|
Monday Nov 24, 2008
In the Trenches: A window into Israel's soul Posted by David Harris
Comments: 41
If all we knew about Israel came from the media, which seems to have an aversion to upbeat stories, how would the country be portrayed? Images of war, conflict, corruption, and domestic fault lines would dominate. And if all we knew about Israel came from international organizations, which make a habit of singling it out for vilification - especially each November, when Israel's very creation becomes an annual target for its enemies at the UN - what would we see? A nonstop litany of accusations of every conceivable evil known to humankind. For many, these are the only sources of information about Israel. But anyone who's been to Israel understands that the real place, seen up close, is quite different. That's why there's no substitute for a first-hand look. Okay, Israel isn't perfect. It has its share of problems. But what country - even among the most highly developed in the world - doesn't have its shortcomings? And no one else faces the unique security challenges, with all the stresses and strains, which are Israel's daily fare. That said, Israel's got an awful lot going for it - robust democracy, cutting-edge innovation, thriving arts, astonishing diversity, and no-holds-barred debate. Above all, it has a zest for life. You don't have to believe me. Confirmation comes from an unlikely source, Sheikh Nasrallah, Hizboullah's leader, although he draws rather different conclusions. He declared: "We have discovered how to hit the Jews where they are the most vulnerable. The Jews love life, so that is what we shall take away from them. We are going to win, because they love life and we love death." This love of life isn't just about hedonism or narcissism, though, of course, Israelis aren't immune. The few murderous exceptions, such as Yigal Amir or Baruch Goldstein, are just that - exceptions, who were roundly condemned for their brutal violence. It's about something more. The Israeli zest for life derives from the Jewish interpretation of the meaning of life - namely, inspired by a higher authority, to be agents of change for a more humane and compassionate planet. It's about the oft-cited Jewish notion of tikkun olam, or healing the world. Some have argued that Israelis would be justified if they turned inward, circled the wagons, and said to hell with a world that hasn't always treated either Jews or Israel fairly. And they argue that Israel, as the only UN member nation targeted with annihilation by both state and non-state actors, could be excused if it succumbed to total self-preoccupation in the interest of self-preservation. Yet these views don't prevail. There's an irrepressible Israeli yearning to engage the world and make it better. And herein lies a window into Israel's soul, which may not be the stuff of media coverage or UN resolutions, but reveals an all-too-rare inner truth. Consider some striking examples: Wherever disaster strikes in the world, a group called Israeli Flying Aid is ready to respond. Made up of hundreds of volunteers who donate their time, it goes at a moment's notice to places near and far that have been struck by earthquakes, tsunamis, cyclones, floods, and political violence. The goal is to distribute food and medicine, provide first-aid assistance, and offer other survival help. These volunteers are active in countries that have ties with Israel - and those that don't. Often, their work is below the radar because countries accept their help, knowing the level of experience and professionalism, but, sadly, don't want it known that it's being provided by Israelis. But that public rejection has never been a deal-breaker for the group because lives hang in the balance. And sometimes they risk their own well-being to provide relief without government approval. Or take Save A Child's Heart, another completely volunteer effort. Based at the Wolfson Medical Center, near Tel Aviv, a team of dozens of top-flight medical personnel treat children with major cardiac problems from around the world, including the West Bank and Arab countries, and also train personnel in other lands to perform surgery. Or consider Hadassah Hospital in Jerusalem, which I had occasion to visit recently. Stand in the entrance or walk its corridors. From secular Jews to devout Muslims, all patients receive outstanding care. And if you probe, you'll discover that some of those patients are from countries that not only have no ties to Israel, but even regularly accuse the Jewish state of infecting Arabs with deadly viruses. Yet their citizens find round-about ways to reach Israel and benefit from its lifesaving health care. Which brings us to the 13-year-old boy whose parents brought him to Israel after doctors in Iran, their native land, and Turkey were unable to treat his life-threatening brain tumor. Their names haven't been revealed for fear of retribution once they return to Iran, a country that calls for a world without Israel. But