|
Wednesday May 14, 2008
The Sephardi Perspective: The beautiful game Posted by Ashley Perry (Perez)
Comments: 15
I was invited to my first Israeli basketball game earlier in the week and I was curious to witness a live game and its accompanying atmosphere. Having been brought up in England, football (I refuse to use the word 'soccer' which is anyway a shortened version of Association Football) is the only sport that matters, however, I am always curious to experience any quintessentially Israeli events. In England and most of the world, 'Football is life'. As one English manager famously put it: "some people think football is a matter of life and death. I assure you, it's much more serious than that." In Israel, basketball is known as the Ashkenazi sport and football is known as the game of the Sephardim. For most of the early decades of the state of Israel, basketball was the quintessential sabra sport and it literally put Israel "on the map" in 1977 when Maccabi Tel Aviv won the European Cup for the first time. Although Israel qualified for the football World Cup, their first and only time reaching a major international tournament, qualifying for a tournament could not compete with actually winning and placing amongst the favorites on an annual basis. The Israeli 'elites' were attracted to the success of basketball which mimicked the 'new Jew' who could compete amongst the nations of the world. So during the early years of the state the football terraces were left mainly to Sephardim and those outside of the 'elites'. Many of the football teams were based in the poorer towns and neighborhoods and many of the players had grown up in the same streets and alleys as those that now paid to watch them play. Football has always been the great equalizer for the poorest communities around the world. When I trekked across parts of the African bush, whenever I would approach a village I would see boys and girls running after a pile of cloths wrapped up as a make-shift ball. The fact that the game can be played anywhere is the beauty of the game and the attraction for the working-classes. The likes of Eli Ohana, Haim Revivo and currently Yossi Benayoun have become heroes to their fans, but each grew up in poor Sephardi neighborhoods of Jerusalem, Ashdod and Dimona respectively. Players like Eyal Berkovic, because of their background, never attained the same status amongst the fans even though he matched their achievements. Even today, perusing the names of the players in the teams of the Israeli Premier league shows that Sephardim vastly outnumber the Ashkenazi Israelis. In basketball it is almost the complete opposite. Another answer to the different ethnic make-up between the two sports may be the passion that is expressed surrounding the sport. My experience at the basketball game was pleasant but it seemed to lack the edge that most football matches have. Although there were the typical drums being pounded and the fans chanting non-stop, there lacked that gladiatorial, intense and sometimes intimidating atmosphere that is like a drug for many. Football fans like almost no other have allegiances that sometimes outrank national or ethnic ties. In many places in Europe, your ties to your team are so extreme that you would sometimes literally die for your team. One's highs and lows are connected to the performance of your team and you genuinely feel a part of something. There have been reams of books and papers written on this subject because it because it appears to defy logic to those who have never experienced it. Joao Coelho, a Portuguese sociologist, notes that "it is fascinating, even though sometimes frightening, how a football team gains vast and complex social signification and symbolism which overtake the simple outcome of a sporting competition." Another sociologist HK Hognestad on the other hand, suggests that passionate football support parallels famed anthropologist Geertz's notion of deep play in that "symbolic pride is tied to support and football is therefore frequently made into 'a matter of honour'." This is perhaps the essence of the Sephardi attachment to football. For many whom felt discriminated against by the state and its apparatus, football was a good outlet for one's anger and passion. The chanting on the terraces at football involves an almost primal cry and tensions are let run amok against your opposing fans, hopefully only in a verbal manner. Although Israeli football fans are some of the least violent of all the European leagues, the passion they display is amongst the highest. A few seasons ago when their favorite player was about to be sold to another club, some Betar Jerusalem fans broke into a training session and temporarily abducted the player until the management agreed to stop the deal. In 2003, when Avi Nimni was sold by Maccabi Tel Aviv to Betar, a number of Maccabi fans turned up to games the following season wearing only black and refused to cheer the team until he returned to Maccabi. Over the years football has massively outranked basketball in overall popularity and the terraces will see people of every ethnic, social and even religious background. However, the atmosphere is still overwhelmingly Sephardi. The rhythmic darbouka, the Mizrahi songs and the constant chomping of garinim (sunflower seeds) coupled with the incredible passion makes it the stomping ground of Sephardim. I enjoyed my night at the basketball, but I felt somewhat out of place. Apart from not completely understanding the rules and why I should get excited about a basket that will probably happen again in half a minute, I missed the meaning and passion of the football terraces. Football is the game of the people, the passion and the flavor make the game attractive even to those who don't even follow the game. My wife, an Ashkenazi of American descent, used to come with me to football games but rarely even knew which way our team was kicking. However, she knew every song and would stand on her chair and scream at whoever she thought wasn't doing their job. The atmosphere just swept her up and she became an avid fan. This is the beauty of football and this is what makes it a 'Sephardi' sport in Israel.
