|
Monday Mar 10, 2008
The Sephardi Perspective: Reclaiming the Jewish word Posted by Ashley Perry (Perez)
Comments: 21
While we look forward to Purim, there are many other reasons that Adar is such a celebratory month. The third of Adar commemorates the completion of the Second Temple, the seventh is the hilula of Moses and the 28th of Adar is a Talmudic celebration to commemorate the rescinding of a Roman decree against ritual circumcision, Torah study and keeping the Shabbat. However, another important date is often overlooked that goes to the root of the 'People of the Book' in the modern era. Next week is the anniversary of the creation of the first printed and dated Hebrew book ever published with movable type on the 10th of Adar, Feb. 17, 1475. The book is a copy of Rashi's commentary of the Five Books of Moses. It was printed by Abraham ben Yitzhak ben Garton in Adar 5235 in the city of Reggio di Calabria, Italy. The sole copy of this book that still exists is kept in the Palatine Library in Parma, Italy. The method of type was called incunabula, which is a block-book printed from a single carved or sculpted wooden block for each page, made with individual pieces of cast metal movable type on a printing press, in the technology made famous by Johannes Gutenberg. Relatively little is known of Garton, although most historians claim that he was a Spanish Jew who had escaped to Italy because of the wave of anti-Jewish hatred asserting itself in the Iberian Peninsular. Reggio di Calabria had become a haven for those Jews who fled Spain firstly because of the anti-Jewish violence and then the Spanish Inquisition. Interestingly Garton used what has now become known as 'Rashi Script' which differs from other written forms of Hebrew. The type-set became known as Rashi Script because of this event; Rashi himself never used such a script. The script was known to be used by early Sephardi Jews and also became the type-set for Ladino, the language of the Iberian exiles. This book set the tone for a cultural, intellectual and Judaic revolution. While the bastion of Jewish civilization which had been Spain was being literally burnt at the stake, the printing press in Central Europe allowed the Ashkenazi world to rise in dominance. Many Iberian exiles took the printing press to the Ottoman Empire and other parts of the Mediterranean. However, this venture did not permeate the Arab world in significant numbers. The Arab world did not adopt a significant printing press for many centuries after Johannes Gutenberg first created the printed word. One reason is that the cursive nature of the Arabic script and certain of its other peculiarities made its adaptation to printing difficult. Another reason was the Western trend toward printing and the development of ornamental and sometimes elaborate type faces. In Islam, the drawing or depicting of human or animal forms was forbidden and writers and artists were forced to resort either to what has since come to be known as "arabesque" (designs based on strictly geometrical forms or patterns of leaves and flowers) or, very often, to calligraphy. This made writing the religiously preferred mode of copying texts. While Christian Europe was undergoing the Renaissance and the Reformation, the Arab world had already been in decline for a couple of centuries. The 15th century Reconquista of Spain by the Catholic monarchs was the final nail in the coffin. The disruption to the cycle of equity based on Ibn Khaldun's famous model of Asabiyyah (the rise and fall of civilizations) points to the decline being mainly due to political and economic factors. Tolerance of differing ideas and concepts had greatly reduced from the great Arab polemical debates at the turn of the millennium. This is perhaps best demonstrated by al-Ghazali's polemic work The Incoherence of the Philosophers. This decline also affected the Jews within Arab lands as they were faced with more intolerant neighbors. While colonialism brought with it a rebirth in the standards of education for many Jews in the Arab World, centuries of lagging standards meant many were behind their European brethren. The Alliance Israélite Universelle, an organization created to combine the ideals of self-defense and self-sufficiency through education and professional development among Jews, disconnected many Jews from their traditions which in turn made sure they played little part in a Jewish intellectual renaissance. Jewish printing presses from the Arab World during these centuries of decline were almost non-existent. This had a dramatic effect on the modern Jewish state. While religious life was largely unaffected due to the fact that large portions of the Sephardi service are sung or intoned in unison and thus had less use of printed prayer books, very few Jews of the Arab World had access to large compendiums of Jewish works. While there was a time where almost all of the great Jewish treatises were Sephardi, recent times have proven the opposite is true. Today we see that most of the recent well-known works of Judaica are of Ashkenazi origin. It is time for the great Sephardi mind to recapture their place in the Jewish world and not just in Halacha, where they have made inroads out of necessity. The great works of the Rambam, Ramban, Aboulafia, HaLevi and many others demonstrate that Sephardim have a rich history to rest on. The anniversary of the first Jewish printed book should be a good time of reflection for the Sephardim to share in the dissemination of the Jewish word.
