Sunday Nov 01, 2009

Window on Israel: Why the stalemate?

Posted by Ira Sharkansky
Comments: 14
BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Decrease text sizeDecrease text size
Increase text sizeIncrease text size

Headline in Friday's Ha'aretz:  "Abu Mazen [Mahmoud Abbas] is losing hope: 'I sense that Netanyahu has not changed since 1996'"
 
A headline on an inside page in the same edition: "Paralysis at the summit of coordination between the government and the territories." That story goes on to say that things are not happening in the policy to advance "economic peace" on account of the failure of Israeli government to make appointments to key positions in the program.
 
Elsewhere in the news we hear that negotiations about freeing Gilad Schalit are moving at the speed of a crippled snail. International donors are complaining that Gazans are still living amid the rubble because Israel will not open the borders to the supplies and equipment that their contributions will provide.
 
Let me offer explanations for these disparate items, summed up in some pithy epigrams:

  • There is no free lunch in international relations
  • You screw us, we'll screw you
  • "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you" may be a spiritual ideal, but the more popular norm in international politics is the simpler "Do unto others."

Israel can live well enough without solving the problem of Palestine. The Palestinians may pride themselves in their willingness to die for their national cause, but they have committed national suicide. There will be no Palestinian state as long as key factions persist with the dreams of turning back the clock to 1967, to 1947, or to the mid-19th century before Jews began coming to this area.
 
I perceive that Netanyahu has changed since 1996. He appears to be wiser, and more skilled in expressing what he demands as conditions for moving forward with a peace process.
 
Abu Mazen's problem is that he has not changed. From the information available to the public, I see no signs of flexibility in his position. No matter what Israel has offered, it is not enough.
 
Too bad the peace process seems to be stuck, despite its position high on the priority list of the Obama White House and European governments.
 
Several things beyond Palestinian stubbornness are contributing to the stalemate.
 
The Goldstone Report is one of them, and symbolizes a general condition. As Netanyahu has said, why should Israel be generous when international organizations and others distort reality, judge Israel so much more severely than they judge other countries, and are working to deny Israel the right to defend itself? When Abu Mazen works to keep the Goldstone Report on the agenda of international organizations, he provides Netanyahu yet another reason to just say "screw him."
 
Another major contributor to stalemate is Hamas. Its unrelenting refusal to recognize Israel's legitimacy, as well as its persistence in demanding the freedom of individuals seen in Israel as murderers makes it a doubtful partner for negotiations. Gaza represents about half of Palestine, and Hamas appears to be strong in the West Bank. Moreover, Hamas is only one of numerous Palestinian groups that push Abu Mazen to a hard line with Israel. Abu Mazen may be able to stay in power in Ramallah by demanding the Palestinian wish list, but why should Israel bother?
 
There is also the problem of Iran. Not only is it resisting international efforts to temper its nuclear aspirations, but it is a prominent influence on Hamas and Hizbullah, as well as Syria and Turkey.
 
Peace would be nice, but the prevailing sentiment is not to rely on the Palestinians, governments that find it convenient to express their support for a Palestinian state, and other governments that have trouble finding words sufficiently strong to boost Palestine and threaten Israel.