1 | Yitzhaq Agadi, Great Neck, NY, Wednesday May 14, 2008
What's interesting is that the situation is almost reversed in America: the few people who actually play/follow soccer are upper-class white folk, while basketball courts are the domain of mostly low income, inner-city minorities.
2 | Pezza in London, Wednesday May 14, 2008
Excellent article. We should not be surprised that football, 'the beautiful game' where one can express themselves creatively; a game that promotes free thinking should be the sport of the Sephardim. Meanwhile Basketball a predictable, mundane and soulless sport should be the preference of the Ashkenazi. Art Imitating Life?
3 | Yellow Boy, Jerusalem, Wednesday May 14, 2008
Deary me Ashley, Shankley was Scotish, not English.
4 | Chas N-B London, Thursday May 15, 2008
This is one of the most interesting things I've ever read. I could read your words all day.
CNB
5 | Dan K, Jerusalem, Thursday May 15, 2008
Very interesting point about the high levels of passion, yet relatively low incidents of violence, which is a credit to Israeli football. English football has largely stamped hooliganism out of the game in recent years, which was critical following the dark years of the 80s. However, the English game's more recent clean cut image has often been at the expense of the passionate atmosphere previously associated with English football. As a result, some of English football's 'cathedrals', such as Old Trafford and Arsenal's Emirates have become more like quiet village churches...
6 | Chiquifru, Boston, MA, Thursday May 15, 2008
As a European of Sephardic origin and a football fan, it was interesting to learn the Sephardic roots of Israeli football although I must admit that I'm also a big fan of basketball and of Maccabi Tel Aviv. Your description reminds me of South Africa where blacks traditionally played football and whites played rugby. Football is the world's sport and it would be great if all Israelis, Sephardim and Ashkenazi alike, played the beautiful game which would make the Israeli national team formidable. By the way,I can't wait to see the development of Israel's young talent Gai Assulin and Ben Sahar.
7 | Ronny - Jerusalem, Thursday May 15, 2008
On the whole what you're saying is true about the past 35 years, but during the 1st 2 decades of Israel the Israeli football stars were actually Ashkenazi. Stelmach, Chodorov,Glazer,Speigler,Shpeigel,Feigenbaum,Rosen,Vissoker,Merimovitc and the list goes on. It was actuallly with squads of mainly Ashkenazim that Israel did well in the Asian games in 56 60 64 and 68, world cup of 70, and Olympic games of 68. Your analysis about Eyal Berkovic is wrong as well.What about rocket Ronnie Rosental who played in the same era (a few years before Eyal) and was very popular here.
8 | David Hakim Los Angeles, Thursday May 15, 2008
WHy do we have to differentiant between Sephardi and Ashkanazi all the time, I am Egyptian Jew and my wife is ROmanian we both love football and we are both passionate. There is no differences between sephardi, askanazi and mizrahi we are all jews.
9 | Scott, Haifa, Thursday May 15, 2008
Ashley - great article. To Ronny in Jerusalem, let me start of by saying "Rocket Ronny" was a best an average player who is not in the same class as those listed in the article. I had to watch his lazy butt every week at Spurs, and thought he was playing in a league that he just wasn't good enough for. He may have been popular here, and with goalkeepers of opposing teams, but not with the White Hart Lane faithfull....
10 | Proud Sephardi - USA, Thursday May 15, 2008
To Pezza #2. Very well said! I couldn't agree with your more.
11 | Not The Other Herb, Siberia, Thursday May 15, 2008
Right you are, #1. In America, basketball is considered a Sephardi sport, or something like that. (Sorry! The devil made me say it.)
12 | Sharona Jerusalem, Friday May 16, 2008
Being from America I don't like soccer at all. Boring boring boring. That is why the fans have to go wild. Amazingly there is very little fan violence at American football games. People get hurt at soccer games. The recent chanpionship game here is a perfect example. They could have just done the penalty shots and gone home early. Basketball is boring too. You just need the last 5 minutes. Soccer has become the "opiate" of the masses.
13 | Ben Azai, London, Friday May 16, 2008
Reply to Pezza in London. In London all Jews, Ashkenazim and Sephardim, are liklely to support football more than basketball. There goes your theory. In the most Ashkenazic country, Germany, football is the national sport, the same as in Spain, the original home of Sephardim.
14 | Joe Feld, London, Friday May 16, 2008
An enjoyable article. A refreshing change from politics and angst. It's interesting to note that cricket and baseball have not made it in Israel. Cricket possibly because it takes too long and slow for most Israelis, baseball because it's too American and Israel is part of the European sports world. Has rugby made it to Israel?
15 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Saturday May 24, 2008
...guys, we're all Jews. Don't frame your dislike for some sport on 'the other' just because you don't like them anyway. I love basketball: it is accessible, fast-paced, and requires skill in order to excel, just like any other sport. Many Sephardim AND Ashkenazim love it, too. I don't think any sport is really identifiable with either of the groups in America as much as we might like to think...
|
All Categories
Tags:Blogroll |