1 | Mark, Tuesday Mar 11, 2008
Here, here -- provided it is done in the spirit of the Sephardi mesorah, pedagogical approach, and world-outlook, the proliferation of modern Sephardi publications would do much to enrich the Jewish world.
2 | Debra USA, Tuesday Mar 11, 2008
Amen! It's about time.
3 | Proud Sephardi - USA, Tuesday Mar 11, 2008
What has been lacking from Sephardi publications are accurate English translations of great Sephardi authors who wrote in Hebrew or Arabic. There are many books that have yet to be translated. Moreover, they need to be translated by Sephardim who do not have an Askhenazi/Ultra-orthodox bias (read: ARTSCROLL).
4 | James (part 2), Thursday Mar 13, 2008
However, halachic details are important in this difficult time. Instead of showing off "pride, it's better to learn from each other. There are plenty intermarriages among the Sephardim and Ashkenazim. Had any of the posters actually read the great Sephardic authors like RaMBaM, RIF, RAAVAD, or RaMBaN they would not find differences from much of the Ashkenazi/Ultra Orthodox bias. Only together we are one people and the author failed to write about that.
5 | Tova, Toronto Canada, Thursday Mar 13, 2008
Sephardi Jew & Ashkenaz Jew - Wrong.
We are one People. Ashkenaz adoped names & labelling of the Jewish People. Torah - One People. One Nation, One GOD. One Israel.
Young Israeli are not bothered by Sephardi or Ashkenaz as their parents. Also, Ashkenaz are much more assismalted. Which means the majority of Jews from Eastern Europe do have Christian roots.
Moses, David, Solomon, the Prophets, they are not Ashkenaz. Why do we cling to false naming of our people.
6 | Avram Piha, Thursday Mar 13, 2008
great piece Mr. Perry. Keep it up
7 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Friday Mar 14, 2008
Thank you! Intellectual leadership that isn't off-the-wall extremist within the Sephardi world has been sorely lacking for a long time now. Kudos to Ashley for pointing this out. Viva la revolucion!
8 | Serge, Montreal, Friday Mar 14, 2008
There are a number of strange assertions in this article. The idea that Sephardic services have a greater proportion that is to be sung in unison, for example, or rely less on printed books.
Perhaps Mr. Perry confuses American and Yekke Reform and Conservative services with traditional Ashkenazi services.
Perhaps Mr. Perry confuses North African and Middle Eastern Sephardic services with all Sephardic services -- see the long-standing Spanish and Portuguese prayer book, adopted over the last two centuries in the Shearith Israel congregations.
9 | Proud Sephardi - USA, Friday Mar 14, 2008
To James - #4. If you think that Rambam would not have found problems with "Ultra-orthodox" Jews then you are perhaps unaware that this same/similar strain of Judaism burnt his books in the 13th century. LIke in the past, these "ultra-orthodox" shun secular education and exposure or acknowledgement of the great philosophers of the past. Ask an ultra-orthodox Jew what the age of the world is - 5768 years or 3-4 billion years. Most cannot accept scientific proof that runs counter to the Talmud, etc. Just look what happened to the "Zoo rabbi".
10 | Mark Schwartz Tel Aviv, Saturday Mar 15, 2008
I must thank the Jerusalem Post for making these kind of articles available. Growing up soooo ashkenasi in Tulsa, Oklahoma, we studied precious little Sephardic history. Shame on my Hebrew and religious school! Now at age 54 I am a voracious reader about Jewish cultures other than mine now that I live in Israel.
Let's keep all our beautiful Jewish cultures alive! JPost, keep up the good work covering everything there is of interest in the Jewish world!
Thanks so much!
11 | Ashley Perry, Israel, Saturday Mar 15, 2008
Serge,
The Spanish and Portuguese way of praying is the exception that proves the rule. The S&P were Western and not from the Arab world and thus had access to an advanced printing press. Also, the S&P make up only a very few percentage of Sephardim worldwide.
What other strange assertions did I Make?
