Tuesday Apr 21, 2009

At Durban II: A brief encounter with three clowns

Posted by Zach Novetsky
Comments: 19
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

Although Monday's opening events at the Durban II conference are now old news, let me tell you what you did not see because Monday was a day that brought a brief encounter between three "clowns" (i.e. Ahmadinejad and the courageous French students).

It all began at 8AM this morning. After a quick breakfast, a large group of EUJS students hurried to the Plaza de Nations to protest the Second Durban Debacle before it officially began. Arriving at the Plaza, we took hold of our signs, placed a black piece of masking tape over our mouths, and stood in unity - silently.

PHOTO: Our siltent protest

Then, two Darfurian passerbys asked to partake in our protest (the woman wore a hijab), placed the tape over their mouths, and stood with us - silently. And we continued to stand there, in silence, in front of a building whose ambassadors have for too long remained silent when confronted by the world's pressing issues.

PHOTO: The two Darfurians who joined us

As the UN ambassadors and cameramen walked by, I can assure you that they felt our presence. It was impossible for them not to see our posters' graphic depictions of the serious human rights violations around the world; problems that must be addressed, that must be solved, but which can only be resolved by an effective United Nations. This was our message, and we think it resonated within the bones of the many ambassadors who passed by us, the same ambassadors who walked out in protest of Ahmadinejad's farcical address.

Empowered by our early morning success, the day continued. After several meetings attempting to prepare us for what was to come, I walked with a small group of new acquaintances to get my UN accreditation. Before I even entered the tent, I was face-to-face with a massive poster protesting the Gaza war in Arabic letters: the Iranian NGOs had arrived.

As I approached the man with the sign, ready for a verbal confrontation, I was interrupted by a group of Muslim Darfurian refugees. Prior to my uttering a single word, the Darfurians began emotively interrogating the Iranian man: "You say you care about the Palestinians because they are Muslim, but why are you silent when it comes to the genocide in Darfur! We are all humans!"

The Darfurian refugee, whose entire family was massacred because of the state-sanctioned genocide, told everyone around him his heartrending tale about the plight of the Darfurians, while he continued to lambast the Iranian man for his myopic beliefs. He told us that just the other day, a refugee camp was sprayed with poison disguised as insecticide, killing children and forcing pregnant women to have spontaneous abortions. There are few times in my life that I have been so affected by a personal story.

Walking from the accreditation tent to the UN compound where our first meeting would be held, I heard the wail of sirens. Turning the corner, a convoy of police cars, motorcycles, and vans with police bearing heavy weaponry rapidly approached. And then I saw it: the Iranian flag on top of the black Mercedes.

The group I was with froze and watched as the President of Iran passed by (inches away!), waving, smiling, and, ironically, holding up the peace sign. He did not know which group we represented because if he did, I am sure he would have offered a flagrantly different hand-gesture. Appalled that my eyes just gazed upon this man, I continued to walk.

To my relief, in the distance, I caught sight of Ahmadinejad's antithesis, Elie Wiesel, whose image calmed my boiling blood. He was walking side-by-side with Alan Dershowitz. After introducing myself to the both of them, I found out that they would be joining the European Union of Jewish Students (EUJS) delegation in the NGO conference room for Ahmadinejad's speech.

PHOTO: Elie Weisel and I

Together, we entered the massive UN room and saw many other NGOs, including the Neteuri Karta (Dovid Weiss, the head of this sickening organization, received his accreditation from the Iranian Republic of course), several Iranian NGOs, and others representing Palestinian causes. We took our seats all over the room, stationing ourselves in front of the large television screen at the front of the room. Then, we waited.

PHOTO: The NGO room where we waited

The screen turned on just as Ahmadinejad was being introduced (with the title of "His Excellency"). The introducer comically mispronounced his name, which was received by a loud roar of laughter within our NGO room. After this blunder, we were told that the speech would be translated on the UN headphones...but there was no sound. Ahmadinejad continued to speak, and yet there was no sound...no translation. Alan Dershowitz, in the back row of the NGO room, stood up and boldly announced that it was in violation of our rights as UN delegates not to have a translation. Before the UN guards rushed to silence him, the French Jewish students dressed as clowns took over the television screen, causing the guards to rush into the other conference room. The Jewish members in the NGO room (and other non-Jewish NGO groups appalled by Ahmadinejad's presence) rose in applause, laughter, chants, but most importantly, unity as we together staged the first walk-out!