BOOKMARK or SHARE: technorati digg del.icio.us reddit newsvine facebook What's this?
Print  |  
Comments: Post your own comment
1  |   David US, Sunday Nov 01, 2009
Re 1) "Gazans living amid rubble - Israel will not open " TRUE. Re 2) "Israel can live well enough without solving the problem of Palestine.." FOR HOW LONG ?? Re 3) "Netanyahu has changed since 1996. He appears wiser...for moving forward with a peace process" FALSE. Same demagogue - moving backward. Re 4) "Several things are contributing to the stalemate.The Goldstone Report is one of them .." Goldstone has ZERO to do with the issue. Re 5) "why should Israel be generous.." Israel has been generous? :):) Re 6)"international organizations and others distort reality". HOW do YOU know that ??
2  |   Allen F USA, Sunday Nov 01, 2009
For 4000 years of Judasim, the first monotheistic religion, the Jewish people have gotten a kick in tuchas from the world. After all, we did the crime of giving God, The Ten Commandments, Jesus, and Allah to the world..(where did Islam get Allah..from the eskimos?). Thus Islam thinks it is the "New Chosen"..It can't stand the fact that Jews control Jerusalem..their third Holiest City. Mecca and Medina are not enough..I guess..but it begs the question..do the Jihadi Islamists want NY, Paris and London too?
3  |   Morton Friedman Lanham, MD, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Face reality, Talk of 'negotiations' is fruitless. Since Israel's resurrection in 1947, it has brought Oslo and an Intifada, Kassams from Gaza, SCUDS from Iraq, Katushyas from Lebanon, hudnas with egypt and Jordan (only a fool would call it Peace), continuous acts of war from UN signatories (in vilolation of the UN Charter). Perhaps Israel needs to apply the International principles of dhimmi, ghetto and shtetl, until such time as its sworn enemies beg for mercy. I have many non-violent suggestions, too many for the space given in this 'Talkback'.
4  |   Ricardo - USA, Monday Nov 02, 2009
I don't think that talking about a stalemate is appropriate at this time. The overwhelming hypocrisy from the muslim world as they are 'disturbing the peace' on a global scale proves that their talk is not only reliable, but criminal. Their constant hate speech and slander and human rights violations are not being dealt with. Why??? Because it is nurtured in their own countries by a program called Islam. 900,000,000 dollars was sent to gaza for human aid and what did we get. A goldstoner report and gazan stooges yelling 'death to Israel'. No accountability says the money should be refunded.
5  |   Enquiring mind, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Gaza also has borders with Egypt, are those borders closed or open? Something we cannot learn from the moribund (formerly mainstream) media. Gazans do a lot of whinging, but can they not leave, bring in supplies etc. from Egypt?
6  |   Colin Bradley DK, Monday Nov 02, 2009
This is a strange and not very coherent blog Ira. I hope you can clarify it a little. One of your salient points seems to be that any sort of peace process is going to take flexibility and willingness to compromise, yet at the same time you also seem to be saying that Israel doesn't need to show anything of the kind before Palestine does (presumably because you believe there's a huge credit built up in Israel's goodwill account from past negotiations) and then you seem to hint that even if Palestine does come up with something Israel can easily afford to ignore it anyway.
7  |   Colin Bradley DK, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Another point is the 'problem of Iran'. Excuse me? Is that the Palestinians responsibility to solve that problem? You really don't seem to have anything constructive to say at all. If any of this message is at all intended for the outside world then it seems it could be summed up in two words. "Screw you." This makes me rather sad. This is not the Israel I once knew.
8  |   Martin Munitz, USA, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Stop the settlement expansion and then see what happens. Withdraw from the settlements and then see what happens. You don't need this land and the only real purpose it serves is to fan the flames. Isreal needs to take this giant step.
9  |   Shlomo Israel, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Martin: Go to a high building, stand on the ledge, and take one giant step forward. A leap of faith, so be it. See what happens. You may even fly with it. For many, setlements are home. Part of the land of Israel that Jews have been praying for thousands of years for. Don't think for a minute that you can suggest that we who live in Israel do your bidding. As for the negotiations. Better to put them on hold than to progressively worsen our position through unilateral retreats. There are lots to talk about and better to keep the cards in our hands for now.
10  |   Eric Shorr, Israel, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Martin, the settlement expansion and settlers were withdrawn from Gaza and look what happened. I doubt that Palestinians really want peace.
11  |   R willer London, Monday Nov 02, 2009
Israel cannot hope to live indefinitely in a state of non-peace. Do you really want your children and grandchildren to live in anxiety and fear and for what? is there anyone who still believes that divine grant is a root of title to land? No system of law, national or international, accepts such an idiotic proposition. Perhaps I should consider moving out of my home in central London if a Druid says his Welsh ancestors were promised it by their creator. Give up the West Bank and the West will back you.
12  |   Bloodyscot Dallas, Texas, Monday Nov 02, 2009
There are many parts to this stalemate, first over half of Israel has given up on peace deal and now believe that removing Palestinian then settling the land is the only solution also many believe land is needed for foreign Jews. Second over half of people living in Gaza are children of refugees from Israel and own little or no land in Gaza, their main goal is to return to the land of their parents and grandparents, not a 2 state solution. Third is the main goal of the PA is keeping the W. Bank for a state of Palestine but they also have alot of refugees living in overcrowded camps.
13  |   Ray Saperstein, Baltimore, USA, Monday Nov 02, 2009
To Martim #8 - we've already seen what happens when Israel withdraws. In case you didn't notice, Israel withdrew from Southern Lebanon and Gaza. What did they get in return? More rockets. Why not direct some suggestions to the Palestinians? Stop the terrorism and then see what happens. Stop teaching your children to hate, and then see what happens. Stop the incitement, and then see what happens. Stop refusing to recognize Israel as a Jewish state, and then see what happens.
14  |   Chris USA, Tuesday Nov 03, 2009
Dear Ira, what does your grumbling accomplish? Can you turn one hair on your head gray with this pointless criticism? Solutions begin with the awareness of what is possible. You seem ignorant of the dangers facing Israel if it does nothing. Unlike the PA who have nothing to lose and everything to gain by doing nothing, Israel risks everything by its inaction. There is a clock ticking down the minutes of Israel's life. Will you save it? Will your blind criticism evaporate the enemies of Israel like smoke? I certainly hope so, because I see great anguish and suffering ahead if we do not change.
Add your comment remaining characters
Name and Location *

