Thursday Oct 02, 2008

Generation Bubelah: What IS it about religion?

Posted by Cynthia Blair Kane
Comments: 7
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

"I go to bible study," a new friend of mine said to me the other day while sitting at my kitchen table. "I love Jesus Christ." He said, slouching back, taking a sip of a beer.

I looked over to him.

"Why? Why do you love Jesus Christ?"

"Because he's my man. I mean he's helped me out so much in my life. I just love him."

I'm watching my friend, who has only been my friend for about a week, and I hide whatever weird reaction I am having to all of this by saying, "oh."

"What?"

"Nothing," I say, spreading another piece of cheese on a cracker.

"I know I don't follow the bible in a strict sense. I drink, smoke, and I like the ladies, but I love Jesus Christ. I just love him."

These words, "I love Jesus Christ," gave me flashbacks to the JesusCamp documentary that gave me nightmares for days.

Sometimes, religion scares me. All fanatics in all religions scare me. I wanted to pull out the bumper sticker: God, please protect me from your followers and hold it in front of him to create a line of defense.

"What? Does that bother you?" He asked me. "Do you hate me because I'm not Jewish?" He had found out I was Jewish only an hour before we began this conversation.

"No, I don't hate anyone because they're not Jewish."

"You know now, because I know you're Jewish, the more I talk with you, the more you look it."
And I'm supposed to respond how?

"So were your parents religious?"

"Yes," he says, "we read the bible every night. And every Friday when I would have plans to go out after dinner, my mother would always read the bible a little bit longer than the other nights. She told me it wasn't true, but it was. You're like the third Jew I've ever met." He says.

To which I could have responded by saying, "you're the first Jesus Christ superfan I've met outside of America. But instead I said, "It's because there aren't many Jews around here, anymore."

"Yeah, there aren't many Jews where I'm from in Scotland, I guess Europe in general."

So we talk for a while and as much as his passion and wanting to preach the gospel puts my tummy funny, we find the idea of religion being more of an individual choice rather than an obligation in common.

"Just because I drink and go home with girls doesn't mean I shouldn't be considered a Protestant."

"Right," I say, "and just because I don't study the Torah doesn't mean I'm not a good Jew."

"You don't study the Torah?"

"No."

"Have you ever?"

"I went to Hebrew and Sunday school when I was younger."

"And that counts?"

Realizing what I thought we had in common would be enough to let the Jesus Camp images go, it wasn't.

It wasn't that he wasn't Jewish, it was the look in his eye when he spoke about Jesus Christ. The way he said his name made me want to run for the hills. The repetition of the phrase, "I love Jesus Christ" reminded me of poetry class when I was a freshman in college. We were studying the Griots, and we talked about the use of repetition in their storytelling. What made the pieces so powerful was this sort of monotonous tone of repetition. This repetition of the phrase, I love Jesus Christ, seemed to cloud my friends eyes as he spoke; he looked in a trance.

Call me crazy, but for the first time I no longer felt like talking about religion, or discussing the idea of religious identity. Most people I talk with about religion are not religious, but this was a different story. It was the first time I felt someone's religion push up against mine. And it honestly felt like he thought his religion was better. What was strange for me was that I've never thought my religion better than anyone else's just, different. And though I was trying to find what was common between our views, he focused on the differences, and overlooked his contradictions to the gospel.

"So you're going to marry a Protestant?" I ask.

"Yes. I want a nice, sweet girl. I know Jews marry outside of their religion but I don't want that."

Was that supposed to be a stab?

"Not all Jews marry outside of the religion, actually the majority don't. It's still not a widely accepted thing to do in the religious world."

He took a sip of his beer.

"I just don't think I could be with someone who didn't love Jesus Christ like I do."

Why did he keep saying it? It was like by praising him, all his daily doings, that don't coincide with the gospel, would be overlooked.

Maybe other people would have felt threatened so they would argue, and try to push his values, etc down; however, I was in shock. Shocked because of the change in his demeanor once we began talking about religion.

"I want to preach the gospel," he said, "or I know that's what I should be doing."