The NGO conference room was in disarray and over the commotion, Ahmadinejad's insidious voice could not be heard. As we left the NGO room and made our way over to the main conference room, the official ambassadors began following suit, led by the honorable French Ambassador Jean-Baptiste Mattei.

And so it was, the first day of the Second Durban Debacle.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   Rabbi David Hoffman, ex-Cape Town, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
Well done Zach! Back at Durban I ,I approached the SA Boards of Deputies,national and regional, to meet the self-styled revolutionaries with some placards and demonstrations of our own, but this was simply unthinkable for such a conservative leadership. I brought the masses to meet the most anti-zionist Israeli, the very dense Uri Davis, and hundreds realized they were dealing with a paper tiger. The difference between Durban I and Durban II was the effective locally based organization of European Jewry and human rights activists. In South Africa that lesson was only mastered in the aftermath
2  |   am olam canada, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
Full commendations to you and your cohorts as your courageous presence and voices offered an utterly necessary protest AT this 'conference' that has marked itself for history as the most egregious inversion, to date, of the rights and values it professes both to espouse and advocate; and thereby offering an historical retrospective - enforcing the world to witness, and so NEVER to forget, that Durban I and II have been nothing more than another Nuremberg Rally where in Geneva (!) - once a true sanctuary for the oppressed - humanity, Jewish humanity, was silenced.
3  |   Roger H Frost, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
God tells us to be the light of truth
4  |   Sandra Israel, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
Shalom Zak, I want to congratulate you, and your fellow student, for confronting Ahmadinejad in such a fitting way. Your comments regarding the Darfurian Muslims was very touching, and I hope that one day their terrible experiences will be taken very seriously and something positive is done for the survivors.
5  |   Debby Skokie, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
Zach, we are so proud that you are there as a student representing all of our sentiments back home. You stand there today representing 6,000,000 of our people who no longer have a voice. They died because of the same kind of hatred that you are there apposing. You are making your family, your University and your people proud.
6  |   adena kirstein, nyc, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
so proud of you back at NYU - keep up the amazing advocacy and great reporting.
7  |   A. Meller, Geneva, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
As a Swiss ashamed of my cowardly government for hosting Ahmadinejjad, I wholeheartedly commend your and the EUJS wonderful work in Geneva
8  |   Sandy Novetsky, Tuesday Apr 21, 2009
Zach,Initially dad and I were apprehensive and extremely worried about your attending this conference...after reading your blogs and understanding how important it is to stand up for human rights and especially those of Israel and the jewish people...all we can say is how lucky we are to have a son like you who cares and always follows through in his strong convitions and constant desire to help make this world a better place!!!!You make us sooooo proud and we love who and what you have become as an adult!!!!!!Thanks for making us feel that we were standing beside you in these critical situatio
9  |   Morton Friedman Lanham, MD, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
Don't waste your time looking for any of this in the American 'Free Press', it is not on their agenda. I doubt if you will find any mention of it in many UK rags either. Will any of the french papers acknowledge it? And that is the problem, it seems to require a bomb to get attention in our 'literate', 'liberal', world.
10  |   Rachel from Skokie, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
keep up the good work, we need more people like you.
11  |   Helene, Skokie, IL, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
Your writing brings alive the drama and frustration of the events that are happening at this conference.. Zach, your strong, intelligent voice makes you a credit to the EUJS, NYU and your fellow Jews.
12  |   eduardo novo sp brazil, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
the beast is back, the people need to be warned,and to denounce to denounce,never again,need to be the word of order on the diaspora and israel. long live to our students.
13  |   Caryn Lincolnwood,IL, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
Zach, God bless you for all you are doing for Klal Yisroel. Your parents and grandparents must be so proud of all your efforts to bring peace to this crazy world. Keep up your amazing reports, it makes us feel as though we are there along with you. Stay safe, and keep on letting the world know the real truth.Your voice is being heard all over the world.
14  |   Jaime XMarrano Barcelona, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
You look up at that first picture and you see a group of neat and well dressed good looking people demonstrating. Not that rent-a-mob screaming and screeching hysterically,on the other side,that puts placards with the nastiest antisemitic and anti-Israeli messages.Israeli's and Jews world-wide have the ability and brains to counter this sick propaganda that is constantly aimed at Israel.
15  |   Lucy, Boston, MA, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
Kol hakavod for being there and protesting. Just to remind you that their V sign - is for victory, not peace.
16  |   Valko, UK, Wednesday Apr 22, 2009
Zach, I know its hard to leave in a country at war, but is it not appropriate Iranians to fights for human rights in Iran, israelis for human rights in Israel, and Sudanese for human rights in Darfur?
17  |   Carol & Steve - Framingham, MA, Friday Apr 24, 2009
Zach - Yasher Koach! You are our future -
18  |   Daniel Orvomaa - Univ. of Helsinki, Thursday Apr 30, 2009
Great job Zach! Don't know if you remember but we did meet briefly last Monday. I just finished my own report for a paper back home and you wouldn't believe how similar it was to yours! unfortunately so few will ever hear about all this, and by all this I don't mean only the events at Durban, I mean Darfur, Iran and everything that's seriously wrong with the world today. I'm grateful for the whole experience, although it left me feeling more sad than victorious. Keep up the good work, next year in Jerusalem!
19  |   Fro, New Zealand, Friday May 01, 2009
Lone voices joining each other make up a power to be reckoned with in the face of blatant UN sanctioned 'injustice' and 'racism'. Well done. You and your family are blessed in history. Thank you.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
Your Blog/Website
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