there they were at Sheba Hospital in Tel Hashomer counting on quality care to save a life - and getting it. Or take the aftermath of a recent terrorist attack in Jerusalem, where the wounded Israeli was transported to the same hospital as his Palestinian assailant, who was shot by police, in an effort to save both their lives. Visit Hebrew University, where the thirty-fourth class of students studying for a master's degree in public health was recently welcomed. The overwhelming majority of the students, many already physicians or health-care professionals, come from developing countries in Africa, Asia, and Latin America. They receive full stipends from Jewish foundations to get their degrees. When they complete the program, they are far better equipped to improve public health and, yes, save lives. And at this moment, courtesy of Israel, a large group of African physicians is in the country for an annual program of advance training. They come from across the continent, including Ethiopia, Kenya, Nigeria, Tanzania, and Uganda, and they're spending several months acquiring new medical skills, once again, to save lives. Last month, a group of twenty-five students from two Israeli medical schools, Tel Aviv and Ben-Gurion universities, traveled for two weeks at their own expense to Ethiopia to volunteer in health agencies. Their goal, driven purely by idealism, was to help with de-worming efforts, especially in HIV/AIDS patients. And one last particularly striking example. Remember the two Israeli soldiers, Eldad Regev and Ehud Goldwasser, who were kidnapped across an international border by Hizbullah in 2006, triggering a war that summer? They were wounded when abducted, but very much alive. Earlier this year, their corpses were returned to Israel in a so-called swap. In contrast, among those sent back to Lebanon was Samir Kuntar, a Hizbullah terrorist captured by Israel after he killed a four-year-old Israeli girl and her father in 1978. The details of the murders, according to Newsweek, were "so sickening they give pause even to some of Israel's enemies." These barbaric acts, for which he has never apologized, earned him a hero's welcome upon his arrival to Beirut. Not only was Kuntar returned alive - Israel, after all, has no capital punishment, even in such grisly cases - but he came back to Lebanon with a bachelor's degree in hand, courtesy of the Open University in Israel! Yes, Sheikh Nasrallah is right in one respect - Jews love life, and not just for themselves. With its humanitarian spirit and pioneering medical research and technology, Israel is a small country making an outsized difference on the world stage in advancing the quality of life. But Nasrallah also believes that the cult of death has the upper hand. Here, he couldn't be more wrong. In truth, the affirmation of life, as embodied by Israel, will always triumph over an ideology grounded in murder and mayhem.
1 |
Ilan The Amazing in Atlanta The Amazing,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Thanks for mentioning SOME of the good Israel does, and not as an excuse but as an accurate description depicting the benevolent side of Israelis. If you listened to what's said on some college campuses or news organizations, one would be truly hard pressed to buy into your article :)
2 |
Marian, USA,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Beautifully said. Thank you for this outstanding expression of the Jewish soul.
3 |
Ben Finn - NYC,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
We who love israel know what that nation is, and your article re-emphasizes it berautifully. But will it make any difference to those who hate Israel and wish its destruction? Ah, were it only possible for fanatical hatred to be written away by an article.
4 |
Pearl Minsky, Staten Island, NY,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Bravo Israel.
5 |
Lew Coopersmith,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
"A window..." is the type of message that should be sent to all people not well informed about Israel - not just Jews! Especially Europeans where large Arab populations may bias knowledge of what Israel really is. Hopefully the AJC reaches out to these populations with this information. I will forward this blog as a peace message to acquaintances - both Jews and non-Jews.
6 |
William Michaels, Denver, CO USA,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Sadly, until we, as a People, come to value the protection and preservation of Jewish life as Job One and stop celebrating being so "kind and compassionate" to people who murder us, out of a romantic but ultimately smug & dystopian sense of moral superiority, we will continue to face a national life of perpetual mourning. That Israel does so many wonderful things for the world is great, but our Torah also instructs us to protect Jews first . . . . and that would include the soldiers who are kidnapped by our would-be annihilators. Lets stop so happily returning them home to plot more mayhem!