12 | Jonas Graversgaard, Denmark, Sunday Mar 16, 2008
The dinosaurs are a myth, they were dragons.
13 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Monday Mar 17, 2008
....re the S&P (um, actually, that sounds too much like the bond-rating/stock-index firm, so let's scratch that acronym) way of praying: when I'm in Istanbul on Shabbat, I've found that a similar or greater proportion of prayers were sung aloud in comparison with the Syrian synagogues in Brooklyn (who are well-known for their singing outside of prayer). This was not an isolated occurence, Ashley, and is a major reason why I love to visit that city. There is little difference today in terms of 'printed books': see for example the Siddurim published by Orot in Lakewood, the best there is, IMHO.
14 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Monday Mar 17, 2008
I also echo Mark Schwartz's comments: I learned more about Sephardi culture, custom and tradition in University than I ever learned at the Yeshivah of Flatbush or in my own communities institutions (summer camps, synagogues, etc)
15 | Proud Sephardi - USA, Wednesday Mar 19, 2008
To Eli B. - I recall that you questioned whether the Black Hat Ashkenazim had influenced the community in Brooklyn to become overly stringent. My question to you is - you yourself admit that you did not learn about Sephardi custom, culture, etc from your community - how can you say that this influence isn't present, without really understanding the development and history of Sephardi traditions in your own community?
16 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Friday Mar 21, 2008
...PS: clearly my comment was overreaching: I did not live in a vaccuum for 20+ years in Brooklyn. I do know that Sephardi heritage beyond what they brought with them from 19th Century Halab is seldom discussed or revelled in, as it should be. I encountered R Yehudah haLevi, the two Ibn Ezras, among others only when I took a course on the Jews in Medieval Spain at NYU. So when I said 'Sephardi' I meant 'Medieval Sephardim'. Obviously I know more than a wee bit about what my own community's customs are!
17 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Friday Mar 21, 2008
and I'm not saying the 'black hat' influence isn't around - clearly it is - but that this influence, precisely because it is so widespread among the more 'religious' types, and has inspired the sort of demagogue that is currently our most revered rabbi - you know of whom I speak - that this influence has ceased to be 'Ashkenazic' as such. This is not a recent occurrence: it has been building, I believe for a long time.
18 | Proud Sephardi - USA, Sunday Mar 23, 2008
Eli B. - yes I agree with all your points. Indeed, the Brooklyn community has changed since its beginnings and more so than ever since they marginalized the scion of your old community - you know of whom I speak (I think). Nevertheless, the movement away from your rich traditions was due to "outside" influences.
The problem isn't just with your community, however - it is the same with the worldwide Sephardic community. Moreover, in Israel, though our leadership proclaims to uphold "Sephardic Halacha", in every other way they acquiesce to the Ashkenazim who are truly in control.
19 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Wednesday Mar 26, 2008
I don't know how far they moved away from 'traditions' - there is little Ashkenazic about prayer, food, pizmonim, etc. There is still very much an aura of protectionism about those things, and let's not forget the edict against gerim: a purely Syrian invention which is far more conservative than anything the Ashkenazim have in place. What changed, I believe, are certain attitudes toward the halacha and the rabbinim who espoused it. There is too much deference to the rabbinate and too little actual thought about the halacha. (continued)
20 | Eli B. - Brooklyn, NY, Wednesday Mar 26, 2008
This is a historically Ashkenazic trait which I believe we have taken on, and has led to the emergence of . Today, it is clear to me, mainstream American Ashkenazim have more candid conversations about halacha, judaism, etc. more than the Aleppians have.
I do not know who the 'scion of the old community' is. Was he alive within my lifetime? Today, our most revered Rabbanim are of the Kassin family (Shaul, Yaakov, and of course Hacham Baruch). I'm assuming you aren't referring to any of them?
21 | Proud Sephardi - USA, Friday Mar 28, 2008
Eli B. - I agree with your points regarding food and liturgy, but the mentality of strictness and rigidity has been adopted from the Ashkenazim. Name a rabbi in the community who did not attend an Ashenazi Kolel/Yeshiva - post highschool. Even Porat Yosef in Israel is now modeled along Ashkenazi lines.
Here is an email I set up so we can communicate: jpostblog at gmail. I know the people you knos
|
All Categories
Tags:Blogroll |