At Durban II

Zach is a member of the European Union of Jewish Student's delegation sent to the United Nations' 2009 World Conference on Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia, and Other Intolerance - dubbed Durban II after the 2001 World Conference on Racism in Durban, South Africa - which is taking place April 20-25 in Geneva, Switzerland. Zach will be blogging for JPost about the conference as the event unfolds. 

Zach is currently a junior at New York University, majoring in Philosophy and minoring in Religious Studies, with intentions of attending law school. On campus, he is involved in Muslim-Jewish interfaith activities with Hillel, and is the 2009 Winner of the PANIM: Aaron Goldman Young Jewish Activist Award. Before college, Zach attended Yeshivat Eretz HaTzvi in Katamon, Jerusalem.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. World opinion: who cares?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Glen A. Fritz
    Tuesday Nov 17, 2009
  2. Mr. President, bring the troops home
    Posted in Koch's Comments by Ed Koch
    Thursday Nov 19, 2009
  3. Interfaith dialogue - naïve or necessary?
    Posted in Guest Blog by Ruth Wasserman
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  4. Who will take care of my fruit trees?
    Posted in Making Aliyah by Jonathan Feldstein
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009
  5. Our base is broader
    Posted in Green-Lined by Yisrael Medad
    Sunday Nov 22, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Joey B.: Zach: why should it come as a surprise to you that the U.N. so despises Israel? It, like Europe in general, has for years and will continue to do so. Know this for sure, however, that there are many Christian students who, while not Jewish, are still strongly pro-Israel. In fact, it is the Christians in the U.S., especially in the southern U.S., that continue to defend Israel and her right to exist. Let it be known that while Jewish complacency may exist on American college campuses, we Christians who believe in Israel will never relent our support. The God of Abraham lives! Shalom.
Fro, New Zealand: Lone voices joining each other make up a power to be reckoned with in the face of blatant UN sanctioned 'injustice' and 'racism'. Well done. You and your family are blessed in history. Thank you.
Daniel Orvomaa - Univ. of Helsinki: Great job Zach! Don't know if you remember but we did meet briefly last Monday. I just finished my own report for a paper back home and you wouldn't believe how similar it was to yours! unfortunately so few will ever hear about all this, and by all this I don't mean only the events at Durban, I mean Darfur, Iran and everything that's seriously wrong with the world today. I'm grateful for the whole experience, although it left me feeling more sad than victorious. Keep up the good work, next year in Jerusalem!