7 |
G. Adams, Washiington, DC,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Part 1. From 1947 (my fourth year) until 2005, when she died, my mother's best friend was a Jewish woman who lived out the best of what you write about. From her family, from other Jews I have known, and from my four visits in Israel, I can not and will not dispute what you have written. This is why I am so sad and distressed that the Jewish soul is not evident in the policies of the Israeli government toward the Palestinians. The occupation treats each Palestinian as though he or she were the worst of the lot. Just as Bush's invasion of Iraq created thousands of would-be terrorists,
8 |
G. Adams, Washiington, DC,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Part 2. the occupation policies provoke hate and violence among many who would otherwise not succumb to these evils. The government and the populace must find the courage of Rabin again and accept the risk involved in sincerely and realistically working toward a two-state solution. Over the long term, the Israeli people will suffer less than they do under present policies. The first step must be to vacate the settlements that are contrary even to Israeli law.
9 |
M. Lisner, Tel Aviv,
Monday Nov 24, 2008
Thank you Mr. Harris for bringing attention to Israel's many altruistic activities. As a participant in the Ethiopia trip, I was honored to be a part of this humanitarian experience and thankful for being given this opportunity by Israel. As a student at one of the participating universities, I look forward to more opportunities to represent Israel in this capacity.
10 |
ELIEZER MESHULAM - LAKEWOOD, NJ USA,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
BS"D
Most of what you said in this article is so true about our Holy Nation. And, I appreciate your positive perspective. For my family and me, however, who are planning aliyah, BE"H next year, we know that the views that you've expressed regarding the current government in Israel are far from correct. You said that Israel has a "robust democracy, cutting-edge innovation, thriving arts, astonishing diversity, and no-holds-barred debate." We take serious issue with the characterization of Israel's government as a robust democracy. Debate is stifled by the ruling class & the media.
11 |
Marc Ginsburg,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
If Americans had this spirit and sense of benevolence, we'd withstand any crisis, as have the Israelis. And, as a matter of fact, they do. As much as its been beaten down by a consumerist, money-driven culture, our present hardships are reviving the sense of higher purpose we share with our friends and allies across the sea in Israel. I sincerely hope and pray that our two nations can once and for all bring about an end to that supreme act of barbarity and savagery--war.
12 |
Philip Brogadir, Williamsville, NY,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
Some fine and necessary insights into aspects of Israeli society. However, I'm confused by and resent Harris's waxing enthusiastic about the release of Samir Kuntar, and with a college degree in hand, to boot! I fail to appreciate this exercise as an indication of the goodness, or love of life, or tikun olam of Israelis. If accurate,it may rather be indicative of misplaced, even twisted thinking and behavior and I would think that those who hate the nation and its people revel in its naivete and distorted values. Certainly Kuntar does but I don't know why the same appears to be true of Harris.
13 |
Paul Winter,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
For all the truth in David Harris' article, a couple of points are missing. When Samir Kuntar receives a hero's welcome - and congratulations from Abu Mazen, Israel's "peace partner" - to the silence of democracies, NGOs and bleeding hearts like Am Nasty, all of Israel's good deeds count for nil. When no Mohammedan decries Kuntar's deed, we have a right to question that peaceful creed. Shame on Israel's "friends" for not condemning Kuntar and his supporters, shame on Islam for the pride it takes in a child killer and shame on Jews who think that our goodness will influence those who hate us.
14 |
George, Denver, Colorado,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
To #12, respectfully, I thnk you missed the point Harris was making about Samir Kuntar. He certainly wasn't "waxing enthusiastic" about a vicious terrorist's release. Rather, he was contrasting Hezbollah's murder of the two Israeli soldiers, Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev, with Israel's treatment of Kuntar, without making an editorial comment on whether the "so-called swap," as he called it, was worth it in the first place.
