|
Sunday Feb 22, 2009
Army Life: Religion in the IDF Posted by D.B.
Comments: 9
BlogCentral would like to welcome a new contributor to the Army Life blog: D.B. He was born and raised in Virginia, USA, and graduated from The College of William & Mary in Virginia in '07 with a degree in Government (Political Science). In September of 2007, D.B. made aliyah and is currently serving as a combat soldier in the Israeli Army, Golani infantry brigade. I studied in a Jewish seminary (yeshiva) a few years back, and at the time I was just beginning to consider the idea of serving in the IDF. This particular yeshiva is a "charedi" institution - essentially ultra-orthodox. Charedi yeshivas are generally not very 'Zionistic', and their opinion of young men serving in an army instead of spending all day, every day, studying Torah is fairly low. So, when I volunteered to a rabbi that I was interested in the IDF, the response wasn't warm, to say the least. The rhetoric thrown around was that the IDF is a "bad place for religious Jews." They liked to say that it's hard to be religious there, that it's hard to keep your level of faith, and that there are too many bad influences. At the time, I didn't have any other source of information. I didn't know what it's like to be an Orthodox Jew in the army, so I just took it for what it was worth: hyper-religious Jerusalemites judging what they had no experience in in the first place. I didn't know what to think, but I assumed that they were being slightly dramatic. And now I know just how wrong they were. I have become even more observant of Torah law in the army. I pray three times a day, as required in Judaism, I eat kosher without exception, and I celebrate all the holidays and cultural events to the max. It's just so easy to be religious in the army. We wake up in the morning, do a gun safety check, and then we are promptly given nearly an hour for the morning prayers. It's either pray or clean the rooms...Easy choice. Shabbat and the holidays, as well, are just kind of thrown in your face. For example, for Shabbat the entire base eats a festive and special meal together on Friday night. In the beginning we say the kiddush, a sanctification of the sabbath day, with the entire base standing with heads covered in the Jewish fashion. We all say amen together, and inevitably hundreds of soldiers are singing and dancing to Jewish songs. There's also a dvar Torah, or a saying from the Torah - similar to a sermon, but usually a highly specific and interesting tidbit on an aspect of a Bible story. In fact, the army is such a good place for religious people that I have actually wondered if the secular soldiers are often uncomfortable or offended. We say prayers together, we have to listen to a religious sermon from a rabbi, there is a large synagogue in the middle of the base, the meals are mandatory, and the commanders made it very clear to not disturb the Shabbat observant crowd - i.e., electronics playing music, excessive use of the lights, and so on. I'm constantly surprised at the religiosity of this organization.
1 |
Ex-Golanchik, London,
Sunday Feb 22, 2009
The only bad thing about religion in the army is the kiddush wine. Tastes like glue.
I don't recall any discomfort or offence on the part of the secular soldiers. When I served in Golani in the early 90's (as a secular Jew), helping our religious friends with their kit while they prayed was just part of the routine, we didn't even think about it. And they were gracious towards us too - they'd volunteer for things after they'd finished praying, to give others a break. And naturally the Christian soldier always went home for Xmas and Easter!
You're doing a great thing there D.B. Kol hakavod!
2 |
Drew, NYC,
Sunday Feb 22, 2009
All Kiddish wine tastes like glue, Golanchik.
3 |
Rabbi Ben Packer Chapel Hill, NC,
Sunday Feb 22, 2009
Dear DB, I'm glad its going so well for you thus far. Just know that it gets alot harder when you get to kav. Also, you're in Golani and that's just about the best place to be in the entire army for a religious soldier.
I too was very impressed with the army's attitude toward Judaism during basic training. That attitude got progressively worse until the point that most of my fellow soldiers (and I) ended up not extending our time in the army directly because of our constant mistreatment for being religious Jews
Nonetheles, I wish you continued success from a fellow combat soldier from VA.
4 |
Delano, Carmichael, CA, USA,
Monday Feb 23, 2009
Good to learn your Army experience. It answered several questions that I've had. There's a huge difference between religion for the sake of religion or tradition and loving what the religion is all about. It could be the basis of a relationship with the G-d of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. When I was in the US Army I attended a few base chapel services. The 'fare' was purely liberalism--pablum. You would avoid the finest restaurant in NYC if the entire menu was 'corn dogs' in various flavors of sugar syrup--you would be appalled--irate. Quickly my Army life became 100 percent devoid of religion!
5 |
Avrohom - Israel,
Monday Feb 23, 2009
Of course there are very divergent experineces. I was unable to adhere to halachot of shmita, Shabbat and was ridculed by officers for being religous and because I would not partake in utter nonsense that occupied the time of others in my platoon. The kitchen at my base was treif and we could see people using our vessels for things that were explicitly and unarguable not kosher. So, while there are good reasons to be in the IDF and in some circumstances the IDF is the right choice for some people, the IDF is a difficult place for Torah-observent men and women. Not all need to be in IDF.
6 |
Avi, Ohio,
Monday Feb 23, 2009
D.B., I would be interested in talking to you about your experiences. I am also from Virginia, also graduated from W&M (but in '98). Became religiously observant 7 yrs ago. I am looking to make aliyah with my wife and kids in the next 2-4 years and may need to be involved to some extent with the IDF as a doctor. Email address: avsheili@yahoo.com
7 |
John Lawless,
Thursday Feb 26, 2009
Let me first say up front, "I am a Gentile." Now that is out of the way I can speak. I pray that Adoniah that one who created and sustains all things will bless you for your committment in the IDF. I remember Moses was in the army. Joshua was the army. David was in the army. I read in both Greek and Hebrew but Hebrew is my favorite. I know so little compared to those of God's chosen people. Our world is very secular and it will continue to be hard to stay faithful. As God blessed his people in the 1967 Six Day War I pray he will bless you. Shalom...a Gentile
8 |
Johnny,
Wednesday Apr 01, 2009
Since when are active soldiers allowed to write blogs? No too long ago it would have been forbidden, and with good reason.
And since when do soldiers only one year into their service feel they have enough perspective or experience to make wide, sweeping generalizations? The best soldiers in my experience are the ones that shut up and listen, unless they are in a spokesman unit.
These guys deserve a pat on the back, and should feel free to share their experiences with the media, but only after they are released.
9 |
Matis Monsey, New York,
Wednesday Jul 15, 2009
dumb comments about Kiddush wine
anyhoo why are Christians in the Israeli army?
|
Top Rated Posts
Tags:Blogroll |