chit-chat, she thrust out her hand and introduced herself. I responded with my hand and name. She paused for a second before blurting out: "I thought you were dead." Now, working in the Jewish world, I'm used to what we call Jewish compliments, along the lines of "You dont look so good" and "You don't seem at the top of your game." This one, however, took the cake. I needed a moment to recover from her comment before replying that, to the best of my knowledge, I was still kicking, unless she could see something in me that I obviously couldn't see in myself. A bit more conversation and everything became clear. There is, or more precisely was, a David Harris in Houston who gained some notoriety. He was an orthodontist who cheated on his wife. She tried to win him back by having cosmetic surgery and changing her wardrobe, but alas, it didn't work. The philandering continued. Finally, the wife had enough. She took out the family car and ran him over - not once, but three times, to make sure he got the point. He died, but not before another David Harris had made it into the headlines. As a matter of fact, having first checked phone books and later the internet, it's safe to say that David Harris is about as "un-unique" a name as there is. But at least I thought I was safe in the Jewish world. Not so. Along came another David Harris. In fact, he even shares the same middle initial with me and, wouldn't you know it, he decided to enter the Jewish world. First, he joined another Jewish organization with the very same initials as my own AJC. I don't think I have to describe the confusion that can be generated by two people with the exact same name working for two Jewish organizations with the exact same initials. I kept hoping he'd be unhappy in his chosen career path, or maybe decide to convert to another religion, or be so avant-garde that he might marry and take his wife's surname. None of that happened. So, instead, I figured I'd just take credit for everything smart he said and disown the things I disagreed with. Then he moved. He went to the National Jewish Democratic Council. Well, the good news is that we no longer have institutional initials in common. The bad news is that he's clearly a partisan, and I'm not. In fact, I've spent my entire career studiously avoiding partisan labels for my agency or myself. Yet now I'm confused with a professional partisan - and those who always suspected me of being a closet Democrat think they finally got me. So, let me say once and for all that I was never married to Joan Baez, never had a mother in jail on a murder conviction, haven't come back from the dead, and am not a card-carrying member of anything political. No doubt, however, it won't be long before the next name confusion - maybe this time with the professional football player, David Harris of the New York Jets. Now that's one I might not even try to disown.
1 |
David Harris,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
I am the real David Harris. Ask your colleagues at The Jerusalem Post about me. My middle initial is Z.
2 |
Reginald, Houston,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
My best friend growing up was David Harris. It definitely is a common name. I liked the light-heartedness of this piece.
3 |
shirley levy scarsdale,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
What a charming and witty article. David Harris writes as well as he speaks!
4 |
yoav, ny,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Great article, but it left me with one question - was the writer's mother ever in jail, but not for murder?
Look at the way this sentence was written:: "never had a mother in jail on a murder conviction"...
5 |
Stephan, Highland Park, Ill.,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Certainly an aside from his usual columns, but rather different, entertaining and humorous. I thorougly enjoyed it.
6 |
Susan North Jersey,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Time to add a new initial to your name:
David U. Harris
Z. David Harris
D. Avid Harris
7 |
David Zohar, Jerusalem,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
I was born David M Harris in England 70 years ago, immigrated to Israel in 1948, and when i joined the Israeli diplomatic service I was told I could not represent the country with a goyishe name - so we changed it to Zohar.
The family had become Harris at the end of the 19th century when English people found they could not pronounce Chmielnik (Polish). What was the surname before that-I have no idea.
8 |
Zakah - USA,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Thank you David Harris for making the matter of your name clear. I was beginning to think you had multiple personalities, and the nine lives of a cat. You seemed to be everywhere and I was beginning to get confused.
9 |
Jon A. Vienna, Virginia,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
This is a very cute story, Mr. Harris. I think that somewhere deep in the hart you are a little bit ashamed of this non-Jewish family name. But, please, dont rush to a shrink you have not done anything wrong!
I probably would change my family name too, if I could speak without an accent . All the best. Jon A.
10 |
Evan, Midland Park, NJ,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
How true it is! It's great to start a beautiful autumn day with a big smile on my face. Thank you David Harris.
11 |
Sara B. Leviten; North Miami, FL,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
The timing of this article is such a coincidence. The spelling of my last name is not very common. I found out this past week that someone has the same first and last name as I do: Sara Leviten. I don't know her middle initial. I've written her father to find out if we are related. He has responded, yet.
12 |
Eric Cantor, Philadelphia,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
David,
Very amusing!
Eric Cantor
13 |
Esav Benyamin,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
A common name for an uncommon man.
We're glad to have you around -- whoever you are!
14 |
Meredith, Texas,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Perhaps other David Harris' will be pleased to be mistaken for YOU! We are reminded about the connection between one's name and one's character.