NOTE: Comments are moderated and will not appear on this blog, until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting.

For more information, please see our
Readers' Submission Policy.

E-mail * (will NOT be published)
Your Blog/Website
--------------------------------
* All fields are required

About this blog

Window on Israel Hebrew University Political Science professor evaluates the latest happenings in Israel.

Search this blog

Archives
Combined feed for all JPost.com blogs

Most Popular

  1. Arguments 'ad hominem' in defense of the Goldstone Report
    Posted in Double Standard Watch by Alan M. Dershowitz
    Thursday Feb 04, 2010
  2. A walk in the park with Obama
    Posted in Koch's Comments by Ed Koch
    Thursday Feb 04, 2010
  3. Rank hypocrisy and transparent double standards
    Posted in In the Trenches by David Harris
    Sunday Feb 07, 2010
  4. Hizbullah is not the IRA
    Posted in Levant in Focus by Tony Badran
    Thursday Feb 04, 2010
  5. China's ascendancy and what it means for the US
    Posted in Koch's Comments by Ed Koch
    Tuesday Feb 09, 2010

Top Rated Posts

Recent Comments

Jason - Atlanta, GA: "The United States is UNRWA's largest bilateral donor. In 2009, the United States provided over $267 million to UNRWA, including $116.2 million to its General Fund, $119.5 million to its West Bank/Gaza emergency programs, $30 million to emergency programs in Lebanon, and $2.2 million to assist other Palestinians in the region." For a country so far in debt, this is ridiculous. The US is in such deep debt, that China is pretty much signing all our checks, yet we continue to pay millions to the UNRWA. We are also over 50% funding for the UN in general. This has to stop.
P-ANT: MR. SHARANSKY,IN MY HUMBLE OPINION SIR,THE ROLE OF GOV. SHOULD BE TO PROTECT AND SERVE,AS EFFICIENTLY AS POSSIBLE,AS GOV. IS AN EXPENSE AND TAX AN IMPEDIMENT TO GROWTH,WHAT GOV. COULD KNOW THE NEEDS OF INDIVIDUALS BETTER THAN THE INDIVIDUALS,BIG GOV. BREEDS CORRUPTION.I`VE SEEN IT,THE BIGGER THE WORSE THE PROBLEM GETS,TRUST ME SIR I`VE NOTHING TO GAIN BY DECEIVING YOU,THE PROOF IS EVERYWHERE,HOW CAN YOU NOT SEE,YOUR AN INTELLIGENT GUY,PUT YOURSELVE ON THE OTHER SIDE OF OPINION FOR A DAY AND THEN RE-EVALUATE.WE MUST BE OBJECTIVE TO BE WISE.
P-ANT: IRA, AMERICA`S WEALTH CAME FROM MINIMISED GOV. AND TAXES,THE ABILITY FOR EVEN THE HUMBLIST OF PEOPLE TO SUCCEED LAY WITH THEIR OWN DESIRE OR VISION OF SUCCESS,WEALTH HAS MANY FORMS SIR,HIGHER TAX AND BIGGER GOV. RESULT IN MORE EFFORT TO ACHEIVE LESS,GOV. IS AN EXPENSE PUT ON PEOPLE,IF WE FAIL TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT,THEN YOU HAVE A NON-STARTER.THEIVES SIR THATS WHATS HAPPENING,BLINDED BY GREED AND POWER.HOWEVER AT LEAST WE REALIZE OUR SURVIVAL IS ONE MUTUAL BENEFIT,THAT WITHOUT ALLIED MILITARIES WE`D BE SURE TO DESTROY EVERYTHING.