And all I wanted to do was drop the topic completely. So when he asked, "do you want to come outside with me while I smoke? And talk more about religion?" I declined.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |  Matthew Joseph Chicago IL, Thursday Oct 02, 2008
Cynthia, I apologize for that man and most christians just like any religion, are just follwers and nothing more but that is about most things they do in life. The true meaning in Yeshua that gets lost in translation, to forgive which is true but if you keep stumbling on the same virtue, are you really trying to change, and let it be a surprise to all christians and religous fanatics that everyone gets judged for there deeds not there beliefs. If I beleive I am a good person but in a reality am not that will be part of there judgement and fanatics are just that.GD bless and Peace Alway Matthew
2  |  Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ, Monday Oct 06, 2008
Hi, Cynthia, it sounds like your friend has a very immature way of thinking about G-d and religion--perhaps that will evolve. However, it might be worth thinking about the mitzvah in the Shema--You shall love the L-rd your G-d with all your heart, with all your soul, and all of your resources. Perhaps you would benefit from trying to make that a constant part of your life. Of course, the real question is how one translates the emotion into action. Best wishes, Shalom
3  |  Odesa, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
Jewish and Christian cults, are not really that much different. Why they are, so often at odds with each other? Both are irracional, based on mithology and tradition. If I pray tonight to the Great Maple Tree...will I be wrong or sinfull? Dont think so.
4  |  Shalom, Cherry Hill, NJ, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
Hi, Odesa, you might want to educate yourself before demonstrating your bias and ignorance in public. One example, in the Bible (Old Testament) G-d commands all Jewish men to gather three times annually in Jerusalem, and guarantees their border security. There is no jewish tradition or history of his guarantee not working when this command was obeyed. As Jews are famous for remembering our history, how do you explain this, and what person would have given such a guarantee in writing?
5  |  Yonaton, Beer Sheva Israel, Tuesday Oct 07, 2008
Cynthia, In every religion, it doesn't matter which one, the new converts are the most radical. This is a normal phase. You can find the most radical Orthodox Jews among Baal Teshuva. I would suggest not to judge this man as many blog commenters have, but to actually document his "religious journey" for the next couple years. You will probably find that he will either "temper" his judgement towards people outside his faith, or find a wiser way to effectively communicate his beliefs in an unoffensive manner. As a journalist, it would be interesting if you could document religious phases.
6  |  corinne de Souza, Hove, UK, Friday Oct 17, 2008
Hi Cynthia Greetings from a rather lapsed Roman Catholic on the South coast of Britain. This guy wanted to 'preach' ?! He was in your kitchen, for goodness sakes. As I understand it, good manners dictate the 'preacher' is invited to do so. So, let's check out the chap: he smokes (that's OK - so do I);is rude; uses the most dated language I have heard in years; is a jerk; has no sense of humour. Tell him to go walk on water . . . but I bet the 'moderator' will not let this one through. Political correctness and all that. very best wishes Corinne
7  |  ora, Monday Nov 10, 2008
halarious---and i know what u mean...do go out more with guys like that--at least that way there r more chances u will NOT marry any of them but stick to a "nice jewish boy" again-halariously written
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Generation Bubelah A mid-20s American perspective on Judaism, assimilation, relationships and travel by Cynthia Blair Kane.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. Israel's actions are lawful and commendable
    Posted in Double Standard Watch by Alan M. Dershowitz
    Sunday Jan 04, 2009
  2. To all you "embarrassed" Jews
    Posted in Israel Stories by Jeremy Cardash
    Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
  3. "We are Hamas"
    Posted in The Warped Mirror by Petra Marquardt-Bigman
    Sunday Jan 04, 2009
  4. No plans to leave Ashkelon
    Posted in Living with Rockets by Ashkelon
    Wednesday Dec 31, 2008
  5. Averaging one grad per hour
    Posted in Living with Rockets by Ashkelon
    Tuesday Jan 06, 2009

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Jan, Australia: Shakespeare wondered if a rose would be as sweet with another name. Labelling had impact even then. But it was Adam who gave the animals names. How do we differentiate between an elephant and a mouse unless we label them? English precise differentiating now contains some 998,751 labels. Perhaps your problem is that 6 labels is not enough....what if say you had 20? And what if you attached something to 'Jew'. A guy a train station in Denmark said he was Italian-American so I was Danish Swedish Welsh Anglo-adopted-Jew Irish-illegitimate Australian, to prove the nonsense of labels!
Pearl at the Ca Coast, USA: Ms.Kane, I believe you_unwittingly_express your generation's (yes I dare to generalize, for this venue's purposes) "post-hypnotic" condition of what I term victimhood-vindication. Oh, yes indeed, you are 'boxed-in': entrapped inside your well-travelled (by the understandably fear and fury-driven females preceding your generation who numbly saw "you" off triumphally) universe of self-liberation(?) May you live long, write and read wide; juxtapose history and herstory...deeply enough to begin to discern your ancestors' correlation between fear and wisdom. In summary, may Experience finally l
Matthew Joseph, Chicago IL US: Oh my poor girl,this is the product of your generation and the one just before and one after you. Its what I like to call "I want it now for nothing generation". Also this is what the secularist want conformism, they are easier to control and manipulate. The Era of the freethinker and independance from what you call labeling is dead and buried. Plus when non-jew say things like that is because your really the first jew they have spoken to, be flattered also one thing to get you through dont sweat the small stuff.G-d bless and peace always in Yeshua.Matthew Joseph