Sunday Jun 22, 2008

In the Trenches: The greatest generation up close

Posted by David Harris
Comments: 11
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

Ten years ago this month, my father passed away.

In his declining years, he had few friends and only a tiny family, and since he was almost obsessively modest about himself, little was known about him outside a small circle. He deserved more. He was part of the generation that was put to the ultimate test, and he passed with flying colors. He saw nothing special in what he did, but what he did was awe-inspiring. We owe his generation, which some have called the Greatest Generation, more than we may ever realize.

Dad was born in Budapest in 1920. His full name was Erich Albert Loewe.

My father's family was assimilationist. They embraced modernity and universalism. Dad had little knowledge of Judaism and even less comfort in a synagogue. That made his decision to wear a Star of David later in life and to develop an emotional attachment to Israel, which he visited numerous times, all the more striking to me.

Dad's family moved to Vienna shortly after his birth and, in 1925, to Berlin, where my grandfather worked as a journalist.

Berlin's Jews in the 1920s were an extraordinary presence in the city. To a large degree, they defined the cultural, medical, scientific, and commercial worlds. Dad threw himself into math and science, loved to tinker with just about anything mechanical or electrical, and enjoyed skiing.

In 1933, Hitler came to power. Life as my father knew it was about to be shattered. His family left Germany almost immediately. They saw what was coming, in Germany at least. First, they went to Poland, and then sent my father, 14 at the time, to Vienna to live with relatives.

Meanwhile, my grandmother became a cook in the Soviet Red Army, and my grandfather was interned in Shanghai by the Japanese occupying army for "spying." It would be well over a decade before this family of three would be reunited.

Anti-Semitism was a potent force in Vienna long before the Anschluss in 1938, but many Jews were nonetheless shocked by the paroxysms of hatred expressed by many Austrians after the Nazi takeover that year.

Dad recalled walking home from school shortly thereafter. He was 18 at the time. At the Kohlmarkt, in the center of Vienna, he was grabbed by uniformed members of the Nazi SS and SA and, together with a few other Jewish kids, ordered to get on their knees, and shine and polish the Nazis' boots. My father remembered returning to his aunt and uncle’s apartment around 4 A.M. after seven or eight hours of this humiliating work.

He eventually left Austria in 1938 and moved to Paris. He enrolled in the faculty of physics and chemistry at the Sorbonne, and worked nights at an aircraft supplier.

It was in Paris that he first met his future wife, Nelly Chender, who was then just the kid sister of my father's friend. Her family had managed to leave Moscow in 1929 and resettle in France.

Dad finished his course and enlisted in the French army, or so he thought, in Sathonay, near Lyon. Through an apparent clerical error, the French assigned him to the notorious Foreign Legion (La Légion étrangère) rather than the Legion for Foreigners (La Légion pour les étrangers).

He was sent to French-ruled Algeria, where he did his gritty military service, often enduring taunts of sale juif ("dirty Jew") from the officers. When France fell to the Nazi onslaught in June 1940, my father was placed in a prisoner-of-war camp in Kenadsa, in western Algeria. The prisoners were assigned to perilous and debilitating work in the coal mines of the Sahara.

A fellow prisoner who became Dad's lifelong friend later told me that my father was tenacious and his spirit indomitable. Determined to return to the war against the Nazis, he escaped from the camp in 1943, after more than three years' incarceration. He had tried once before, but been caught and shot in the ankle in the process.

He joined a caravan of Arab traders making their way across the desert and was able to reach Algiers. There, after an extended hospitalization for treatment of the ankle wound, malnutrition, and exhaustion, he joined the British Army. Given the rank of sergeant, he supervised Algerian workers at an airport being used by Allied forces. But that wasn't the kind of military work he had in mind.

After a few months in the British Army, he was transferred to the Office of Strategic Services (OSS), the legendary American wartime espionage unit under the command of Colonel Wild Bill Donovan.

The story I was told is that the Americans wanted him to change his surname. It sounded too Jewish and too complicated with those two dots over the "o." They gave him someone's address book, and my father, who barely spoke a word of English, picked the name "Harris" because it looked like "Paris." True or not, I'll never know.

After participating in the invasion of Italy with the US Fifth Army, he was involved in one of the war's most ferocious battles, at Monte Cassino, and then helped liberate Rome. Eventually, the OSS trained him in the craft of espionage. The OSS school in Italy fronted as a psychiatric hospital. Long after the war's end, my father would wake up screaming in the middle of the night, a result of having been roughly awakened during training and put through mock interrogations.
 
In all, my father parachuted 13 times as an OSS agent - three training jumps and ten actual jumps behind enemy lines in Austria and Yugoslavia. His assignment in the final months of the war was to help persuade the Austrians to break away from the Germans and surrender first.