15 |
Kad : Germany,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
Great Article,
the media in Europe is very Anti-Israel because of Europe's growing muslim population they are terribly afraid of a backlash from fanatic muslims here.In a last survey over 50% of Germans thought that Israel and the Us were the main obsticles to peace in the entire world.Iran is a strong partner of Germany and the trade millions with each other every year.The Jewish state can only depend on Hashem. The jew will overcome once again.
16 |
koluwo simon peter,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
Israel will always remain loved by those who are for the light and for Adonai. many may hope bad for Israel, but Adonai will be Israel,s guide, protector for ever, so, those who feel bad for Israel will find themselves fighting Adonai, and should count themselves faillers becuase Adonai is more powerful and loves Israel more, even although many may not see the good acts of Israel, the good Adonai sees and hears to Israel,s call, and will punish those who have misunderstood or mistreated her people. Long Live Israel, long live His people. Amen.
17 |
Barbara Parsons Bainbridge, GA., USA,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
Israel has many supporters even in South Georgia, USA, and I will always have a heart for her people. We owe Israel so much, for our reoligions, the records they ekpt and for above all teaching the true meaning of nationalism. I look to Israel as a great example as a people who have borne great sorrows and have ascended above those trials to become a united nation. As long as people like me live, Israel will alwyas have friends in America. God bless you.
18 |
Edwin, Tanzania,
Tuesday Nov 25, 2008
I was a member of the MPH class some 8 years ago at Hebrew University in Jerusalem. Coming from Tanzania, my impressions of Israel were very negative and I expected to arrive in a war zone with bombs going off all of the time. My family and friends thought I was crazy to go. After a short time in Jerusalem, I was amazed to find a prospering, innovative country. I remain eternally grateful to Israel for giving me the opportunity to learn about public health from some amazing professors in an amazing country. Thank you Mr. Harris for shedding light on this wonderful program
19 |
Chaim - Israel,
Wednesday Nov 26, 2008
We need much more of a zest for helping Israel. It is fine to want to help the world. However, the world won't help Israel when we need it. First we need to help ourselves. We need to stop hurting ourselves in obvious ways such as arming and freeing terrorists and handing over parcels of our tiny Homeland to our sworn existential foes. We need to stop electing politicians who hurt Israel by perverse appeasment and corruption. Our primary zest must be for our own land and people. Without that, we will have nothing to give.
20 |
Tatiana, Russia,
Wednesday Nov 26, 2008
I was a student in the MPH program in Jerusalem 15 years ago. Coming from Russia, I was impressed to see how so many Russian Jews came to Israel and were quickly integrated. I was also really impressed by the warmth with which I was received by Israel. I now work for an NGO that adresses the growing problem of Tuberculous in Russia. I remain thankful to Israel for giving me the public health tools to help people on a large scale. Also, when I hear people speaking badly about Israel or unfairly singling her out, I share my experience with them.
21 |
Edie Chicago Illinois USA,
Wednesday Nov 26, 2008
Just came back from our seventh trip to Israel and couldn't agree with you more! Standing at sunset in the Negev at the rim of the Machtesh not only did I feel that sense of history of the world but of the pristine beauty and undaunted majesty that is the soul of Israel.
22 |
Gábor Fränkl Budapest, Hungary,
Thursday Nov 27, 2008
Mr. Harris, I know all these things, naturally,but the world's mass media enterprises brought a though-ou strategic decision to intentionally suppress these info[s]. Just consider that distasteful shame of a country, Spain, where the TVE [TelevisionEspana] deliberatly refused to air the film its crew has taken in Hadassa Hospital.Shame and disgust! Or you can see how those two paragons of journalism: BBC and CNN (both are third rate organs imo) distorts and manipulates everything which even remotely has to do with Israel. This is the "press" in Britain, Europe, elsewhere. No censorship please!