15 |
Florida Gulf Coast,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
David A. Harris at the AJC...now, that's my man. I met him in Palm Beach, Florida at one AJC annual meeting and came away convinced he is the real McCoy. I would not change him for any counterfeit David Harris out there. But I could switch my allegiance from the New England Patriots to the New York Jets if he would front their line to protect Quarterback Sanchez. That's the kind of trust I have in my man David A Harris of the AJC.
16 |
Dennis NYC,,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
I saw you in concert once. You were pretty good. [ Link to page ] /
I also saw you play once for the NY Jets [ Link to page ]
How do you find time to do all these things?
Thanks for the article
17 |
Fern Baker,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
For me there is only one David Harris, and that is you. I have often thought that you are truly one of the most articulate, fair and balanced Jewish and Israel advocates out there today, in what is most certainly a very hostile world. I am aware, as are so many of my like-minded friends and colleagues, that you can be counted on to speak up and speak out on the daily issues and confrontations Israel and Jews are faced with, as well as bring a physical presence to your protestations, calls for fairness, etc. no matter when and where that may be. We are lucky to have you represent us. Thank you
18 |
eveline, New York City,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
charming column-good luck
19 |
j. Lehman,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Thanks God I did not know any other Davis Harris.
20 |
j. Lehmna,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
David Harris is pretty well known in jewish circles but can all the David Horowitz identify themselves who is each one?
21 |
Chris,
Sunday Nov 08, 2009
Once upon a time at the temple in Jerusalem , i was so 7 years old, i had 2 friends. The one was named bird and the other eye. I came to the temple through the Lion´s Gate, and they both came trough the Western Wall. And we plaid soccer at the temple. They were much older than me, and they showed me how to play. Eye was a good goalkeeper and bird got a heavy strong shoot with his right feet. And i learned to play from them, then i was able to win, cause i could keep the goal, was able to shot with the right feet, but although with my left feet. Do you know my name ?
22 |
Andrei, Romania,
Monday Nov 09, 2009
Hi David, funny piece :) I still saw in it a bit of the sadness you have for being attacked by different in the J world.. :) Good luck with everything, Andrei
23 |
Robbins, Santa Monica, CA,
Monday Nov 09, 2009
At first I expected an article about Ahmadinejad and the speculation/rumors of his Jewish identity based on his former surname, but this article ran more like an episode of Seinfeld! Glad to see our man in the trenches has a sense of humor and a personal side. I hope your children have more unique names though!
24 |
Lucca, Haifa Israel,
Monday Nov 09, 2009
Hi David,
loved your article, I think we are somehow on the same wavelength, let's smile no matter what!
I sign my blogs with my first name "Lucca" no danger more lucca's will show up, and if, it
s a boy's name in Italy, or in Rumania.
My husband dragged once a young woman over to me in a park to show me the chain she wore on her neck with "Lucca" on it! We couldn't believe it!
25 |
Stanley Tel Aviv,
Monday Nov 09, 2009
David Harris: What a lovely article. Living in Israel with a Jewish American Name like Stanley definitely stands out. I'm proud to be an American Jew living in israel. Thank you, you are so very wise and love reading your columns, keep it up, i look forward to them
26 |
Dan Dille,
Tuesday Nov 10, 2009
You are fortunate to have a name that is attached to a family, a history, and a people. I have lived my life with none of those. I have no history beyond the people who raised me. I have no idea what nationality I belong to, or where my anscestors' homeland is. This is part of what's responsible for my admiration of the Jewish people. Even during the Diaspora, family and heritage meant everything. I'm glad your predecessors created a homeland for the Jews, and I'm telling you it's worth fighting to keep it. Only someone with no heritage can see what you have in its true light.
27 |
Janet Kasten Friedman Kohav HaShahar Israel,
Tuesday Nov 10, 2009
My husband's name is Yehoshua Friedman which is a very common name in Israel. We sometimes get other people's mail, etc. but since he's not famous (or, G-d forbid, infamous,) it makes little difference. Your tale was cute and fun to read. If it really bothers you, you can, as many people suggested, change your name. I recommend NOT changing the name completely. If you did that people would not recognise that your accomplishments were indeed yours. Adding an extra middle name, or even a nickname would do the trick, if you insisted that people use it. (e.g.the M.K. Arieh, Lova Eliav)
28 |
Victor Galindo,
Tuesday Nov 10, 2009
A delightful story. I have experienced a touch of the same. Growing up in NYC, my family was the only Galindo (in our case it is Sephardic). But since then (80 years ago), I have encountered many Galindos' from Puerto Rico and Mexico and elsewhere. Quite a few with the first name Victor. Some famous like the ice skater. Generally, though, it is a bother when I am mistaken for someone with unpaid debts. Best of luck.
|
Top Rated Posts
Tags:Blogroll |