Why the Orthodox make aliyah - the true story

The Jerusalem Post recently published an article entitled Why Do The Orthodox Make Aliyah, in which Yizhar Hess, executive director and CEO of the Masorti (conservative) Movement gave attempted to answer that question, despite the fact that he himself is not Orthodox. According to Hess, Orthodox people are encouraged to move to Israel because the religious institutions are Orthodox. For example, only Orthodox conversions and marriages are accepted by the state.

As an Orthodox person, I have two major problems with Hess's explanation. Neither I nor any of the olim I know came to Israel because Orthodox rabbis are officially recognized, and just because someone is Orthodox doesn't mean that he or she identifies with the religious status quo in Israel.

The truth is inconvenient in Israel too

Growing up, I was always taught to care about the environment. Going green is definitely a part of American popular culture. As a child, I watched "Captain Planet," a television show about a superhero who foiled the plots of polluters. "Litterbug" was the last thing you wanted to be called on the playground. The local government required that families separate paper, plastic and glass when they took out the trash. Everyone knows what the "recycle" symbol looks like, because they went to Earth Day assemblies in school.

Thanksgiving is not my holiday

This past Thursday was Thanksgiving in America. I started thinking about what Thanksgiving is all about while I was working at my part-time job, rather than having the weekend off. Growing up, the fourth Thursday in November meant two things to me: waking up early to watch the parade on TV, and getting ready to bargain-shop the next day.

Some years, my sister and I would go to see the latest blockbuster movie. If I was celebrating with my mother's side of the family, we'd get together in the evening for dinner at our favorite deli in Manhattan. If I was celebrating with my father's side, we'd go to my grandmother's house to eat a more traditional Thanksgiving meal in the early afternoon - that was catered by our favorite deli in New Jersey.

The constant threat of uni strikes

For the past three years, university students in Israel have not been able to complete their degrees uninterrupted.

In 2006, there was the Second Lebanon War, in which many students, who also serve as reserve soldiers, fought. In October of that year, the Ministry of Education and the Treasury formed the Shochat Committee, which was meant to find a cure for Israeli higher education's numerous ailments. When the Committee recommended that tuition be raised in 2007, the National Union of Israeli Students called a strike. Students around the country blockaded the entrances to university campuses, and even those who opposed the strike were not able to get to class. Last year, senior professors did not teach until February, demanding a raise in their salaries and better working conditions. Israeli students had three semesters: one in which only junior professors taught, one for classes taught by senior professors, and one with both. The third semester ended in August, cutting into students' summer vacation.

Deciding on a college path

Flashback to eleventh grade: All around me, my classmates panicked, going on college visits around the country, while I stuck with the few that were close to home (Penn, Princeton, Columbia and Rutgers). In twelfth grade, while my friends wrote essay after essay on "Why I want to study at [insert school-name here]," I applied to four schools (see list above), all of which, even the Ivy Leagues, I considered back-up plans. My college advisor didn't know what to do with me; how could such a dedicated student be so lazy when it came to applying to college?

About this blog

Majoring in Aliyah Lahav Harkov studies political science and communications at Bar-Ilan University. She made aliyah in 2005 and served 2 years in Sherut Leumi [national service]. She is excited to share her experiences as a student olah, and hopes that her stories will inspire others to make aliyah and get their higher education in Israel.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Peter,USA: The video was awesome. I liked it. I would like to share it with others. If anyone wants to share their personal feelings just visit http://www.lastnightwas.com & post their last night experience.
NY David: Ahhh the internet how it will change things!!!!!!!
Gimme a Break: "Life is too short to spend time with all of this negativity and hate sharing." Charmie, Dear, I'm not the one who bought the extra Q-Tips to clean out my ears after listening on one knee to Rush Limbaugh and Mark Levin. That's you, my dear.