After the war, the OSS helped him come to the United States. At first, he continued to work in intelligence in Washington, but he didn't stay long and retired with the rank of captain. He had had enough of war, both open and clandestine. He wanted to continue his scientific studies, find a job, and get married. He yearned for the security and stability that had been missing for the previous 12 years.

He discovered that my mother's family had made it to New York on one of the last passenger ships crossing the Atlantic before the attack on Pearl Harbor. He located them. My mother, it turned out, was no longer just the kid sister, and they got married in 1946. Shortly thereafter, they moved to Los Angeles, and my father began working as an engineer in the MGM and Argosy film studios.

I was born in Santa Monica in 1949, but we didn't stay long. While the whole country seemed to be moving westward, my parents decided to move back to New York.

My father was fascinated by every advance in technology. One of the newest frontiers at the time was television, so he gladly accepted an offer to work at CBS News. When CBS signed an agreement with a German television network in 1960, he was asked to go to Munich to help implement it. He was a logical choice. He spoke fluent German and was on the cutting edge of the latest breakthroughs in video.

There was only one problem. My father hadn't set foot in Germany since 1933 and, frankly, he had no desire to return. CBS gently encouraged him to give it a shot. If he could adjust emotionally, my mother and I would follow; if not, he'd return. I remember vividly the call that came a few weeks after he left for Munich. Come, he said, and we did.

It was only later that I realized that my parents had taught me two very important lessons in Germany, and they did it in the best way possible - through example. Both lessons have stayed with me.

First, somehow, life goes on. Never, ever, ignore the past, but don't become its prisoner, either. There wasn't a single moment in Germany during that year when we ever forgot where we were. I was only 11, but it quickly dawned on me. Munich, after all, was the site of Hitler's attempted putsch in 1923. It also became the symbol of appeasement in 1938. It was just a few miles from Dachau. And anyone around us over the age of 35, or thereabouts, could well have been involved in the Final Solution.

At the same time, I saw my parents struggling to acknowledge that the Germany of 1960-61 was different. It was a democratic country governed by the rule of law, even if anti-Semitism hadn't entirely disappeared. It couldn't have been easy for them, but my father's work had brought us there and, consequently, they tried their best to be open-minded and forward-looking.

Second, be who you are. My parents were Jewish. They weren't at all observant or particularly knowledgeable about their religious identity, but they were proud of their heritage. They had been marked for extinction because of their identity. Their lives had been disrupted in more ways than I can count because of that identity. Yet they had absolutely no desire to hide from it, much less reinvent themselves. To affirm Jewish identity in postwar Germany took some courage. Yet perhaps they instinctively understood that the ultimate test of the new Germany - and the new Europe - would be how these countries interacted with living Jews, and not only how they dealt with the memory of murdered Jews.

Our time in Germany ended on a bad note: my parents divorced. Personal differences proved irreconcilable. My mother and I returned to New York. My father stayed on in Europe for another 15 years. He then moved with his second wife to Rochester, Minnesota, and then to northern California.

I was never to live in the same city with my father again, or even within driving distance, though we usually managed to see each other once or twice a year. To state the obvious, it wasn't ideal. There were some things I missed out on.

But I've come to understand that my father was a product of a very specific time and place in world history. From an early age, he faced circumstances that were far from enviable and that couldn't help but affect the rest of his life.

At a time when many kids today are thinking about summer camp or their bar or bat mitzvah, my father was on the run from a psychopath who wanted to wipe all the Jews off the face of the earth. When many kids today take family gatherings for granted, my father didn't see his parents from the age of 14 to 26. And when many kids today think about their post-college plans, my father was plotting his escape from a prison camp in western Algeria.

So, I can't say that I ever learned how to drive from my father, or how to handle my first date with a girl, but, in the long run, I was exposed to something no less valuable.

I saw up close the example of a man whose courage knew no limits and who, together with like-minded men and women, saved the world from Hitler. I saw a man who never boasted about his exploits, but who simply did what he knew had to be done, and then, when it was over, tried as best as he could to get on with his life in a new country, culture, and language. And I saw a man who stubbornly believed that tomorrow could be better than yesterday, and who never stopped trying to make it a reality.

Courage, humility, perseverance, and optimism - four character traits that my father embodied and the world could always use more of.

The more time passes since my father's death, the more I miss him.

