Wednesday Apr 09, 2008

Conservative Currents: Judaism and equality - or lack thereof

Posted by Rabbi Avi Novis-Deutsch
Comments: 6
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

The days of Passover command us to remember the story of the Exodus. One of the most fundamental messages of the Exodus is the idea that a nation has decided that "freedom" can take precedence over life itself. In fact, halakha tells us that maintaining our freedom to remain Jews is one of the very few cases in which we must be willing to give up our lives.

In the past, freedom of religion, in the sense of conducting rituals, was left to a small, elite group and the role of the religious leadership was crucial - that was the reality when man entered the modern age.

In that age, Judaism and other religions became more centered on the individual, and hence allowed for the demand for greater involvement in religious thinking and ritual. Nonetheless, even after organized Judaism underwent its first stage of reform, it remained very rabbi-oriented, and the role played by lay members of the religious community was limited. They were restricted to the audience, whose job it was to sit and listen. Children, for the most part, were not even allowed in the sanctuary, and a heavy, holy atmosphere prevailed.

Mitzvot were also traditionally incumbent only on adult males, meaning that the freedom to be a fully participating member of the community was denied to half of the population.

In the 21st century, many of us see it as the responsibility of Judaism to find a way that will allow everyone to participate in the ritual. To be sure, this is a challenge that is not without its difficulties, but that does not mean that it's not worth the effort. At my congregation Mayanot, we have always strived toward such a model. Our congregation was founded as an egalitarian community, and we have always worked to make it possible for every member - and visitor - to be an active participant.

Part of the process involves getting word out that everyone is welcome at our services. At Purim this year, we attracted more than 150 non-members to our Megillah-reading and celebration, and during the High Holidays, we generally draw a similar number, although often different people.

We work to enlarge the circle of people who are involved in leading services and reading Torah. We try to create meaningful activities for children of all ages, special services for very young children, and in addition, we are now working on increasing the participation and roles of children and youth in the main sanctuary services.

Also crucial to the Mayanot ethos is the creation of platforms for children with special needs, so that they too can be equal participants in all activities for children and youth, as well as in the adult services. Mayanot, it is always worth repeating, is fully open to anyone, regardless of gender, sexual orientation, level of observance, or socio-economic status. That is the Mayanot approach to freedom.

Nothing in our community is limited to a "chosen" group; everything is available to everyone, and we are actively doing our best to make this a reality. Therefore, I invite you to take some time before the Seder night to consider whether you think there are ways in which people may be prevented from full and equal participation within the community, and help to remove this obstacle in order to increase egalitarian involvement in synagogue life and ritual.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Denise, Thursday Apr 10, 2008
What prevents equal participation is the orthodox brainwashing that 1) women don't have the brains for Torah study and reading, 2) that if they do have such intelligence they damage the apparently fragile kavod (self-esteem) of the Jewish male tzibbur, and 3) that Jewish males are incapable of the kavanah at worship to discipline their libido. None of this uptight mentality is evident at non-orthodox congregations.
2  |  Pinchas, Tsfat, Thursday Apr 10, 2008
Judaism is NOT about equality. Its about each Jew fulfilling their particular role as the Torah requires. A man's responsibilities differ from that of a woman. A child's from that of an adult. A Kohen's from a Levi, or a Yisrael. No one is better or worse, but they are definitely different. Mixing and confusing these different roles and responsibilities is NOT a good thing and is not what HaSh-m wants of us. He knows, for example, that not only are the sexes different physically, but emotionally and psychologically as well. To ignore that is just foolishness and is NOT Torah Judaism.
3  |  Norb, Friday Apr 11, 2008
That's all well and good so long as you don't compromise with the tenets of Judaism. But unfortunately you do. If I was you the first thing that I would do before preaching to others is to change my name from Deutsch.
4  |  Jack, Saturday Apr 12, 2008
How can you possibly pretend to speak for Judaism when you write such an grossly ignorant statment such as "Mitzvot were also traditionally incumbent only on adult males." Women are obligated in every negative commandment and nearly all postiive commandements, save for a handful. What are you talking about?
5  |  Yoni, New York, Sunday Apr 13, 2008
"That is the Mayanot approach to freedom." i.e. not the Jewish approach: "Let my people go, so they may serve me" -Hashem Freedom in the Torah means to be bound to Torah and mitzvos, not freedom in the contemporary political sense.
6  |  carlos sanchez, port huron michigan june 22 2008, Sunday Jun 22, 2008
If we read the lords word with understanding, then are eyes can be opened to his turth.not by some mans word but by the word of the Father. He is the prosser of the heaves and the earth.The Exodus story was giving us a look at how the Father is going to take his people back from the hands of the enamie.Which is satan who decived eve in the garden of eden.Bcause there was many nations who followed mose.JESUS was in the garden to he is the tree of life.John 14-6 Jesus says im the way the turth and life no man comes to the Father but by me. HE is the lamb promised from GOD to his ppl.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Conservative Currents Rabbi Avi Novis Deutsch of the Schechter Rabbinical Seminary and Rabbis for Human Rights exegete examines Jewish matters.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Top Rated Posts

Most Commented Posts

  1. Israeli Arabs need new leadership
    Posted in The Weekly Portion by MK Dr. Ephraim Sneh
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  2. It's the Palestinians' loss
    Posted in Window on Israel by Ira Sharkansky
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  3. Israel's 'Wild West' tendencies
    Posted in Center Field by Gil Troy
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008
  4. No place for political objectors
    Posted in Point / Counterpoint by Edwin Bennatan
    Sunday Oct 12, 2008

Recent Comments

Chris_B: Sal (10), Sorry but that is NOT racism. There are definitely issues with how converts are treated in Israel, but as far as I know any race of convert gets the same suspicious treatment.
Jacob Maasland, Schoonhoven ,Holland: as a non Jew living for 8 years in Jerusalem, I wanted ti learn about Judaism and a friend introduced me in the Concervative Center of Judaism, Agron Street. Isend a lot of time there, did severel studies, and 6 years an evening class about Talmud. I learnd a lot about Judaism and myself. I was always very welcome. it was a great time. Thanks you
carlos sanchez, port huron michigan june 22 2008: If we read the lords word with understanding, then are eyes can be opened to his turth.not by some mans word but by the word of the Father. He is the prosser of the heaves and the earth.The Exodus story was giving us a look at how the Father is going to take his people back from the hands of the enamie.Which is satan who decived eve in the garden of eden.Bcause there was many nations who followed mose.JESUS was in the garden to he is the tree of life.John 14-6 Jesus says im the way the turth and life no man comes to the Father but by me. HE is the lamb promised from GOD to his ppl.