23 |
Nat israel,
Thursday Nov 27, 2008
Unfortunately Israelis tend to act as a family only in times of danger. When there is peace family kinship seems to disappear behind formalities and routine. Not to mention splits vis a vis religion e.g. hareidim, modern religious, reform , shas, hassidim, etc.
Gone is the accept me as I am, help me when I fall because we are one family.
24 |
SB, Bangalore, India,
Friday Nov 28, 2008
I've always admired Israel and Jews for this attitude. This article sums up everything very well. However, what I found rather disturbing was the "Dhimmitude' thinking when it comes to people of the like of Kuntar. My country, India, already has suffered too much because of such an attitude. Don't go down that route.
Love from India.
25 |
Cark F USA,
Friday Nov 28, 2008
If these events in India don't show us Jews and the non Jewish (Christians) that Islam has declared WW3 ..then we don't remember our 4000 years of Jewish history The Pogromchiks are still out there. Today, it's Jihadists from Islam...faceless and nationless, but supported furtivley by Arabian nations. There must be a new way to fight this evil religion. We must look into the "soul" of the Islamic extremist.
26 |
Jesse, Israel,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
I was also a participant in the trip to Ethiopia a few months ago. It was my first experience in the third worlld and the whole thing was pretty overwhelming. Although what we did only seemed like a drop in the bucket, it was still nice to do something. Being able to be ambassadors for Israel was a real honor. We were all very grateful for the opportunity by the Israeli government to be able to give back. We are already talking about our next trip.
27 |
Solomon, Kenya,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
I was a member of this year's MPH class in Jerusalem. Being able to spend a year in Jerusalem was a truly unforgetable experience. We had the opportunity to travel around Israel and see the many historic sights that make Israel so special. On a more personal level we were invited to an AJC dinner by David Harris. It was a wonderful evening that was truly appreciated by all. I (along with my classmates I am sure) have a new found appreciation for the thriving country that is Israel and I look forward to the day when I will be able to return.
28 |
Dolf, Ghana,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
I had the opportunity to meet Mr. Harris on several occasions last year as a participant in the MPH program. The opportunity to study for a year with all expenses paid was to good to give up. I am the director of a hospital back in Ghana and I must admit that I knew very little about Israel. Not only did I learn a lot in the program, but I was able to get a good feel for Israel. Being there during 4 terrorist attacks made us realize that Israel is a country that many seek to destroy. Also seeing the young soldiers with the huge responsibility of pretecting Israel was very humbling.
29 |
K. Odiette, Nigeria,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
Great piece Mr. Harris. I had the pleasure of meeting you last year while I was in Israel. I was given the opportunity to get my MPH in Jerusalem. I left my wife and small child in Nigeria to do the program and it was a really hard decision. My family thought I was crazy to come, but Hebrew U has a very good reputation and the scholarship was very enticing. I ganed a real appreciation for Israel.Plus, being able to see where the Lord Jesus Christ ended his life was truly amazing. Thank you to Israel for this amazing experience and may the Lord continue to protect you
30 |
Rich, Israel,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
I was a participant on the Ethiopia trip this Succot (along with your son). Although some of my friends went to Europe, I decided that as a medical student, going to work for NGOs in Ethiopia would be much more worthwhile. The Ethiopians were very appreciative of the fact that we were there and we were only to happy to help. Spending Yom Kippur in a small synagogue in the capital Addis was pretty amazing. I was always proud to say that I was from Israel when I was asked. I have heard tha Israel plans many medical missions to Africa and I would love to go back.
31 |
Boortcher Guy USA,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
Yes it's wonderful that Jewish people help to "heal the world"..and what do we get ..a kick in tuchas for it! After all. the Jewish people invented charity! Whatever we do good the Pogromchicks are still out there. We Jews are always walking on banana peels! Let someone else be "chosen" for a while!