Revised and condensed from a longer essay published in June 2003 as "Letter from a Late Father's Son." For copies, please contact pr@ajc.org

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Mark Silverberg, Scranton, PA, USA, Sunday Jun 22, 2008
A fine tribute to your dad, David. He would be proud of what you've done with your life. Mark Silverberg
2  |  Ben Z USA, Sunday Jun 22, 2008
Mr. Harris...a very nice tribute to your father. What an exciting life he led! Many Jews today are not religious, but very much a part of our Jewish heritage. Your father (and mother) certainly belonged to that class. Be well. Ben Z. USA
3  |  Fred, San Francisco, Monday Jun 23, 2008
A beautifully written tribute to your father. He serves as an example to the young people out there. I have passed on the piece to my son to try and teach him about the real heros who made America and the west free (and non-German speaking).
4  |  Jack, NY, Monday Jun 23, 2008
the greatest generation, indeed. mr harris' father seems to epitomize the high standards of strength and sacrifice that have become known as the hallmark of his contemporaries. my own father passed away four years ago this month without imparting many of the lessons i know he would have liked to, and this piece has helped show us all how we can still learn from our father's example. thank you for sharing your family's unique history with the world.
5  |  Andrei, Romaniac, Monday Jun 23, 2008
insight into those who made David the men(sch) he is! Also.. a strong reminder to all young Jews in the States .. life exists before and after America :)
6  |  Vinegar Hill, Madrid, Spain., Tuesday Jun 24, 2008
This is a very passionate, emotional article making two main points, one of which I think the author has himself ignored. Mr. Harris you state that we should not ignore the past and, I agree. In the same breath, however, you state that we should not "become it's prisoner" but, you have! The article is proof of that. Surely the challenge is to look forward to the future generation and what faces them in Israel, so that they might become the "greatest generation" when they try to bring peace to the region. That would be something to write about!
7  |  Erin, London, Monday Jun 30, 2008
What a wonderfully moving piece. Thank god for men like your father, Mr. Harris, as without him the world would not have heros such as yourself. Keep up the good fight!
8  |  Adrienne Lassman, Friday Sep 05, 2008
It is personal narratives such as this that allow us not only a stirring biographical piece but serve to define the writer. You have given us even new insights into your own psyche, David, to add to those gleaned from your brilliant and incisive articles. You embody the best of both of your beloved parents who created the consummate leader and "mensch" you have become. Without knowledge of the past we cannot build upon our hopes and dreams for the future. Our future as Jews is brighter with spokespeople such as you to articulate and disperse our deepest thoughts.
9  |  Paul R. ....Texas-USA, Tuesday Oct 21, 2008
I am a newcomer to your paper, My Father served in Our Army(USA) in WW-2 also Dad had two tanks blown out from under him., .he told me many times of the bodies stacked on the side of the road I just read an article in your paper about why there are so few Democrat Jews in the USA...I have been confused by this for years, considering the Republican party has more Christians that would defend Israel till their last breath, Also, which person would you rather have in the Oval Office, Obama who would sit down with your enemies, or McCain? the veteran, Ask your relatives and friends in the USA?
10  |  Steve, Denver, Colorado, Wednesday Oct 22, 2008
Having just read Ed Koch's startling Jerusalem Post blog that called for the immediate withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan, I'm again reminded of the greatness of the "Greatest Generation" described in Harris's moving blog about his father. When the going was tough, they proved themeselves equal to the challenge. And the leaders of the day, Churchill, Roosevelt and, later, Truman, didn't cave. Koch could learn from their examples. They knew the consequences of defeat and wouldn't countenance it. Nor can we afford to do so today.
11  |  Paul R., Friday Oct 31, 2008
Correction-that post should have read why are there so MANY Democratic Jews in the USA?
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

In the Trenches American Jewish Committee (AJC) Executive Director David Harris assesses challenges to Jewish security worldwide.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. A moral army
    Posted in Army Life by A.J.
    Monday Nov 17, 2008
  2. Ben Hur loves Zion
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008
  3. How did a small tribe from Samaria get all the way out here?
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Tuesday Nov 18, 2008
  4. Indian airports spell chaos
    Posted in Ten Tribes Challenge - India by Amir Mizroch
    Tuesday Nov 18, 2008
  5. Yes we can (stop talking about Obama)
    Posted in Majoring in Aliyah by Lahav Harkov
    Wednesday Nov 19, 2008

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Vinegar hill, Madrid, Spain.: # 40 Tom G: The point is Tom people like you go and shout it from the mountain tops every day. Others read about their past in history books and talk about it discretely.
Tom Ginzbourg: To #18: Yes, I am constantly reminded, even bombarded with stories of the Irish famine (my girlfriend is Irish) and British cruelty. I'm also friends of many Armenians who, as you can see by comment number 4, Doctor Kevorkian, will talk to death about their own 1915 genocide stories of their grandparents, etc. We will never forget your BLOODY INQUISITION, TORQUEMADA, etc.. either
Kyle M Livonia, Michigan: I'm not Jewish, I'm Irish Catholic. I don't really know many practicing Jews. I was led to the site looking for articles on the current military build up in the gulf that may be a message to Iran. After reading a few articles I came across this article. However, I found the comments most interesting. Are Jews typically democrats or republicans? Do you( any one willing to answer) truly feel Iran will attempt to destroy Israel if they are able to create nuclear weapons? Wouldn't Palestinians suffer from such an attack as well? I'd love some answers. any insight would be appreciated.