32 |
Yehuda Neumark, Israel,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
Thank you Mr. Harris for including the International Masters of Public Health Program at Hebrew University-Hadassah as one of the examples of Israel engaging the world and making it better. As Program Director, I take great pride in providing our trainees with a window onto the heritage and history of our people and land, alongside comprehensive training in public health. The above comments by some of our nearly 700 graduates in 85 countries across the globe indeed attests to our "small country making an outsized difference on the world stage in advancing the quality of life".
33 |
Yuval Joffe, Israel / New York / Costa rica,
Saturday Nov 29, 2008
Thak you so much sir, for saying what you just did. Yes, just like everyone ad everywhere we're not perfect... My own vision is to tell a Good Night Story to every child in the world, since children are the ones who will make a changed world for the better. This huge adventure is alive and getting all over in every language. It's an international group of people... and started in an Israely heart and mind in Israel.
Thanks Mr. Harris fro all your kind words. I hope many people around the world will read it and think.
Yuval Joffe
Visionary and founder of GoodNightStory
34 |
Darren White,
Sunday Nov 30, 2008
There's a basic unhealthy thinking in the Israeli psyche that being benevolent to our enemies will somehow change them or show the world how good we Jews are. Needles to say that dislike of Israel is not changed by allowing the enemy to give us a first blow. The same unhealthy thinking manifested itself when Israel in 1993 when the Yom Kippur war was launched by the Egyptians and Syrians, avoided pre-emptive strike against the two enemy armies. Golda Meir wanted to show the world that Israelis are peace-loving people...
35 |
Mark, Philadelphia,
Sunday Nov 30, 2008
It is wonderful to see the profound impact such programs have had on non-Israelis throughout the world. I am not Israeli, nor am I Jewish, but when I see tragedies like that which occurred in Mumbai yesterday, it reinforces my belief that a strong Jewish state is necessary. Jews seem to be hunted wherever they go--the least they deserve is a homeland where they are safe. Long live Israel!
36 |
Jonas, Ethiopia,
Monday Dec 01, 2008
I had the unique opportunity of studying water conservation in Israel in the 1990's. Coming from Ethiopia, I was very eager to see how a country without water could thrive. We were invited by Moshav and spent three months in Israel (mainly in the negev) learning the newest techniques and seeing cutting edge technology. I was hopeful to implement some of these things in Ethiopia and have done so in some parts of the country. Israel's generosity and attempt to help my country will not be forgotten.
37 |
Pamarty Venkataramana,India.,
Wednesday Dec 03, 2008
Truly said,There is no substitue for a first-hand look and being aware of the strength of a land,especially a divine country such as Israel...I have always admired the Self-respect and Pride of the Nation which is a great friend of India...Looking forward to visiting soon.GOD BLESS THE BLESSED PEOPLE OF ISRAEL!
38 |
Isabella Coalillo Kates, Toronto, canada,
Sunday Dec 28, 2008
Your words broadcast a very enlightened perspective . I daily wonder why Israel and its actions continue to be maligned and picked on by the international community. I guess the seeds of racism have healthy rhizomes----let us keep words like yours circulating.
39 |
M. Sperling - Seattle USA,
Saturday Jan 10, 2009
Am I wrong to believe the best thing for the Arabs in the Gaza would be to be liberated from the Terrorist Organization Humas? Is that not chosing life? Is that not the most compassionate solution? If one were an Arab child in Gaza, would not the most compassionate and loving solution for that child's future would be to grow up in a state not ruled by terrorist with some hope for the future?
Compassion is union with the suffering of others. The best solution for Israel is also the best solution for the children of Gaza - putting an end to the reign of terror of Humas.
40 |
Noreen Australia,
Saturday Jan 10, 2009
Thank you Mr Harris please keep on writing the world must see.if its in front of them daily.
41 |
esther - sydney australia,
Monday Jan 12, 2009
your writing is powerful - hope you're sending your articles to world leaders (comments included) so they get the true story.
|
Top Rated Posts
Tags:Blogroll |